A defense of the principle of indifference
Journal of Philosophical Logic 39 (6):655-678 (2010)
| Abstract | The principle of indifference (hereafter ‘Poi’) says that if one has no more reason to believe A than B (and vice versa ), then one ought not to believe A more than B (nor vice versa ). Many think it’s demonstrably false despite its intuitive plausibility, because of a particular style of thought experiment that generates counterexamples. Roger White ( 2008 ) defends Poi by arguing that its antecedent is false in these thought experiments. Like White I believe Poi, but I find his defense unsatisfactory for two reasons: it appeals to false premises, and it saves Poi only at the expense of something that Poi’s believers likely find just as important. So in this essay I defend Poi by arguing that its antecedent does hold in the relevant thought experiments, and that the further propositions needed to reject Poi are false. I play only defense in this essay; I don’t argue that Poi is true (even though I think it is), but rather that one popular refutation is faulty. In showing this, I also note something that has to my knowledge gone unnoticed: given some innocuous-looking assumptions the denial of Poi is equivalent to a version of epistemic permissivism , and Poi itself is equivalent to a version of epistemic uniqueness | |||||||||
| Keywords | No keywords specified (fix it) | |||||||||
| Categories | ||||||||||
| Options |
|
|||||||||
Download options| PhilPapers Archive |
Upload a copy of this paper Check publisher's policy on self-archival Papers currently archived: 5,679 |
| External links |
 |
| Through your library | Configure |
Similar books and articlesVictor Saxer (1984). La ricerca agiografica dai Bollandisti in poi. Augustinianum 24 (1/2):333-345.
Armen T. Marsoobian (1996). Saying, Singing, or Semiotics: "Prima la Musica E Poi le Parole" Revisited. Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 54 (3):269-277.
Andrew Haas (2012). The Birth of Language Out of the Spirit of Improvisation. International Journal of Philosophical Studies 20 (3):331-347.
Rodolfo De Cristofaro (2008). A New Formulation of the Principle of Indifference. Synthese 163 (3):329 - 339.
Dylan Dodd (2013). Roger White's Argument Against Imprecise Credences. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 64 (1):69-77.
Brian Weatherson (2003). Are You a Sim? Philosophical Quarterly 53 (212):425–431.
Brian Weatherson (2005). Should We Respond to Evil with Indifference? Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 70 (3):613–635.
Avrum Stroll & Henry Alexander (1975). 'True' and Truth. Philosophy of Science 42 (4):384-410.
Elinor Mason (2004). Consequentialism and the Principle of Indifference. Utilitas 16 (3):316-321.
Conor McHugh (2010). Self-Knowledge and the Kk Principle. Synthese 173 (3).
Justin A. Capes (2010). The W-Defense. Philosophical Studies 150:61-77.
Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra (2006). Truthmaking, Entailment, and the Conjunction Thesis. Mind 115 (460):957-982.
Kostas Kalimtzis (2007). Philosophical Foundations of Praxis in Poiesis. The Proceedings of the Twenty-First World Congress of Philosophy 10:31-36.
Analytics
Monthly downloads |
Added to index2010-11-17Total downloads37 ( #31,927 of 549,088 )Recent downloads (6 months)2 ( #37,333 of 549,088 )How can I increase my downloads? |
My notes
Discussion
