David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Ezio Di Nucci
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Phronesis 56 (3):193-203 (2011)
It has often been claimed that (i) Aristotle's expression `protasis' means `premiss' in syllogistic contexts and (ii) cannot refer to the conclusion of a syllogism in the Prior Analytics . In this essay we produce and defend a counter-example to these two claims. We argue that (i) the basic meaning of the expression is `proposition' and (ii) while it is often used to refer to the premisses of a syllogism, in Prior Analytics 1.29, 45b4-8 it is used to refer to the conclusion of a syllogism. In our view, the best explanation of Aristotle's use of the expression `protasis' is that it means proposition throughout but is frequently used without change of meaning (in certain specific contexts) to refer to the premisses from which a conclusion follows. In Prior Analytics 1.29, 45b4-8 he uses `protasis' to refer to the conclusion when he needs a single expression to refer to both the conclusion and one of the premisses of the syllogism that constitutes the core of a syllogism through the impossible. If we are correct, we have shown that the view that the expression `the final protasis' in EN 7.3, 1147b9ff must mean `the final premiss' and so cannot refer to the conclusion of the relevant syllogism is mistaken
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
David Hitchcock (2000). Fallacies and Formal Logic in Aristotle. History and Philosophy of Logic 21 (3):207-221.
Gisela Striker (2009). Aristotle's Prior Analytics Book I: Translated with an Introduction and Commentary. OUP Oxford.
Christopher J. Martin (2010). They Had Added Not a Single Tiny Proposition: The Reception of the Prior Analytics in the First Half of the Twelfth Century. Vivarium 48 (1-2):159-192.
Alexander (2006). On Aristotle's "Prior Analytics 1.23-31". Cornell University Press.
Katerina Ierodiakonou (2002). Aristotle's Use of Examples in the "Prior Analytics". Phronesis 47 (2):127 - 152.
Katerina Ierodiakonou (2002). Aristotle's Use of Examples in the Prior Analytics. Phronesis 47 (2):127-152.
S. O. Welding (1971). Aristotle's Theory of the Syllogism. A Logico-Philological Study of Book A of the Prior Analytics. Philosophy and History 4 (2):156-156.
Henry Veatch (1972). Aristotle's Theory of the Syllogism: A Logico-Philosophical Study of Book A of the Prior Analytics. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A 2 (4):369-378.
Leo Sweeney (1971). "Aristotle's Theory of the Syllogism: A Logico-Philological Study of Book 'A' of the 'Prior Analytics,'" by Günther Patzig, Trans. Jonathan Barnes. Modern Schoolman 48 (3):308-309.
Paolo C. Biondi (2010). Prior Analytics 1 Striker Gisela (Ed., Trans.) Aristotle. Prior Analytics Book I. Pp. Xx + 268. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2009. [REVIEW] The Classical Review 60 (02):370-372.
Jonathan Barnes (1990). The Prior Analytics Robin Smith (Ed., Tr.): Aristotle, Prior Analytics (Translated, with Introduction, Commentary, and Notes). Pp. Xxxi + 262. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, 1989. [REVIEW] The Classical Review 40 (2):234-236.
Simo Knuuttila (2010). Generality and Identity in Late Medieval Discussions of the Prior Analytics. Vivarium 48 (1-2):215-227.
John R. Welch (1991). Reconstructing Aristotle: The Practical Syllogism. Philosophia 21 (1-2):69-88.
Sten Ebbesen (2010). The Prior Analytics in the Latin West: 12th-13th Centuries. Vivarium 48 (1-2):96-133.
Robin Smith (1982). What Is Aristotelian Ecthesis? History and Philosophy of Logic 3 (2):113-127.
Added to index2011-07-07
Total downloads39 ( #100,676 of 1,790,186 )
Recent downloads (6 months)3 ( #266,358 of 1,790,186 )
How can I increase my downloads?