Politics, Philosophy and Economics 9 (4):428-445 (2010)
|Abstract||Cranston argued that scarcity makes universal welfare rights impossible. After showing that this argument cannot be avoided by denying scarcity, I consider four challenges to the argument which accept the possibility of conflicts between the duties implied by rights. The first denies the agglomeration principle; the second embraces conflicts of duties; the third affirms the violability of all rights-based duties; and the fourth denies that duties to compensate are overriding. I argue that all four challenges to the scarcity argument are unsuccessful. I then discuss Eddy’s recent challenge, which makes welfare rights context dependent, but I argue that this also fails because it makes rights unknowable. I conclude that the scarcity argument, restated in the light of the discussion, shows that universal welfare rights, as ordinarily understood, are impossible and I explain the philosophical and practical significance of this conclusion|
|Keywords||conflicts context-dependent rights overriding duties scarcity welfare rights rights duties compensation ought implies can agglomeration|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
|Through your library||Configure|
Similar books and articles
Katherine Eddy (2006). Welfare Rights and Conflicts of Rights. Res Publica 12 (4):337-356.
Katherine Eddy (2007). On Revaluing the Currency of Human Rights. Politics, Philosophy and Economics 6 (3):307-328.
Barbara Wall (2013). Catholic Social Teaching and Human Rights. Journal of Catholic Social Thought 10 (1):1-4.
Shari Collins-Chobanian (2000). Beyond Sax and Welfare Interests. Environmental Ethics 22 (2):133-148.
Mark Munsterhjelm & Frederic Gilbert (2010). How Do Research Duties Conflict with Aboriginal Rights? Genetics Research and Biobank Problem in Taiwan. Dilemata 2 (4):33-56.
Hugh V. McLachlan (2010). Moral Rights to Life, Both Natural and Non-Natural: Reflections on James Griffin's Account of Human Rights. Diametros 26:58-76.
David M. Douglas (2011). A Bundle of Software Rights and Duties. Ethics and Information Technology 13 (3):185-197.
Anthony J. Povilitis (1980). On Assigning Rights to Animals and Nature. Environmental Ethics 2 (1):67-71.
Ivar Kolstad (2012). Human Rights and Positive Corporate Duties: The Importance of Corporate–State Interaction. Business Ethics 21 (3):276-285.
Peter Gn West-Oram & Heather Widdows, Global Population and Global Justice: Equitable Distribution of Resources Among Countries. The Electronic Library of Science.
Eleanor Curran (2007). Reclaiming the Rights of the Hobbesian Subject. Palgrave Macmillan.
Siegfried van Duffel (forthcoming). Natural Rights to Welfare. European Journal of Philosophy.
Peter Vallentyne (2003). The Rights and Duties of Childrearing. William and Mary Bill of Rights Journal 11:991-1010.
Terrance McConnell (1984). The Nature and Basis of Inalienable Rights. Law and Philosophy 3 (1):25 - 59.
Tara Smith (1992). On Deriving Rights to Goods From Rights to Freedom. Law and Philosophy 11 (3):217 - 234.
Added to index2010-09-22
Total downloads59 ( #19,696 of 722,700 )
Recent downloads (6 months)4 ( #20,264 of 722,700 )
How can I increase my downloads?