David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Ezio Di Nucci
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Philosophy Compass 7 (6):388-396 (2012)
In a familiar limerick attributed to Ronald Knox, the narrator asks how a “tree/should continue to be/when there’s no one about in the Quad,” and is subsequently reassured that its continuous existence is guaranteed by God’s being “always about in the Quad” observing it. This is meant to capture Berkeley’s so‐called ‘continuity argument’ for the existence of God, on which the claim that objects exist continuously over time is supposed to entail the existence of a Divine Mind that continuously perceives the ideas that constitute those objects. But the continuity argument is not an uncontroversial one. For one thing, we might ask what divine perception is supposed to be like – does God perceive all of the ideas that we do, and in the same way that we do? And if so, does this mean that God perceives pain – that God suffers? For another thing, we might ask whether Berkeley is entitled to the claim that objects exist continuously to begin with. In this paper, I look at some of the problems associated with the continuity argument, and then present a reading of divine perception that attempts to prevent these problems from arising at the outset
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
Jonathan Francis Bennett (1971). Locke, Berkeley, Hume: Central Themes. Oxford,Clarendon Press.
Kenneth P. Winkler (1994). Berkeley: An Interpretation. Oxford University Press Uk.
Tom Stoneham (2002). Berkeley's World: An Examination of the Three Dialogues. Oxford University Press.
David Lewis (1983). Postscript to "Mad Pain and Martian Pain". Philosophical Papers 12:122-133.
Jeffrey K. McDonough (2008). Berkeley, Human Agency and Divine Concurrentism. Journal of the History of Philosophy 46 (4):pp. 567-590.
Citations of this work BETA
Melissa Frankel (forthcoming). Berkeley on the “Twofold State of Things”. International Journal for Philosophy of Religion:1-18.
Similar books and articles
Charles J. McCracken (1979). What Does Berkeley's God See in the Quad? Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie 61 (3):280-292.
E. J. Furlong (1966). Berkeley and the Tree in the Quad. Philosophy 41 (156):169 - 173.
David Berman (1986). Berkeley's Quad. Idealistic Studies 16 (1):41-45.
Robert McKim (1987). What Is God Doing in the Quad? Philosophy Research Archives 13:637-653.
Douglas M. Jesseph (2005). Berkeley, God, and Explanation. In Christia Mercer (ed.), Early Modern Philosophy: Mind, Matter, and Metaphysics. Oxford University Press
Ekaterina Y. Ksenjek & Daniel E. Flage (2012). Berkeley, the Author of Nature, and the Judeo-Christian God. History of Philosophy Quarterly 29 (3):281-300.
Melissa Frankel (2009). Berkeley, Meaning and Minds: Remarks on Glezakos' Comments. Philosophia 37 (3):409-413.
John Russell Roberts (2010). A Mystery at the Heart of Berkeley's Philosophy. Oxford Studies in Early Modern Philosophy:214-46.
Stephen H. Daniel (2011). Berkeley's Rejection of Divine Analogy. Science Et Esprit 63 (2):149-161.
George Botterill (2007). God and First Person in Berkeley. Philosophy 82 (1):87-114.
Margaret Atherton (1995). Berkeley Without God. In Robert G. Muehlmann (ed.), Berkeley's Metaphysics: Structural, Interpretive, and Critical Essays. The Pennsylvania State University Press
Stephen R. L. Clark (1985). God-Appointed Berkeley and the General Good. In John Foster & Howard Robinson (eds.), Essays on Berkeley: A Tercentennial Celebration. Oxford University Press
M. R. Ayers (1987). Divine Ideas and Berkeley's Proofs of God's Existence. In Ernest Sosa (ed.), Essays on the Philosophy of George Berkeley. D. Reidel
Marc A. Hight (2007). Berkeley and Bodily Resurrection. Journal of the History of Philosophy 45 (3):443-458.
Added to index2012-05-04
Total downloads52 ( #79,454 of 1,793,059 )
Recent downloads (6 months)5 ( #169,529 of 1,793,059 )
How can I increase my downloads?