Journal of Political Philosophy 18 (3):357-368 (2010)
|Abstract||In her ‘On the apparent paradox of ideal theory’, Laura Valentini combines three supposedly plausible premises to derive the paradoxical result that ideal theory is both unable to, and indispensable for, guiding action. Her strategy is to undermine one of the three premises by arguing that there are good and bad kinds of ideal theory, and only the bad kinds are vulnerable to the strongest version of their opponents’ attack. By undermining one of the three premises she releases ideal theorists from the paradox, which is as follows. (1) Any sound theory of justice is action-guiding. (2) Any sound theory of justice is ideal. (3) Any ideal theory fails to be action-guiding. Here I shall respond to Valentini in two ways. First, I shall show that both (1) and (2) are false. The falsity of either is sufficient to release ideal theorists from the paradox. Second, I shall show that Valentini’s response to (3) can be extended, because her bad kinds of ideal theory do not necessarily fail to guide action. The cumulative effect of my arguments further strengthens Valentini’s support of ideal theory. I will deal with premises (1) and (2) in Sections I and II, and (3) in Section III.|
|Keywords||Ideal Theory Rawls Counterfactual Interpretation of Original Position Dworkin Non-Ideal Theory Valentini Possible World Accessibility Principles of Justice|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
|Through your library||Configure|
Similar books and articles
Rajeev Gore & Revantha Ramanayake (2012). Valentini's Cut-Elimination for Provability Logic Resolved. The Review of Symbolic Logic 5 (2):212-238.
Shane J. Ralston (2010). Can Pragmatists Be Institutionalists? John Dewey Joins the Non-Ideal/Ideal Theory Debate. Human Studies 33 (1):65-84.
James P. Sterba (1999). Reconciling Public Reason and Religious Values. Social Theory and Practice 25 (1):1-28.
Robert Jubb (2012). Tragedies of Non-Ideal Theory. European Journal of Political Theory 11 (3):229-246.
Holly Lawford-Smith (2013). Understanding Political Feasibility. Journal of Political Philosophy 21 (3):243-259.
Pablo Gilabert & Holly Lawford-Smith (2012). Political Feasibility. A Conceptual Exploration. Political Studies 60 (4):809-825.
Laura Valentini (2011). Gillian Brock, Global Justice: A Cosmopolitan Account. [REVIEW] Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 14 (2):251-252.
Laura Valentini (2009). On the Apparent Paradox of Ideal Theory. Journal of Political Philosophy 17 (3):332-355.
Added to index2009-12-03
Total downloads71 ( #14,661 of 722,863 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #60,917 of 722,863 )
How can I increase my downloads?