David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Journal of Consciousness Studies 17 (11-12):173-79 (2010)
Clare Batty has recently argued that the content of human olfactory experience is 'a very weak kind of abstract, or existentially quantified content', and so that 'there is no way things smell'. Her arguments are based on two claims. Firstly, that there is no intuitive distinction between olfactory hallucination and olfactory illusion. Secondly, that olfaction 'does not present smell at particular locations', and 'seems disengaged from any particular object'. The present article shows both of these claims to be false. It shows that naïve subjects find it quite natural to draw a distinction between olfactory hallucination and olfactory illusion. And it argues that the phenomenology of normal olfactory experience is of particular objects as having smells. Two confusions are responsible for Batty thinking otherwise: (1) Batty's examples are cases of extreme pungency, and she mistakes a peculiarity of intense perceptions for a property of olfaction more generally; (2) Batty focuses on very short time slices and so confuses limitations on the information carried by a single sniff for a limitation on the logical form of all olfactory content.
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Clare Batty (2010). What the Nose Doesn't Know: Non-Veridicality and Olfactory Experience. Journal of Consciousness Studies 17 (3-4):10-17.
Clare Batty (2010). A Representational Account of Olfactory Experience. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 40 (4):511-538.
Clare Batty (2010). Olfactory Experience I: The Content of Olfactory Experience. Philosophy Compass 5 (12):1137-1146.
Clare Batty (2010). Scents and Sensibilia. American Philosophical Quarterly 47 (2):103-118.
Clare Batty (2011). Smelling Lessons. Philosophical Studies 153 (Mar.):161-174.
Benjamin D. Young (2012). Stinking Consciousness! Journal of Consciousness Studies 19 (3-4):223-243.
Clare Batty (2010). Olfactory Experience II: Objects and Properties. Philosophy Compass 5 (12):1147-1156.
R. Hermer-Vazquez & L. Hermer-Vazquez (2003). The Evolution of Neural Dynamics Permitting Isocortical-Limbic-Motor Communication. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 26 (5):559-560.
Clare Batty (2009). What's That Smell? Southern Journal of Philosophy 47 (4):321-348.
Ed Cooke & Erik Myin (2011). Is Trilled Smell Possible? How the Structure of Olfaction Determines the Phenomenology of Smell. Journal of Consciousness Studies 18 (11-12):59-95.
Timothy J. Bayne (2004). Self-Consciousness and the Unity of Consciousness. The Monist 87 (2):219-236.
Peter Walla, Bernd Hufnagl, Johann Lehrner, Dagmar Mayer, Gerald Lindinger, Lüder Deecke & Wilfried Lang (2002). Evidence of Conscious and Subconscious Olfactory Information Processing During Word Encoding: A Magnetoencephalographic (MEG) Study. Cognitive Brain Research 14 (3):309-316.
Leslie P. Tolbert, Lynne A. Oland, Thomas C. Christensen & Anita R. Goriely (2003). Neuronal and Glial Morphology in Olfactory Systems: Significance for Information-Processing and Underlying Developmental Mechanisms. [REVIEW] Brain and Mind 4 (1):27-49.
P. Tolbert Leslie, A. Oland Lynne, C. Christensen Thomas & R. Goriely Anita (2003). Neuronal and Glial Morphology in Olfactory Systems: Significance for Information-Processing and Underlying Developmental Mechanisms. Brain and Mind 4 (1).
Louise Richardson (2013). Sniffing and Smelling. Philosophical Studies 162 (2):401-419.
Added to index2011-02-21
Total downloads45 ( #58,714 of 1,699,588 )
Recent downloads (6 months)8 ( #77,273 of 1,699,588 )
How can I increase my downloads?