Graduate studies at Western
Journal of Religious Ethics 13 (2):258 - 278 (1985)
|Abstract||In response to criticisms of his "Ambiguity in Moral Choice", Richard McCormick developed, in "Commentary on the Commentaries," an alternative view on proportionate reason. I interpret McCormick's view in terms of what I call "the undermining principle," "the theory of associated goods," "the necessity principle," and "the liberty principle." I argue that the first two are the heart of the theory and link McCormick's view to that of Peter Knauer. I then show that McCormick's view suffers from several problems, including a lack of argumentation for his central undermining principle, and counterexamples to his necessity and liberty principles.|
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
|Through your library||Configure|
Similar books and articles
Frederick S. Carney (1978). On McCormick and Teleological Morality. Journal of Religious Ethics 6 (1):81 - 107.
Richard McCormick (2000). Ambiguity in Moral Choice. In Christopher Robert Kaczor (ed.), Proportionalism: For and Against. Marquette University Press.
James Gaffney (1976). The Over-Extended Principle of Totality and Some Underlying Issues. Journal of Religious Ethics 4 (2):259 - 267.
Richard A. McCormick (1989). The Critical Calling: Reflections on Moral Dilemmas Since Vatican Ii. Georgetown University Press.
Walter Ott (2009). Remarks on McCormick's Comments. Philosophia 37 (3):475-476.
Peter McCormick (2004). Warfare, Reason, and Moral Truths. Symposium 8 (2):267-274.
O. Bayer (1988). A Response To Richard McCormick. Studies in Christian Ethics 1 (1):30-32.
J. B. Tubbs (1996). Moral Epistemology in Richard McCormick's Ethics. Christian Bioethics 2 (1):114-126.
John A. Robertson (forthcoming). What We May Do with Preembryos: A Response to Richard A McCormick. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 1 (December):293-302.
Matt McCormick (2005). Kant's Theory of Mind in the Critique of Pure Reason's Subjective Deduction. Journal of Value Inquiry 39 (3):353–381.
Richard Holmes (1992). Fictions, Philosophies, and the Problems of Poetics Peter J. McCormick Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1988, Xvi + 351 P., $42.50, $15.95 Paper. [REVIEW] Dialogue 31 (01):173-.
P. A. Clark (2008). Richard McCormick, SJ, and Dual Epistemology. Christian Bioethics 14 (3):236-271.
Mark T. Nelson (1996). The Principle of Sufficient Reason: A Moral Argument. Religious Studies 32 (1):15-26.
Richard A. McCormick (1992). A Theological Perspective. Ethics and Behavior 2 (2):130 – 131.
Richard A. McCormick (1978). Freedman on the Rights of the Voiceless. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 3 (3):211-221.
Sorry, there are not enough data points to plot this chart.
Added to index2011-05-29
Total downloads1 ( #292,750 of 741,392 )
Recent downloads (6 months)0
How can I increase my downloads?