Conciliation, conflict, or complementarity: Responses to three voices in the hinduism and science discourse
David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Ezio Di Nucci
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Zygon 47 (3):608-623 (2012)
Abstract This essay is a response to three review articles on two recently published books dealing with aspects of Hinduism and science: Jonathan Edelmann's Hindu Theology and Biology: The Bhāgavata Purāṇa and Contemporary Theory, and my own, Hindu Perspectives on Evolution: Darwin, Dharma and Design. The task set by the editor of Zygon for the three reviewers was broad: they could make specific critiques of the two books, or they could use them as starting points to engage in a broad discussion of Hinduism and science, or religion and science in general. In my response, I first provide a fairly detailed reply to David Gosling's many critiques of my book, and in the process call into question his Advaitic conciliation of Hinduism and science. Thomas Ellis's thesis of basic incompatibility between Hinduism and science is much closer to my own viewpoint. One of the main objectives of my book was to explain and illustrate this incompatibility with specific regard to Hindu and Darwinian perspectives on evolution. In this essay I provide a few examples in support of Ellis's incompatibility thesis, encompassing both epistemological and metaphysical dissonances. Finally, I reflect upon Varadaraja V. Raman's wide-ranging exposition on the all-encompassing nature of the Hindu tradition that readily accommodates both religious and scientific quests for knowledge. Raman uses the two books only as starting points for his own thoughts, without reference to my book. I confine myself, accordingly, to a brief critique of his complementarity approach to Hinduism and science, and of his radical inclusivism that enfolds basically all philosophical positions into the warm embrace of the Hindu tradition, including even the extreme antireligious materialism of the Cārvāka
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
Nancey C. Murphy (2006). Bodies and Souls, or Spirited Bodies? Cambridge University Press.
Debiprasad Chattopadhyaya (1959). Lokayata a Study in Ancient Indian Materialism. People's Pub. House.
Debiprasad Chattopadhyaya (1978). Science and Society in Ancient India. Monograph Collection (Matt - Pseudo).
Citations of this work BETA
Willem B. Drees (2013). Rich Religion and Science: AsIan Religions, Ian Barbour, and Much Else. Zygon 48 (4):853-858.
Similar books and articles
Jonathan B. Edelmann (2012). The Role of Hindu Theology in the Religion and Science Dialogue. Zygon 47 (3):624-642.
Varadaraja V. Raman (2012). Hinduism and Science: Some Reflections. Zygon 47 (3):549-574.
Mark W. Muesse (2003). Great World Religions, Hinduism. Teaching Co..
Jonathan B. Edelmann (2012). Hindu Theology and Biology: The Bhagavata Purana and Contemporary Theory. OUP Oxford.
Śrīrāma Goyala (2009). Fundamentals of Paurāṇika Hinduism. Kusumanjali Book World.
Eric R. Dorman (2011). Hinduism and Science: The State of the South Asian Science and Religion Discourse. Zygon 46 (3):593-619.
Patrick Harrigan, Ci Patmanātan̲ & Pa Kōpālakiruṣṇa Aiyar (eds.) (2003). 2nd World Hindu Conference, Souvenir: Glimpses of Hindu Heritage. Ministry of Hindu Religious Affairs.
David Frawley (1990). From the River of Heaven: Hindu and Vedic Knowledge for the Modern Age. Passage Press.
M. M. Agrawal (2002). Freedom of the Soul: A Post-Modern Understanding of Hinduism. Concept Pub. Co..
Nehemiah Nilakantha Sastri Goreh (2003). A Christian Response to the Hindu Philosophical Systems. Punthi Pustak.
David L. Gosling (2012). Science and the Hindu Tradition: Compatibility or Conflict? Zygon 47 (3):575-588.
Saral Jhingran (1989). Aspects of Hindu Morality. Motilal Banarsidass Publishers.
Added to index2012-08-24
Total downloads73 ( #54,956 of 1,790,069 )
Recent downloads (6 months)9 ( #93,512 of 1,790,069 )
How can I increase my downloads?