The Conversation Argument for Actual Intentionalism

British Journal of Aesthetics 52 (3):241-256 (2012)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

Proponents of actual intentionalism hold that an author’s actual intentions should constrain the proper interpretation of his or her works. If, for example, we have good reason to think Proust intends his character Marcel to set out to write a different novel from In Search of Lost Time itself, then that is how we should interpret the text. After decades of being denigrated as the ‘intentional fallacy’, actual intentionalism has enjoyed a renaissance in philosophical aesthetics in recent years, thanks in large part to the image of the conversation that has been enlisted in its favour: when we neglect the author’s intended construal of the text and opt instead for some clever alternative interpretation of our own, we are depriving ourselves of the chance to engage in a conversation (in some metaphorical sense) with this author—and thus are losing the chance (again, in some metaphorical sense) to commune with another human being. In this paper I will raise doubts about whether this appeal to conversation actually helps the actual intentionalist’s case. When we reflect on the essentially interactive nature of any conversation worthy of that name, we see that this conversation metaphor will not deliver the restrictive lesson of actual intentionalism. In fact, it militates against it

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 90,221

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

When artists fail: A reply to Trivedi.Sheila Lintott - 2002 - British Journal of Aesthetics 42 (1):64-72.
Authors' intentions, literary interpretation, and literary value.Stephen Davies - 2006 - British Journal of Aesthetics 46 (3):223-247.
Actual intentionalism vs. hypothetical intentionalism.Gary Iseminger - 1996 - Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 54 (4):319-326.
The inner philosopher: conversations on philosophy's transformative power.Lou Marinoff - 2012 - Cambridge, Mass.: Dialogue Path Press. Edited by Daisaku Ikeda.
Moderate actual intentionalism defended.Robert Stecker - 2006 - Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 64 (4):429-438.
Historical interpretation, intentionalism and philosophy of mind.Vivienne Brown - 2007 - Journal of the Philosophy of History 1 (1):25-62.
Intention, Interpretation and Contemporary Visual Art.Hans Maes - 2010 - British Journal of Aesthetics 50 (2):121-138.
An epistemic dilemma for actual intentionalism.Saam Trivedi - 2001 - British Journal of Aesthetics 41 (2):192-206.

Analytics

Added to PP
2012-07-10

Downloads
191 (#95,087)

6 months
9 (#144,029)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Andrew Huddleston
University of Warwick

Citations of this work

Literary Intentionalism.Robbie Kubala - 2019 - Metaphilosophy 50 (4):503-515.
Composers and Performers.Junyeol Kim - 2020 - Philosophia 48 (4):1469-1481.
Framing Effects in Museum Narratives: Objectivity in Interpretation Revisited.Anna Bergqvist - 2016 - Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement 79:295-318.

Add more citations

References found in this work

No references found.

Add more references