Empirical evaluations of theoretical explanations of psychotherapeutic efficacy: A reply to John D. Greenwood
David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Philosophy of Science 63 (4):622-641 (1996)
Using Grunbaum 1984 and 1993 as a springboard, Greenwood (this issue) claims to have offered several methodologically salubrious and exegetically illuminating theses on empirical evaluations of theoretical explanations of psychotherapeutic efficacy. According to his exegesis of Grunbaum's construction (1984, Ch. 2, Section C; 1993, 184-204) of Freud's "Tally Argument," that argument bespeaks a rife neglect of the epistemologically-significant distinction between empirical evaluations of the efficacy of psychotherapy and evaluations of theoretical explanations of that efficacy. Greenwood presents a defense of a qualified version of Popper's critique of psychoanalysis against Grunbaum's objections to it (1984, Ch. 1B). Finally, Greenwood offers a clarification of the concept of a "placebo control" investigation, taking issue with Grunbaum's 1993 (84-87, 91-93). In the present paper, it is argued contra Greenwood that: (1) his purportedly "best" reading of Freud's Tally Argument and of its import founders, (2) the distinction that Greenwood bemoans as being neglected by mental health researchers actually is a commonplace in the literature on treatment-process and therapeutic outcome, (3) Greenwood's defense of Popper's critique of psychoanalysis is an anachronism, and (4) Greenwood's conceptual analysis of placebo controls is nebulous and misconceived
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Adolf Grunbaum (1987). Psychoanalysis and Theism. The Monist 70 (2):152 - 192.
Donald Levy (1988). Gr Nbaum's Freud. Inquiry 31 (2):193 – 215.
John Davis, William Giakas, Jie Que, Pavan Passad & Stefan Leucht (2011). Should We Treat Depression with Drugs or Psychological Interventions? A Reply to Ioannidis. Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine 6 (1):8-.
John D. Greenwood (1990). Self-Knowledge: Inference, Perception and Articulation. Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology 10 (2):39-48.
A. A. Derksen (1992). Does the Tally Argument Make Freud a Sophisticated Methodologist? Philosophy of Science 59 (1):75-101.
Robert C. Richardson (1990). The "Tally Argument" and the Validation of Psychoanalysis. Philosophy of Science 57 (4):668-676.
Robert Klee (1992). In Defense of the Quine-Duhem Thesis: A Reply to Greenwood. Philosophy of Science 59 (3):487-491.
Edward Erwin (1996). The Evaluation of Psychotherapy: A Reply to Greenwood. Philosophy of Science 63 (4):642-651.
John D. Greenwood (1997). Placebo Control Treatments and the Evaluation of Psychotherapy: A Reply to Grunbaum and Erwin. Philosophy of Science 64 (3):497-510.
John D. Greenwood (1996). Freud's 'Tally' Argument, Placebo Control Treatments, and the Evaluation of Psychotherapy. Philosophy of Science 63 (4):605-621.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads8 ( #199,536 of 1,692,696 )
Recent downloads (6 months)2 ( #108,995 of 1,692,696 )
How can I increase my downloads?