David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Res Publica 17 (3):227-243 (2011)
This paper asks whether (human) rights enforcement is permissible given that it may entail infringing on the rights of innocent bystanders. I consider two strategies that adopt a rights-sensitive consequentialist framework and offer a positive answer to this question, namely Amartya Sen’s and Hillel Steiner’s. Against Sen, I argue that trade-offs between rights are problematic since they contradict the purpose of rights, which is to provide a pluralist solution to disagreement about values, i.e. to allow agents to act in accordance with their values. I further argue that Steiner’s compensation strategy does not succeed in avoiding trade-offs so it falls prey to the same criticism. I propose a non-trade-off solution that is implicit in the accounts discussed and is more consistent with the meta-ethical framework advocated by Sen. This solution relies on an enforceable duty to share in the costs of rights enforcement hence it entails a degree of redistribution for enforcement purposes
|Keywords||Conflicts of rights Trade-offs Enforcement Consequentialism Agent-relative reasons Pluralism|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
S. Caney (1997). Diversity and the Lexical Priority of the Right to Equal Freedom. Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 17 (1):147-163.
Cécile Fabre (2007). Mandatory Rescue Killings. Journal of Political Philosophy 15 (4):363–384.
Robert Nozick (1974). Anarchy, State and Utopia. Basic Books.
Michael Otsuka, Peter Vallentyne & Hillel Steiner (2005). Why Left-Libertarianism Is Not Incoherent, Indeterminate, or Irrelevant: A Reply to Fried. Philosophy and Public Affairs 33 (2):201-215.
Philip Pettit (1987). Rights, Constraints and Trumps. Analysis 47 (1):8 - 14.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Peter Vallentyne (2008). Enforcement Rights and Rights to Reparation. Proceedings of the Xxii World Congress of Philosophy 50:813-820.
Ken A. Bryson (2008). Negotiating Environmental Rights. Ethics, Place and Environment 11 (3):351 – 366.
Daniel E. Lee (2010). Human Rights and the Ethics of Globalization. Cambridge University Press.
Scott Wisor (2012). Property Rights and the Resource Curse: A Reply to Wenar. Journal of Philosophical Research 37:185-204.
Saladin Meckled-Garcia (2004). Neo-Positivism About Rights the Problem with 'Rights as Enforceable Claims'. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 105 (1):143–148.
David Miller (2012). Grounding Human Rights. Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 15 (4):407-427.
Mônica Steffen Guise Rosina & Lea Shaver (2012). Why Are Generic Drugs Being Held Up in Transit? Intellectual Property Rights, International Trade, and the Right to Health in Brazil and Beyond. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 40 (2):197-205.
Eric Mack (2000). In Defense of the Jurisdiction Theory of Rights. Journal of Ethics 4 (1-2):71-98.
William Kline (2010). Do No Harm: A Defense of Markets in Healthcare. [REVIEW] HEC Forum 22 (3):241-251.
Peter Vallentyne (2011). Enforcement Rights Against Non-Culpable Non-Just Intrusion. Ratio 24 (4):422-442.
Axel Gelfert (2013). Strategies of Model-Building in Condensed Matter Physics: Trade-Offs as a Demarcation Criterion Between Physics and Biology? Synthese 190 (2):253-272.
Mitra Ebadolahi, Using Structural Interdicts and the South African Human Rights Commission to Achieve Judicial Enforcement of Economic and Social Rights in South Africa.
John Matthewson (2011). Trade-Offs in Model-Building: A More Target-Oriented Approach. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 42 (2):324-333.
Added to index2011-05-04
Total downloads32 ( #59,668 of 1,139,956 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #165,020 of 1,139,956 )
How can I increase my downloads?