Inquiry 29 (1-4):65 – 77 (1986)
|Abstract||The main theme in most of the contributions to the symposium on Making Sense of Marx is methodological individualism. In the first part of my reply I consider the objections raised to this, in my opinion, trivially true doctrine. Against Taylor I argue that social relations, seen in abstraction from their relata, have no causal efficacy. Against Wood I argue that my defence of methodological individualism and my criticism of functional explanation are less closely related than he makes them out to be. Against Slaughter I argue that he holds two inconsistent views on the importance of individual desires and beliefs in social explanation. Against Meikle I argue that his view that entities are ?real natures? with a normal path of development needs to be restated in terms of dynamically stable processes. In the second part of the reply I deal with the individual contributions one by one. The replies to the ?fundamentalist Marxists? Slaughter and Meikle are relatively brief, because of the dismissive, unscholarly nature of their comments. Similarly I do not have much to say to North and Taylor, whose brief comments do not contain much with which to disagree. I reply at greater length to Wood, conceding the point he makes in the last section of his comment but rejecting his argument concerning functional explanation|
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
No categories specified
(categorize this paper)
|Through your library||Configure|
Similar books and articles
Walter Ott (2009). Remarks on McCormick's Comments. Philosophia 37 (3).
David Papineau, Reply to Robert Kirk's and Andrew Melnyk's Comments on My "Thinking About Consciousness".
W. Suchting (1978). I. Rising Up From Downunder: Comments on Feyerabend's 'Marxist Fairytales From Australia'. Inquiry 21 (1-4):337 – 347.
Joseph Raz (2003). The Practice of Value - Reply. In Jay Wallace (ed.), The Practice of Value. Oxford University Press.
Jon Elster (1980). Vii. Reply to Comments. Inquiry 23 (2):213 – 232.
Hilary Putnam (1964). Comments on Comments on Comments: A Reply to Margenau and Wigner. Philosophy of Science 31 (1):1-6.
Cliff Slaughter (1986). Making Sense of Elster. Inquiry 29 (1-4):45 – 56.
Michael Taylor (1986). Elster's Marx. Inquiry 29 (1-4):3 – 10.
Justin Schwartz (1993). Functional Explanation and Metaphysical Individualism. Philosophy of Science 60 (2):278-301.
Allen W. Wood (1986). Historical Materialism and Functional Explanation. Inquiry 29 (1-4):11 – 27.
Added to index2009-01-30
Total downloads3 ( #213,130 of 722,765 )
Recent downloads (6 months)0
How can I increase my downloads?