David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Acta Analytica 27 (1):29-44 (2012)
There is a strong intuition that for a change to occur, there must be a moment at which the change is taking place. It will be demonstrated that there are no such moments of change, since no state the changing thing could be in at any moment would suffice to make that moment a moment of change. A moment in which the changing thing is simply in the state changed from or the state changed to cannot be the moment of change, since these states are respectively before and after the change; moreover, to select one of these moments over the other as the moment of change would be arbitrary. A moment in which the changing thing is neither in the state changed from nor in the state changed to cannot be the moment of change, since there are changes for which it is impossible for something to be in neither state. Finally, the moment of change cannot be a moment in which the changing thing is in both the state changed from and the state changed to, as suggested by Graham Priest and others. Even if, like proponents of this view, we are willing to accept the contradictions that the account entails, it is demonstrated that on such a model, every change would require an infinite number of other changes, every change would take an infinite amount of time, and some changes would occur without occurring at any time. Further, the model is grossly counterintuitive, with the exact nature of the counterintuitive element depending on what model of time and space one endorses. Finally, it is demonstrated that this model is incompatible with the Leibniz Continuity Condition
|Keywords||Change Dialetheism Metaphysics Philosophy of logic Time|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
J. Ellis McTaggart (1908). The Unreality of Time. Mind 17 (68):457-474.
Chris Mortensen (2004). Dharmakirti and Priest on Change. Philosophy East and West 54 (1):20-28.
Graham Priest (2006). In Contradiction: A Study of the Transconsistent. Oxford University Press.
Michael Tooley (1988). In Defense of the Existence of States of Motion. Philosophical Topics 16 (1):225-254.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Babette E. Babich, The Ethical Alpha and the Linguistic Omega: Heidegger's Anti-Semitism and the Inner Affinity.
Sean D. Kirkland (2007). On Anti-Parmenidean Temporality in Aristotle's Physics. Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy 12 (1):49-62.
Stanley N. Salthe (2011). A Journey From Science Through Systems Science in Pursuit of Change. World Futures 67 (4-5):282 - 303.
John Bowin (2010). Aristotle on the Unity of Change: Five Reductio Arguments in Physics Viii. Ancient Philosophy 30 (2):319-345.
Paul Vincent Spade (1994). How to Start and Stop. Journal of Philosophical Research 19:193-221.
Edo Pivčević (1990). Change and Selves. Oxford University Press.
Jacob Rosen (2012). Motion and Change in Aristotles Physics 5. 1. Phronesis 57 (1):63-99.
Andre Gallois, Identity Over Time. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
John Bowin (2009). Aristotle on the Order and Direction of Time. Apeiron 42 (1):49-78.
Michael Pelczar (2010). Presentism, Eternalism, and Phenomenal Change. Synthese 176 (2):275 - 290.
Don S. Levi (2007). Determinism as a Thesis About the State of the World From Moment to Moment. Philosophy 82 (3):399-419.
Leonid Grinin (2008). Transformation of Sovereignty and Globalization. In Leonid Grinin, Dmitry Beliaev & Andrey Korotayev (eds.), Hierarchy and Power in the History of Civilisations: Political Aspects of Modernity. Librocom.
Dongmo Zhang & Norman Foo (2001). Infinitary Belief Revision. Journal of Philosophical Logic 30 (6):525-570.
Added to index2011-04-14
Total downloads53 ( #35,177 of 1,413,232 )
Recent downloads (6 months)2 ( #94,196 of 1,413,232 )
How can I increase my downloads?