David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Philosophy of Science 57 (4):668-676 (1990)
The classic charge against Freudian theory is that the therapeutic success of psychoanalysis can be explained without appeal to the mechanisms of repression and insight. Whatever therapeutic success psychoanalysis might enjoy would then provide no support for the diagnostic claim that psychological disorders are due to repressed desires or for the therapeutic claim that the gains in psychoanalysis are due to insight into repressed causes. Adolf Grünbaum has repeated the charge in The Foundations of Psychoanalysis (1984), arguing that Freud's response to it in what he calls the "Tally Argument" is woefully inadequate. Grünbaum claims that Freud's defense depends on the view that only psychoanalytic techniques can yield therapeutic effects, and therefore that the transience of some psychoanalytic "cures", the existence of alternative treatment modalities, and the frequency of spontaneous remission undermine Freud's defense of psychoanalysis. I argue that, whatever the merits of psychoanalysis, Freud is not logically committed to any view as extreme as that attributed to him by Grünbaum; and, furthermore, Grünbaum's rendering of Freud is historically inaccurate
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
Paul O'Grady, Paul Rigby & John Hengel (1995). Must a Hermeneutical Psychoanalysis Exclude Science? Man and World 28 (2):115-128.
Similar books and articles
R. A. Sharpe (1986). Psychoanalysis, Science or Insight?Adolf Grünbaum:The Foundations of Psychoanalysis∗. Inquiry 29 (1-4):121-132.
Adolf Grunbaum (1987). Psychoanalysis and Theism. The Monist 70 (2):152 - 192.
Margaret Nash (1989). Gr Nbaum and Psychoanalysis. Philosophical Psychology 2 (3):325 – 343.
Lavinia Gomez (2005). The Freud Wars: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Psychoanalysis. Routledge.
Roland Peterson & Sybe Terwee (1994). Can Functionalism Provide the Proper Basis for a Core Theory of Psychoanalysis? Philosophical Psychology 7 (4):463-469.
Adolf Grunbaum (1996). Empirical Evaluations of Theoretical Explanations of Psychotherapeutic Efficacy: A Reply to John D. Greenwood. Philosophy of Science 63 (4):622-641.
John D. Greenwood (1996). Freud's 'Tally' Argument, Placebo Control Treatments, and the Evaluation of Psychotherapy. Philosophy of Science 63 (4):605-621.
A. A. Derksen (1992). Does the Tally Argument Make Freud a Sophisticated Methodologist? Philosophy of Science 59 (1):75-101.
Donald Levy (1988). Gr Nbaum's Freud. Inquiry 31 (2):193 – 215.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads163 ( #15,309 of 1,777,841 )
Recent downloads (6 months)117 ( #7,288 of 1,777,841 )
How can I increase my downloads?