Off-campus access
Using PhilPapers from home?
Click here to configure this browser for off-campus access.
- Göran Duus-Otterström (2008). Betting Against Hard Determinism. Res Publica 14 (3).The perennial fear associated with the free will problem is the prospect of hard determinism being true. Unlike prevalent attempts to reject hard determinism by defending compatibilist analyses of freedom and responsibility, this article outlines a pragmatic argument to the effect that we are justified in betting that determinism is false even though we may retain the idea that free will and determinism are incompatible. The basic argument is that as long as we accept that libertarian free will is worth wanting, there is a defensible rationale, given the uncertainty which remains as to whether determinism is true or false, to refrain from acting on hard determinism, and thus to bet that libertarian free will exists. The article closes by discussing two potentially decisive objections to this pragmatic argument.Reading list | Discuss | Edit | Categorize |My bibliography
| Export citation | Scholar | At my library 
Discussion of Göran Duus-Otterström, Betting against hard determinism
 Back
All discussions
Start a new thread
|
There are no threads in this forum |
Nothing in this forum yet.
Similar books and articles
"This is an important book, and no one interested in issues which touch on the free will will want to ignore it."--Ethics. In this stimulating and thought-provoking book, the author defends the thesis that free will is incompatible with determinism. He disputes the view that determinism is necessary for moral responsbility. Finding no good reason for accepting determinism, but believing moral responsiblity to be indubitable, he concludes that determinism should be rejected.
Reading list
| Discuss | Edit | Categorize | My bibliography | Export citation | Other links: books.google.com | Scholar | At my library | Share & More ...
| | Other links: books.google.com | Scholar | At my library | Share & More ... After a brief but necessary characterization of the notion of determinism, I discuss and critically evaluate four views on the relationship between determinism and free will by taking into account both (i) what matters most to us in terms of a free will worth-wanting and (ii) which capacities can be legitimately attributed to human beings without contradicting what we currently know from natural sciences. The main point of the paper is to argue that the libertarian faces a dilemma: on the (...)
Reading list
| Discuss | Edit | Categorize | My bibliography | Export citation | Other links: philsci-archive.pitt.edu books.google.com | Scholar | At my library | Share & More ...
| | Other links: philsci-archive.pitt.edu books.google.com | Scholar | At my library | Share & More ... What values, if any, would be undermined by determinism?[i] Traditionally this question has been tackled by asking whether determinism is compatible with free will or whether it is compatible with moral responsibility. Compatibilists say that determinism would not threaten free will or moral responsibility, and hence that people’s values should not be influenced by whether or not they believe in determinism. Incompatibilists say that determinism would undermine free will or moral responsibility, and hence that a belief in determinism should have (...)
Reading list
| Discuss | Edit | Categorize | My bibliography | Export citation | Scholar | Share & More ...
| | Scholar | Share & More ... Of liberty and necessity, by D. Hume.--The doctrine of necessity examined, by C. S. Peirce.--Determinism in history, by E. Nagel.--Some arguments for free will, by T. Reid.--Has the self free will? by C. A. Campbell.--Dialogue on free will, by L. de Valla.--Can the will be caused? by C. Ginet.--Free will, by G. E. Moore.--A modal muddle, by S. N. Thomas.--Determinism, indeterminism, and libertarianism, by C. D. Broad.--An empirical disproof of determinism? by K. Lehrer.--Free will, praise and blame, by J. J. (...)
Reading list
| Discuss | Edit | Categorize | My bibliography | Export citation | Scholar | At my library | Share & More ...
| | Scholar | At my library | Share & More ... On one way of putting things, incompatibilism is the view that in some important sense free will (and/or moral responsibility) is incompatible with determinism. Incompatibilism is typically taken to come in two species: libertarianism, which holds that we are free and responsible (and correspondingly, that determinism does not hold), and skeptical incompatibilism.1 The latter includes views such as hard determinism, which hold that we are not free (and/or responsible) and views that argue that free will is incompatible with both determinism (...)
Reading list
| Discuss | Edit | Categorize | My bibliography | Export citation | Other links: usfca.edu | Scholar | Share & More ...
| | Other links: usfca.edu | Scholar | Share & More ... Part 1. lecture 1. Free will and determinism-- the basic debate -- lecture 2. Fate and karma -- lecture 3. Divine predestination and foreknowledge -- lecture 4. Causal determinism -- lecture 5. Ancient and medieval indeterminism -- lecture 6. Agent causation -- lecture 7. Ancient and classical compatibilism -- lecture 8. Contemporary compatibilism -- lecture 9. Hard determinism -- lecture 10. Free will impossibilism -- lecture 11. The belief in free will -- lecture 12. Physics and free will --.
Reading list
| Discuss | Edit | Categorize | My bibliography | Export citation | Scholar | At my library | Share & More ...
| | Scholar | At my library | Share & More ... 1. “All Theory is Against Free Will…” Powerful arguments have been leveled against the concepts of free will and moral responsibility since the Greeks and perhaps earlier. Some—the hard determinists—aim to show that free will is incompatible with determinism, and that determinism is true. Therefore there is no free will. Others, the “no-free-will-either-way-theorists,” agree that determinism is incompatible with free will, but add that indeterminism, especially the variety posited by quantum physicists, is also incompatible with free will. Therefore there is (...)
Reading list
| Discuss | Edit | Categorize | My bibliography | Export citation | Scholar | Share & More ...
| | Scholar | Share & More ... In this paper I shall define a thesis I shall call 'determinism', and argue that it is incompatible with the thesis that we are able to act otherwise than we do (i.e., is incompatible with 'free will'). Other theses, some of them very different from what I shall call 'determinism', have at least an equal right to this name, and, therefore, I do not claim to show that every thesis that could be called 'determinism' without historical impropriety is incompatible with (...)
Reading list
| Discuss | Edit | Categorize | My bibliography | Export citation | Other links: springerlink.com | Scholar | At my library | Share & More ...
| | Other links: springerlink.com | Scholar | At my library | Share & More ... This paper looks at the basic philosophic positions on the problem of free will and suggests that there is a difference in usage of the term "determinism" between hard and soft determinists. The term "freewillism" is introduced, which is defined as the view that events can be caused by willed choices. Instead of "soft determinism", "hard determinism" and "libertarianism" the terms "soft freewillism", "(hard) determinism" and "hard freewillism" are used. Hence there is only one form of determinism, and the issue (...)
Reading list
| Discuss | Edit | Categorize | My bibliography | Export citation | Scholar | Share & More ...
| | Scholar | Share & More ... Most philosophers now concede that libertarianism has failed as an account of free will. Assuming the correctness of this concession, that leaves compatibilism and hard determinism as the only remaining choices in the free will debate. In this paper, I will argue that hard determinism turns out to be a form of compatibilism, and therefore, compatibilism is the only remaining position in the free will debate. I will attempt to establish this conclusion by arguing that hard determinists will end up (...)
Reading list
| Discuss | Edit | Categorize | My bibliography | Export citation | Other links: blackwell-synergy.com ingentaconnect.com | Scholar | At my library | Share & More ...
| | Other links: blackwell-synergy.com ingentaconnect.com | Scholar | At my library | Share & More ... 
