Phronesis 55 (3):255-270 (2010)
|Abstract||Aristotle in Physics I,1 says some strange-sounding things about how we come to know wholes and parts, universals and particulars. In explicating these, Simplicius distinguishes an initial rough cognition of a thing as a whole, an intermediate "cognition according to the definition and through the elements," and a final cognition of how the thing's many elements are united: only this last is επιστημη. Simplicius refers to the Theaetetus for the point about what is needed for επιστημη and the ways that cognition according to the definition and through the elements falls short. By unpacking this reference I try to reconstruct Simplicius' reading of "Socrates' Dream," its place in the Theaetetus ' larger argument, and its harmony with other Platonic and Aristotelian texts. But this reconstruction depends on undoing some catastrophic emendations in Diels's text of Simplicius. Diels's emendations arise from his assumptions about definitions and elements, in Socrates' Dream and elsewhere, and rethinking the Simplicius passage may help us rethink those assumptions|
|Keywords||Aristotle Simplicius Diels definition element Theaetetus|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
|Through your library||Configure|
Similar books and articles
L. S. B. MacCoull (1998). The Anaximander Saying in its Sixth-Century (C. E.) Context. Philosophy and Theology 11 (1):85-96.
I. Hadot (1982). La Doctrine de Simplicius Sur l'Âme Raisonnable Humaine Dans le Commentaire Sur le Manuel D'Epictète. In H. J. Blumenthal & A. C. Lloyd (eds.), Soul and the Structure of Being in Late Neoplatonism: Syrianus, Proclus, and Simplicius: Papers and Discussions of a Colloquium Held at Liverpool, 15-16 April 1982. Liverpool University Press.
Joh Zahlfleisch (1902). Einige Corollarien des Simplicius in Seinem Commentar Zu Aristoteles' Physik (Ed. Diels). I. P. 1129—1152 (Contra Philoponum). [REVIEW] Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie 15 (2).
H. J. Blumenthal (1982). The Psychology of (?) Simplicius' Commentary on the de Anima. In H. J. Blumenthal & A. C. Lloyd (eds.), Soul and the Structure of Being in Late Neoplatonism: Syrianus, Proclus, and Simplicius: Papers and Discussions of a Colloquium Held at Liverpool, 15-16 April 1982. Liverpool University Press.
Pavel Gregoric & Christoph Helmig (2011). Ομοσε Χωρειν: Simplicius, Corollarium de Loco 601.26–8 (Diels). The Classical Quarterly 61 (02):722-730.
Marc-Antoine Gavray (2011). Archytas Lu Par Simplicius. Un Art de la Conciliation. International Journal of the Platonic Tradition 5 (1):85-158.
Rachel Barney (2009). Simplicius: Commentary, Harmony, and Authority. Antiquorum Philosophia 3:101-120.
R. Gaskin (1998). Simplicius on the Meaning of Sentences: A Commentary on "In Cat." 396,30-397,28. Phronesis 43 (1):42 - 62.
Gaskin (1998). Simplicius on the Meaning of Sentences: A Commentary on In Cat. 396,30-397,28. Phronesis 43 (1):42-62.
Zeev Perelmuter (2010). Nous and Two Kinds of Episteme in Aristotle's Posterior Analytics. Phronesis 55 (3):228-254.
Added to index2010-08-16
Total downloads41 ( #32,659 of 722,864 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #60,917 of 722,864 )
How can I increase my downloads?