Is Hirsch or Wilson confused? A commentary on "The pitfalls of heritability "
| Abstract | In "The pitfalls of heritability," a review of Edward O. Wilson’s Consilience Times Literary Supplement, Feb 12, 1999, p33], Jerry Hirsch claims to have convicted Wilson of a "confusion about genetic similarity and difference." In his book, Wilson claims that if we assume that "a mere one thousand genes out of the fifty to a hundred thousand genes in the human genome were to exist in two forms in the population," the probability of any two humans--excluding identical siblings--having the same genotype is vanishingly small. Hirsch points out that a single genotype can be produced in more than one way, thus increasing the likelihood of a single genotype recurring in the human population. Hirsch’s point is fair enough as far it goes, but it does not go nearly far enough. Hirsch has failed to carry out all the relevant calculations needed to determine the probability of two humans having the same genotype. In the realm of Vast numbers ("Very much greater than ASTronomical"--Dennett, 1995, p109), increased likelihood in and of itself tells us nothing. Here, then, are some of the relevant calculations | |||||||||
| Keywords | No keywords specified (fix it) | |||||||||
| Categories | ||||||||||
| Options |
|
|||||||||
Download options| PhilPapers Archive |
Upload a copy of this paper Check publisher's policy on self-archival Papers currently archived: 5,672 |
| External links |
  Try with proxy. |
| Through your library | Only published papers are available at libraries |
Similar books and articlesStephan Blatti & Sandra Lapointe (eds.) (forthcoming). Ontology After Carnap. Oxford University Press.
Eli Hirsch (1982). The Concept of Identity. Oxford University Press.
Sidney J. Segalowitz (1999). Why Twin Studies Really Don't Tell Us Much About Human Heritability. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 22 (5):904-905.
Eli Hirsch (1993). Dividing Reality. Oxford University Press.
Omri Tal (2009). From Heritability to Probability. Biology and Philosophy 24 (1):81-105.
Ken Koltun-Fromm (2000). Public Religion in Samson Raphael Hirsch and Samuel Hirsch's Interpretation of Religious Symbolism. Journal of Jewish Thought and Philosophy 9 (1):69-105.
Gerald Marsh (2010). Is the Hirsch-Sider Dispute Merely Verbal? Australasian Journal of Philosophy 88 (3):459-469.
Sylvia Culp (1997). Establishing Genotype/Phenotype Relationships: Gene Targeting as an Experimental Approach. Philosophy of Science 64 (4):278.
Neven Sesardic (1993). Heritability and Causality. Philosophy of Science 60 (3):396-418.
Jerry Hirsch (1999). Rose Succeeds Where Wilson Fails. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 22 (5):895-896.
Analytics
Monthly downloads |
Added to index2009-01-28Total downloads18 ( #67,529 of 549,065 )Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #63,185 of 549,065 )How can I increase my downloads? |
My notes
Discussion
