David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Ezio Di Nucci
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Developing World Bioethics 11 (3):109-119 (2011)
Recent global advances in available technology to prevent mother-to-child HIV transmission necessitate a rethinking of contemporary and previous ethical debates on HIV testing as a means to preventing vertical transmission. In this paper, we will provide an ethical analysis of HIV-testing strategies of pregnant women. First, we argue that provider-initiated opt-out HIV testing seems to be the most effective HIV test strategy. The flip-side of an opt-out strategy is that it may end up as involuntary testing in a clinical setting. We analyse this ethical puzzle from a novel perspective, taking into account the moral importance of certain hypothetical preferences of the child, as well as the moral importance of certain actual preferences of the mother. Finally, we balance the conflicting concerns and try to arrive at an ethically sound solution to this dilemma. Our aim is to introduce a novel perspective from which to analyse testing strategies, and to explore the implications and possible benefits of our proposal. The conclusion from our analysis is that policies that recommend provider-initiated opt-out HIV testing of pregnant mothers, with a risk of becoming involuntary testing in a clinical setting, are acceptable. The rationale behind this is that the increased availability of very effective and inexpensive life-saving drugs makes the ethical problems raised by the possible intrusiveness of HIV testing less important than the child's hypothetical preferences to be born healthy. Health care providers, therefore, have a duty to offer both opt-out HIV testing and available PMTCT (preventing mother-to-child transmission) interventions
|Keywords||HIV/AIDS ethics of care developing world bioethics antiretroviral therapy mandatory testing informed consent bioethics|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Russell Armstrong (2008). Mandatory Hiv Testing in Pregnancy: Is There Ever a Time? Developing World Bioethics 8 (1):1–10.
Sofia Gruskin, Shahira Ahmed & Laura Ferguson (2008). Provider-Initiated Hiv Testing and Counseling in Health Facilities – What Does This Mean for the Health and Human Rights of Pregnant Women? Developing World Bioethics 8 (1):23–32.
Harold W. Jaffe (2009). Increasing Knowledge of Hiv Infection Status Through Opt-Out Testing. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 6 (2):229-233.
Martin Gunderson, David J. Mayo & Frank S. Rhame (1996). Routine HIV Testing of Hospital Patients and Pregnant Women: Informed Consent in the Real World. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 6 (2):161-182.
Stuart Rennie & Bavon Mupenda (2008). Ethics of Mandatory Premarital Hiv Testing in Africa: The Case of Goma, Democratic Republic of Congo. Developing World Bioethics 8 (2):126-137.
Michael Waxman, Roland Merchant, M. Celada & Melissa Clark (2011). Perspectives on the Ethical Concerns and Justifications of the 2006 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention HIV Testing Recommendations. BMC Medical Ethics 12 (1):24-.
L. Fields & C. Kaplan (2011). Opt-Out HIV Testing: An Ethical Analysis of Women's Reproductive Rights. Nursing Ethics 18 (5):734-742.
Viva C. Thorsen, Johanne Sundby & Francis Martinson (2008). Potential Initiators of Hiv-Related Stigmatization: Ethical and Programmatic Challenges for Pmtct Programs. Developing World Bioethics 8 (1):43–50.
Peter A. Clark (2006). Mother-to-Child Transmission of Hiv in Botswana: An Ethical Perspective on Mandatory Testing. Developing World Bioethics 6 (1):1–12.
E. Salang Seloilwe (2011). Commentary on 'Opt-Out HIV Testing: An Ethical Analysis of Women's Reproductive Rights'. Nursing Ethics 18 (5):743-745.
Thaddeus Metz (2005). The Ethics of Routine HIV Testing: A Respect-Based Analysis. South African Journal on Human Rights 21 (3):370-405.
Melissa Whellams (2008). The Approval of Over-the-Counter HIV Tests: Playing Fair When Making the Rules. [REVIEW] Journal of Business Ethics 77 (1):5 - 15.
K. M. Boyd (1990). Institute of Medical Ethics: Working Party Report. HIV Infection: The Ethics of Anonymised Testing and of Testing Pregnant Women. Journal of Medical Ethics 16 (4):173-178.
Matthew K. Wynia (2006). Routine Screening: Informed Consent, Stigma and the Waning of HIV Exceptionalism. American Journal of Bioethics 6 (4):5 – 8.
P. de Zulueta (2000). The Ethics of Anonymised HIV Testing of Pregnant Women: A Reappraisal. Journal of Medical Ethics 26 (1):16-21.
Added to index2011-07-26
Total downloads14 ( #255,754 of 1,907,041 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #468,221 of 1,907,041 )
How can I increase my downloads?