David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Journal of Religious Ethics 38 (2):321-347 (2010)
This paper examines the argument that moral approval of homosexuality is analogous to the early church's inclusion of gentiles. The analogy has a long but often overlooked history, dating back to the start of the modern gay-rights movement. It has recently gained greater prominence because of its importance to the Episcopal Church's debate with the wider Anglican Communion. Beginning with the Episcopal Church argument, we see that there are five specific areas most in need of further clarification. In this essay I examine significant uses of the analogy from the prior 25 years to see how effectively they address these five areas. I conclude that the conversation surrounding the Gentile Analogy is the current, best hope for mutual understanding among Christians about homosexuality. However, if the analogy is to advance the Christian conversation, much greater care and precision is needed in its application from traditionalists and revisionists alike
|Keywords||homosexuality analogy Episcopal Church moral reasoning Jerusalem Council Anglican Communion Acts 10–15 Windsor Report early church gentiles|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
Markus N. A. Bockmuehl (2000/2003). Jewish Law in Gentile Churches: Halakhah and the Beginning of Christian Public Ethics. Baker Academic.
David B. Burrell (1973). Analogy and Philosophical Language. New Haven,Yale University Press.
Jeffrey Stout (2003). How Charity Transcends the Culture Wars: Eugene Rogers and Others on Same-Sex Marriage. Journal of Religious Ethics 31 (2):169 - 180.
Judith Jarvis Thomson (1971). A Defense of Abortion. Philosophy and Public Affairs 1 (1):47-66.
E. Wiland (2000). Unconscious Violinists and the Use of Analogies in Moral Argument. Journal of Medical Ethics 26 (6):466-468.
Citations of this work BETA
John Perry (2012). Vocation and Creation: Beyond the Gentile-Homosexual Analogy. Journal of Religious Ethics 40 (2):385-400.
Jon C. Olson (2012). The Jerusalem Decree, Paul, and the Gentile Analogy to Homosexual Persons. Journal of Religious Ethics 40 (2):360-384.
Georg Spielthenner (2014). Analogical Reasoning in Ethics. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 17 (5):861-874.
Similar books and articles
Steven A. Long (2011). Analogia Entis: On the Analogy of Being, Metaphysics, and the Act of Faith. University of Notre Dame Press.
Paul F. Camenisch (1976). Abortion, Analogies and the Emergence of Value. Journal of Religious Ethics 4 (1):131 - 158.
P. R. Wilson (1964). On the Argument by Analogy. Philosophy of Science 31 (1):34-39.
Eric Dietrich (2000). Analogy and Conceptual Change, or You Can't Step Into the Same Mind Twice. In Eric Dietrich Art Markman (ed.), Cognitive Dynamics: Conceptual change in humans and machines. Lawrence Erlbaum. 265--294.
Jiri Syrovatka (2000). Analogy and Understanding. Theoria 15 (3):435-450.
Ralph M. McInerny (1961). The Logic of Analogy. The Hague, Martinus Nijhoff.
A. Gregory (2001). Harvey, Aristotle and the Weather Cycle. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C 32 (1):153-168.
John J. Callanan (2008). Kant on Analogy. British Journal for the History of Philosophy 16 (4):747 – 772.
Eliyahu White (1999). Talk About God, and Others: (Approaches to Likeness in Certain Western Theological and Philosophical Systems): A Process Metaphysics of Analogy Introduced Historically: (By Way of Regard Especially to Attempted Syntheses of Bible and Hellenism). S.N..
Michael J. Wreen (2007). A Second Form of Argument From Analogy. Theoria 73 (3):221-239.
Added to index2010-05-25
Total downloads42 ( #42,788 of 1,099,868 )
Recent downloads (6 months)4 ( #90,276 of 1,099,868 )
How can I increase my downloads?