Triangulation, Objectivity and the Ambiguity Problem (Triangulación, objetividad y el problema de la ambigüedad)
Crítica 35 (105):25 - 48 (2003)
| Abstract | Davidson claims that a creature that has spent its entire life in isolation cannot have thoughts. His two reasons for this claim are that (i) interaction with another creature (what he calls "triangulation") is required to locate the cause of the creature's responses, and that (ii) linguistic communication is necessary to acquire the concept of objective truth, which is itself required in order to have thoughts. I argue that, at best, these two reasons imply that in order to have thoughts a creature must be capable of participating in triangulation, not that it must have already participated in triangulation. I then argue that triangulation doesn't solve the ambiguity problem; that is, it doesn't entail that a being's thoughts and utterances are about distal objects rather than proximal patterns of stimulation. Fortunately, ambiguity, like other forms of indeterminacy, doesn't entail that we cannot have thoughts. /// Davidson afirma que una criatura que ha pasado su vida entera aislada no puede tener pensamientos. Aduce dos razones para esto: (i) que se requiere la interacción con otra criatura (lo que él llama "triangulación") para localizar la causa de las respuestas de la criatura, y (ii) que la comunicación lingüística es necesaria para adquirir el concepto de verdad objetiva, que a su vez es necesario para tener pensamientos. Argumento que, en el mejor de los casos, estas dos razones implican que para tener pensamientos una criatura debe ser capaz de participar en una triangulacion, no que ya debe haber participado en ella. Arguyo, además, que la triangulación no resuelve el problema de la ambigüedad, esto es, no implica que lo que un ser piensa y dice sea acerca de objetos distantes, más que de patrones de estimulacion próximos. Por fortuna, la ambigiiedad, como otras formas de indeterminación, no implica que no podamos tener pensamientos. | |||||||||
| Keywords | No keywords specified (fix it) | |||||||||
| Categories | No categories specified (fix it) | |||||||||
| Options |
|
|||||||||
Download options| PhilPapers Archive |
Upload a copy of this paper Check publisher's policy on self-archival Papers currently archived: 5,705 |
| External links |
 |
| Through your library | Configure |
Similar books and articlesClaudine Verheggen (2007). Triangulating with Davidson. Philosophical Quarterly 57 (226):96-103.
Ingar Brink (2004). Joint Attention, Triangulation and Radical Interpretation: A Problem and its Solution. Dialectica 58 (2):179–206.
Andrew Sneddon (2001). What's Wrong with Selling Yourself Into Slavery? Paternalism and Deep Autonomy (¿Por Qué Está Mal Moralmente Venderse Uno Mismo Como Esclavo? Paternalismo y Autonomía Profunda). Crítica 33 (98):97 - 121.
Nathaniel Goldberg (2009). Triangulation, Untranslatability, and Reconciliation. Philosophia 37 (2).
Timothy J. Nulty (2006). Davidsonian Triangulation and Heideggerian Comportment. International Journal of Philosophical Studies 14 (3):443 – 453.
Gustavo Sarmiento (2007). El método de la metafísica en la Dissertatio de Kant. The Proceedings of the Twenty-First World Congress of Philosophy 10:155-160.
Elena Nájera (2008). A propósito de la crítica antiepistemológica de la “verdad” y la “objetividad”. Proceedings of the Xxii World Congress of Philosophy 53:325-333.
Robert W. Lurz (2001). How to Solve the Distinguishability Problem: Triangulation Without Explicit Training. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 24 (6):1142-1143.
Antonio Gaitán Torres (2005). En la Cuerda Floja. El Acceso Normativo En Practical Reality (On the Tightrope. The Normative Access in Practical Reality). Crítica 37 (109):65 - 97.
Andrea Iacona (2007). Future Contingents and Aristotle's Fantasy (Los Futuros Contingentes y la Fantasía de Aristóteles). Crítica 39 (117):45 - 60.
Fidel Gutiérrez Vivanco (2006). El Problema de la Education. The Proceedings of the Twenty-First World Congress of Philosophy 4:147-152.
Analytics
Monthly downloads |
Added to index2011-05-29Total downloads2 ( #232,628 of 549,132 )Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #63,397 of 549,132 )How can I increase my downloads? |
My notes
Discussion
