Graduate studies at Western
|Abstract||The Eighth Amendment of the United States Constitution dictates that “Excessive bail shall not be required, excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.”[i] I have often wondered, and perhaps the reader has as well: just what purpose is served by the addition of the word “unusual” to the constitutional clause prohibiting cruel punishments? When a legislature enacts or a judge levies a punishment that is much harsher than what the norm is for such an offense, this unusual punishment is often taken to be unconstitutional. But while it is certainly unusual to bestow a life sentence without parole upon a petty thief, is not this excessive punishment cruel and thus wouldn’t a ban of just cruel punishments suffice? If “cruel” in a constitutional sense means something like “unjustifiably harsh,” why would a punishment need to have any other property to be unconstitutional? Of course, there are punishments that are unjust but not cruel. One such case would occur when a judge gives a guilty friend an unusually light sentence. But the word “unusual” could not have been added to render such lenient sentences unconstitutional for the crucial phrase of the Eighth Amendment is a conjunction and not a disjunction. It does not prohibit cruel or unusual punishments but cruel and unusual punishments.|
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
|Through your library||Only published papers are available at libraries|
Similar books and articles
H. J. McCloskey (1965). A Non-Utilitarian Approach to Punishment. Inquiry 8 (1-4):249 – 263.
Robert S. Gerstein (1974). Capital Punishment-"Cruel and Unusal"?: A Retributivist Response. Ethics 85 (1):75-79.
Julia Tanner (2008). Why I Won’T Hurt Your Felines? In Steven Hales (ed.), What Philosophy Can Tell You About Your Cat. Open Court Publishing.
Jeremy Bentham (2009). The Rationale of Punishment. Prometheus Books.
I. I. Smith, Utility and the Principle of Medical Futility: Safeguarding Autonomy and the Prohibition Against Cruel and Unusual Punishment.
Cbarles S. Milligan (1993). The “Cruel and Unusual” Proscription in the Eighth Amendment. Social Philosophy Today 8:103-116.
Roozbeh Baker, Proportionality in the Criminal Law: The Differing American Versus Canadian Approaches to Punishment.
Thomas A. Long (1973). Capital Punishment-"Cruel and Unusual"? Ethics 83 (3):214-223.
William A. Edmundson (1984). Death Penalties: A Review of Raoul Berger, Death Penalties. [REVIEW] Duke Law Journal 1984:624-29.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads16 ( #81,852 of 739,368 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #61,680 of 739,368 )
How can I increase my downloads?