Criminalizing Health-Related Behaviors Dangerous to Others? Disease Transmission, Transmission-Facilitation, and the Importance of Trust
Graduate studies at Western
Criminal Law and Philosophy 6 (1):47-63 (2012)
|Abstract||Statutes criminalizing behavior that risks transmission of HIV/AIDS exemplify use of the criminal law against individuals who are victims of infectious disease. These statutes, despite their frequency, are misguided in terms of the goals of the criminal law and the public health aim of reducing overall burdens of disease, for at least three important reasons. First, they identify individual offenders for punishment, a paradigm that is misplaced in the most typical contexts of transmission of infectious disease and even for HIV/AIDS, despite claims of AIDS exceptionalism. Second, although there are examples of individuals who transmit infectious disease in a manner that fits the criminal law paradigm of identification of individual offenders for deterrence or retribution, these examples are limited and can be accommodated by existing criminal laws not devoted specifically to infectious disease. Third, and most importantly, the current criminal laws regarding HIV/AIDS, like many other criminal laws applied to infectious disease transmission, have been misguided in focusing on punishment of the diseased individual as a wrongful transmitter. Instead of individual offenders, activities that enhance the scale of disease transmission—behaviors that might be characterized as ‘transmission facilitation’—are a more appropriate target for the criminal law. Examples are trafficking in human beings (including sex trafficking, organ trafficking, and labor trafficking), suppression of information about the emergence of infection in circumstances in which there is a legally established obligation to disclose, and intentional or reckless activities to discourage disease treatment or prevention. Difficulties remain with justifications for criminalizing even these behaviors, however, most importantly the need for trust in reducing overall burdens of disease, problems in identifying individual responsible offenders, and potential misalignment between static criminal law and the changing nature of infectious disease|
|Keywords||Criminalization Infectious disease HIV/AIDS Trafficking Disease transmission|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
|Through your library||Configure|
Similar books and articles
James B. McArthur, As the Tide Turns: The Changing HIV/AIDS Epidemic and the Criminalization of HIV Exposure.
Michael J. Selgelid & Christian Enemark (2008). Infectious Diseases, Security and Ethics: The Case of Hiv/Aids. Bioethics 22 (9):457-465.
Sabina Gainotti, Nicola Moran, Carlo Petrini & Darren Shickle (2008). Ethical Models Underpinning Responses to Threats to Public Health: A Comparison of Approaches to Communicable Disease Control in Europe. Bioethics 22 (9):466-476.
Sara M. Glasgow & Dennis Pirages (2004). The Health of Nations: Infectious Disease, Environmental Change, and Their Effects on National Security and Development, And: Plagues and Politics: Infectious Disease and International Policy (Review). Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 47 (1):140-145.
Philip Hefner (2004). The Necessity for a Theology of Disease: Reflections on Totalities and Fragments. Zygon 39 (2):487-496.
Yvonne Lau & Chrystal Jaye (2009). The 'Obligation' to Screen and its Effect on Autonomy. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 6 (4):495-505.
Thomas Schramme (2007). The Significance of the Concept of Disease for Justice in Health Care. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 28 (2):121-135.
Leslie P. Francis & John G. Francis (2010). Stateless Crimes, Legitimacy, and International Criminal Law: The Case of Organ Trafficking. [REVIEW] Criminal Law and Philosophy 4 (3):283-295.
André Krom (2011). The Harm Principle as a Mid-Level Principle? Three Problems From the Context of Infectious Disease Control. Bioethics 25 (8):437-444.
Joseph B. R. Gaie & Sana Mmolai (eds.) (2007). The Concept of Botho and Hiv&Aids in Botswana. Zapf Chancery.
Kazem Sadegh-Zadeh (2000). Fuzzy Health, Illness, and Disease. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 25 (5):605 – 638.
Albert Mosley (2004). Does Hiv or Poverty Cause Aids? Biomedical and Epidemiological Perspectives. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 25 (5-6):399-421.
Germund Hesslow (1993). Do We Need a Concept of Disease? Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 14 (1).
Sorry, there are not enough data points to plot this chart.
Added to index2011-12-10
Total downloads1 ( #292,879 of 740,604 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #61,960 of 740,604 )
How can I increase my downloads?