David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Classical Quarterly 32 (3-4):137- (1938)
The source-criticism2 of Diodorus XVI has been dominated by the principle of argument from detail. Thus, if two details in Diodorus' text are found to conflict, they are assumed to derive from different sources and, if similar, from the same source; and, where a fragment of an ancient historian is found to resemble a passage in Diodorus, that historian is assumed to be the source employed by Diodorus in that passage; finally, when a sufficient mosaic of such details is pieced together, general divisions are drawn to embrace each separate detail. But this principle is of questionable value: for it implies the tacit assumption that Diodorus made no mistake in compressing or transcribing detail, added no colour himself, and could only have derived a given detail, described in a given manner, from the one ancient historian whose description of that detail is preserved. When one remembers that Diodorus is a careless and unintelligent compiler of a compendious narrative, who aimed like Ephorus at lending each book a unity, and that the fragments of the many historians whom Diodorus may have excerpted are very scanty, it is clear that this principle admits of a large margin of error
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Charles E. Muntz (2011). The Sources of Diodorus Siculus, Book 1. Classical Quarterly 61 (02):574-594.
N. G. L. Hammond (1948). The Lost Diodorus Diodorus Siculus with an English Translation by C. H. Oldfather. In 12 Vols. Vol. IV: Books IX–XII. 40. (Loeb Classical Library.) Pp. 468; 4 Maps. London: Heinemann, 1947. Cloth, 10s. Net. [REVIEW] The Classical Review 62 (2):66.
A. Devine (1997). Review. Diodorus Siculus: The Reign of Philip II: The Greek and Macedonian Narrative From Book XVI. A Companion. EI McQueen. [REVIEW] The Classical Review 47 (2):284-285.
N. G. L. Hammond (1978). Diodorus Siculus XIX. The Classical Review 28 (01):16-.
Christopher Tuplin (2005). Diodorus 15 P. J. Stylianou: A Historical Commentary on Diodorus Siculus Book 15 . Pp. Xxii + 602. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1998. Cased. ISBN: 0-19-815239-. [REVIEW] The Classical Review 55 (01):73-.
John Carter (1992). Reassessing Diodorus Kenneth Sacks: Diodorus Siculus and the First Century. Pp. Xii + 242. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1990. $29.95. [REVIEW] The Classical Review 42 (01):34-36.
J. Gwyn Griffiths (1973). Diodorus Siculus I. 22. 4 F. The Classical Review 23 (01):9-.
J. Gwyn Griffiths (1948). Diodorus Siculus, 1. 47. 3. The Classical Review 62 (3-4):114-.
E. J. Chinnock (1892). Gleanings from Diodorus Siculus. The Classical Review 6 (06):260-.
R. K. Sinclair (1966). Diodorus Siculus and Fighting in Relays. Classical Quarterly 16 (02):249-.
Paul Mckechnie (1995). Diodorus Siculus and Hephaestion's Pyre. Classical Quarterly 45 (02):418-.
N. G. L. Hammond (1964). The Loeb Diodorus C. Bradford Welles: Diodorus of Sicily. With an English Translation. (Loeb Classical Library.) Vol. Viii (Books Xvi. 66–95, Xvii). Pp. V+485; 2 Maps. London: Heinemann, 1963. Cloth, 18s. Net. [REVIEW] The Classical Review 14 (02):157-158.
Catherine Rubincam (1998). How Many Books Did Diodorus Siculus Originally Intend to Write? Classical Quarterly 48 (01):229-.
N. G. L. Hammond (1936). Diodorus Siculus, Books II 35–IV 58. With an English Translation by C. H. Oldfather. Pp. X+539; 2 Maps. (Loeb Classical Library.) London: Heinemann, 1935. Cloth, 10s. (Leather, 12s. 6d.). [REVIEW] The Classical Review 50 (04):148-.
Added to index2010-12-09
Total downloads9 ( #173,442 of 1,413,402 )
Recent downloads (6 months)3 ( #67,314 of 1,413,402 )
How can I increase my downloads?