Philosophical Psychology 13 (1):77-95 (2000)
|Abstract||Jerry Fodor and Ernest Lepore [(1992) Holism: a shopper's guide, Oxford: Blackwell; (1996) in R. McCauley (Ed.) The Churchlands and their critics , Cambridge: Blackwell] have launched a powerful attack against Paul Churchland's connectionist theory of semantics--also known as state space semantics. In one part of their attack, Fodor and Lepore argue that the architectural and functional idiosyncrasies of connectionist networks preclude us from articulating a notion of conceptual similarity applicable to state space semantics. Aarre Laakso and Gary Cottrell [(1998) in M. A. Gernsbacher & S. Derry (Eds) Proceedings of the 20th Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society, Mahway, NJ: Erlbaum; Philosophical Psychology ] 13, 47-76 have recently run a number of simulations on simple feedforward networks and applied a mathematical technique for measuring conceptual similarity in the representational spaces of those networks. Laakso and Cottrell contend that their results decisively refute Fodor and Lepore's criticisms. Paul Churchland [(1998) Journal of Philosophy, 95, 5-32 ] goes further. He uses Laakso and Cottrell's neurosimulations to argue that connectionism does furnish us with all we need to construct a robust theory of semantics and a robust theory of translation. In this paper I shall argue that whereas Laakso and Cottrell's neurocomputational results may provide us with a rebuttal of Fodor and Lepore's argument, Churchland's conclusion is far too optimistic. In particular, I shall try to show that connectionist modelling does not provide any objective criterion for achieving a one-to-one accurate translational mapping across networks|
|Keywords||Mind Science Semantics Space Churchland, P Fodor, J Lepore, E|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
|Through your library||Configure|
Similar books and articles
Jesse J. Prinz (2006). Empiricism and State-Space Semantics. In Brian L Keeley (ed.), Paul Churchland. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Aarre Laakso & Garrison W. Cottrell (2006). Churchland on Connectionism. In Brian L. Keeley (ed.), Paul Churchland. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Francisco Calvo Garzón (2003). Connectionist Semantics and the Collateral Information Challenge. Mind and Language 18 (1):77-94.
Timothy Schroeder (2007). A Recipe for Concept Similarity. Mind and Language 22 (1):68-91.
Jerry A. Fodor & Ernest LePore (1993). Precis of Holism: A Shopper's Guide. [REVIEW] Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 53 (3):637-682.
Christopher Gauker (1993). Holism Without Meaning: A Critical Review of Fodor and Lepore's Holism: A Shopper's Guide. Philosophical Psychology 6 (4):441-49.
Paul M. Churchland (1998). Conceptual Similarity Across Sensory and Neural Diversity: The Fodor/Lepore Challenge Answered. Journal Of Philosophy 95 (1):5-32.
Jerry A. Fodor & Ernest Lepore (1999). All at Sea in Semantic Space: Churchland on Meaning Similarity. Journal Of Philosophy 96 (8):381-403.
Aarre Laakso & Garrison W. Cottrell (2000). Content and Cluster Analysis: Assessing Representational Similarity in Neural Systems. Philosophical Psychology 13 (1):47-76.
Francisco Calvo Garzon (2000). State Space Semantics and Conceptual Similarity: Reply to Churchland. Philosophical Psychology 13 (1):77-96.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads31 ( #44,807 of 722,776 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #60,541 of 722,776 )
How can I increase my downloads?