David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Ezio Di Nucci
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Ethical Perspectives 6 (2):126-138 (1999)
The July 1998 announcement of Peter Singer's appointment to the chair of bio ethics at Princeton University's Center for Human Values as the Ira W. DeCamp Professor of Bioethics raised a very loud controversy, largely due to Singer's favourable opinion of infanticide.The present paper is not the forum in which to recount this well publicized and often overly emotional conflict. Indeed, sustained critical discussion of the issues at hand was often found lacking in this debate. Generally the debate included on the anti-Singer side people who had read little of his works, or who had perhaps merely heard his views second hand. The student newspaper of Princeton, the Daily Princetonian, documented many instances of this kind of opposition.On the other hand, his supporters tended to reply with accusations of quotations taken out of context and calls for academic freedom. This present paper is not interested in this debate, but rather concerns itself with the way in which Singer views the distinction between the human being and the person. It is this distinction which grounds his position on infanticide, and thus it is to this that we must turn.In this paper I take issue with Singer's use of the distinction between the person and the human. In so doing, I first explain Singer's basic position on personhood and sentience, and the relative value of organisms named under these two terms. With this discussion in hand, I then lay stress on a simple and repeated dictum of Singer's: the newborn infant up to the age of one month is not a person.This leads us to the position that the only possible ground for the selective infanticide of disabled infants is that newborn infants, healthy or not, are not persons, primarily because they lack self-consciousness. Then I investigate his ideas of personhood and self-consciousness as abstractions. Finally, in conclusion, I offer some observations drawn from Jonathan Swift
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
John Bigelow & Robert Pargetter (1990). From Extroverted Realism to Correspondence: A Modest Proposal. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 50 (3):435-460.
H. D. Rankin (1968). A Modest Proposal About the "Republic". Apeiron 2 (2):20 - 22.
Arthur Madigan (1984). "Metaphysics" E 3: A Modest Proposal. Phronesis 29 (2):123 - 136.
Michael B. Green (1979). Harris's Modest Proposal. Philosophy 54 (209):400 - 406.
Arthur Madigan (1984). Metaphysics E 3: A Modest Proposal. Phronesis 29 (2):123-136.
S. C. Patten (1979). Scepticism and the Second Analogy: A Modest Proposal. Dialogue 18 (1):27-40.
Edward Regis Jr (1974). A Modest Linguistic Proposal. New Scholasticism 48 (2):247-250.
John W. Glaser & Ronald B. Miller (1993). A Paradigm Shift for Ethics Committees and Case Consultation: A Modest Proposal. [REVIEW] HEC Forum 5 (2):83-88.
Henry E. Kyburg Jr (1961). A Modest Proposal Concerning Simplicity. Philosophical Review 70 (3):390-395.
Jan Narveson (1985). Getting on the Road to Peace: A Modest Proposal. Ethics 95 (3):589-605.
James E. Tomberlin (1972). The is-Ought Dichotomy: A Modest Proposal. [REVIEW] Journal of Value Inquiry 6 (1):57-59.
Nicholas Denyer (2000). Traffic Lights: A Modest Proposal. Mind 109:45 - 46.
Michael A. Cavanaugh (1982). A Modest Proposal. Philosophy of the Social Sciences 12 (3):289-301.
Howard Trachtman (2002). A Modest Proposal. American Journal of Bioethics 2 (1):1-2.
Michele M. Moody-Adams (1999). Griffin's Modest Proposal. Utilitas 11 (1):112.
Added to index2010-09-02
Total downloads3 ( #617,186 of 1,796,439 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #467,624 of 1,796,439 )
How can I increase my downloads?