In defence of the sovereignty of philosophy: Al-baghdadi's critique of Ibn al-haytham's geometrisation of place
David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Arabic Sciences and Philosophy 17 (1):57-80 (2007)
This paper investigates the objections that were raised by the philosopher ‘Abd al-La[tdotu ]if al-Baghdadi (d. ca. 1231 CE) against al-[Hdotu ]asan ibn al-Haytham’s (Alhazen; d. after 1041 CE) geometrisation of place. In this line of enquiry, I contrast the philosophical propositions that were advanced by al-Baghdadi in his tract: Fi al-Radd ‘ala Ibn al-Haytham fi al-makan (A refutation of Ibn al-Haytham’s place), with the geometrical demonstrations that Ibn al-Haytham presented in his groundbreaking treatise: Qawl fi al-Makan (Discourse on place). In examining the particulars of al-Baghdadi’s fragile defence of Aristotle’s definition of topos as delineated in Book IV of the Physics, which was rejected on mathematical grounds by Ibn al-Haytham, a special attention is also given to highlighting the systemic distinctions between the entities that are studied within the speculative physical doctrines of common sense and immediate experience, and the postulated ‘objects’ of scientific and mathematical research. (Published Online February 12 2007) Footnotes1 An earlier concise version of this paper was presented on 18 February 2006 in Florence, under the title: ‘The physical or the mathematical? interrogating al-Baghdadi's critique of Ibn al-Haytham's geometrisation of place’, as part of the Colloque de la Société Internationale d'Histoire des Sciences et des Philosophies Arabes et Islamiques (Circulation des savoirs autour de la Méditerranée, IXe–XVIe siècles), which was held in association with the University of Florence. This text will be published as part of the Proceedings of the Colloquium (Les Actes du Colloque), under the editorship of Graziella Federici Vescovini (Florence).
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
Nader El-Bizri (2011). The Groundbreaking Physics of Averroës. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A 42 (1):210-214.
Similar books and articles
Ahmad S. Dallal (1995). Ibn Al-Haytham's Universal Solution for Finding the Direction of the Qibla by Calculation. Arabic Sciences and Philosophy 5 (02):145-.
Roshdi Rashed (2007). The Celestial Kinematics of Ibn Al-Haytham. Arabic Sciences and Philosophy 17 (1):7-55.
Dominique Raynaud (2003). Ibn Al-Haytham on Binocular Vision: A Precursor of Physiological Optics. Arabic Sciences and Philosophy 13 (1):79-99.
Alain Michel (2003). Géométrie Et Philosophie: De Thabit Ibn Qurra À Ibn Al-Haytham. Arabic Sciences and Philosophy 13 (2):311-315.
Khalid Bouzoubaâ Fennane (2003). Reflections on the Principle of Continuity on the Basis of Ibn Al-Haytham's Commentary on Proposition I.7 of Euclid's Elements. Arabic Sciences and Philosophy 13 (1):101-136.
Christian Houzel (2009). The New Astronomy of Ibn Al-Haytham. Arabic Sciences and Philosophy 19 (1):1-41.
Gérard Simon (1992). L'optique d'Ibn Al-Haytham Et la Tradition Ptoléméenne. Arabic Sciences and Philosophy 2 (02):203-.
A. I. Sabra (1966). Ibn Al-Haytham's Criticisms of Ptolemy's. Journal of the History of Philosophy 4 (2).
Muhammad Saud (1990). The Scientific Method of Ibn Al-Haytham. Islamic Research Institute, International Islamic University.
Eberhard Knobloch (2002). The Knowledge of Arabic Mathematics by Clavius. Arabic Sciences and Philosophy 12 (2):257-284.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads11 ( #150,693 of 1,413,336 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #154,079 of 1,413,336 )
How can I increase my downloads?