Mounce and Winch on Understanding (or Not Understanding) an Indigenous Society
Philosophical Investigations 35 (3-4):350-372 (2012)
| Abstract | Howard Mounce and Peter Winch both made novel and illuminating contributions to discussions about how, or whether, we can understand societies very different from our own – societies that would, these days, be referred to as “indigenous,”“tribal,”“traditional” or “small-scale.” This paper aims to elucidate some disagreements between Mounce and Winch while also critically engaging in the debate. The concepts of “practice” and “language-game” are considered in connection with magic-related activities among the Azande of north-central Africa, and Mounce's contention that the Azande's whole way of speaking about magic and witchcraft is “hardly intelligible” is examined. I challenge Mounce's interpretations of certain analogies that he uses, and propose that his argument relies on what is probably an underestimation of the degree to which magic and witchcraft are integral to Azande culture as a whole | |||||||||
| Keywords | No keywords specified (fix it) | |||||||||
| Categories | No categories specified (fix it) | |||||||||
| Options |
|
|||||||||
Download options| PhilPapers Archive |
Upload a copy of this paper Check publisher's policy on self-archival Papers currently archived: 5,672 |
| External links |
 |
| Through your library | Configure |
Similar books and articlesBerel Dov Lerner (1995). Understanding a (Secular) Primitive Society. Religious Studies 31 (3):303 - 309.
W. W. Sharrock & R. J. Anderson (1985). Iv. Understanding Peter Winch. Inquiry 28 (1-4):119 – 122.
Piero Pinzauti (2012). The Autonomy of Morality From Religion. The End of Religion and of Relativism. Howard Mounce on Peter Winch. Philosophical Investigations 35 (2):154-166.
Howard Mounce (2011). Winch and Anscombe on Ethics and Religion. Philosophical Investigations 34 (3):241-248.
H. O. Mounce (1988). Peter Winch, Trying to Make Sense, Basil Blackwell 1987, Pp. Viii + 213, Price £27.50. Philosophical Investigations 11 (3):236-244.
H. O. Mounce (1973). Understanding a Primitive Society. Philosophy 48 (186):347-.
Nigel Pleasants (2000). Winch and Wittgenstein on Understanding Ourselves Critically: Descriptive Not Metaphysical. Inquiry 43 (3):289 – 317.
Berel Dov Lerner (1995). Winch and Instrumental Pluralism. Philosophy of the Social Sciences 25 (2):180-191.
Kevin Schilbrack (2009). Rationality, Relativism, and Religion: A Reinterpretation of Peter Winch. Sophia 48 (4).
Olli Lagerspetz (2012). Peter Winch on Political Authority and Political Culture. Philosophical Investigations 35 (3-4):277-302.
H. O. Mounce (1967). Virtue and the Understanding. Analysis 28 (1):11 - 17.
Mikel Burley (2012). Reply to Howard Mounce. Philosophical Investigations 35 (3-4):377-379.
Michael Weston (2010). Forms of Our Life: Wittgenstein and the Later Heidegger. Philosophical Investigations 33 (3):245-265.
H. O. Mounce (2012). Response to Mikel Burley. Philosophical Investigations 35 (3-4):373-376.
D. Z. Phillips (1991). Waiting for the Vanishing Shed. Philosophy and Theology 5 (4):333-353.
Analytics
Monthly downloads |
Added to index2012-04-20Total downloads6 ( #145,546 of 549,067 )Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #63,185 of 549,067 )How can I increase my downloads? |
My notes
Discussion
