David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Philosophical Quarterly 47 (189):501-7 (1997)
A contrast is drawn between two types of externalism, one based on ideas of Wittgenstein, the other on arguments from Putnam. Gregory McCulloch’s attempt to combine the two types is then examined and criticized. Putnamian externalism is ambiguous. It can be interpreted either as the empirical claim that we give priority to scientific as opposed to other forms of discourse, or as a metaphysical claim that our language attempts to conform to the structure of the world ‘in itself’. But the first claim is simply false, and the second involves a form of metaphysical realism that a Wittgensteinian must reject as unintelligible. McCulloch’s attempted synthesis of the two types is therefore either incoherent, or else simply adds an empirical falsehood to Wittgenstein’s conceptual point. It is also noted that Putnam himself has progressively retreated from his original claims, and now appears to be a Wittgensteinian, but not a ‘Putnamian’, externalist
|Keywords||Epistemology Externalism Knowledge Meaning Mcculloch, G|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
|Through your library||Configure|
Similar books and articles
Kevin Falvey & Joseph Owens (1994). Externalism, Self-Knowledge, and Skepticism. Philosophical Review 103 (1):107-37.
Akeel Bilgrami (1992). Can Externalism Be Reconciled with Self-Knowledge? Philosophical Topics 20 (1):233-68.
Sven Bernecker (1996). Externalism and the Attitudinal Component of Self-Knowledge. Noûs 30 (2):262-75.
Yujin Nagasawa (2002). Externalism and the Memory Argument. Dialectica 56 (4):335-46.
Gregory McCulloch (2002). Phenomenological Externalism. In Nicholas Smith (ed.), Reading McDowell. Routledge.
Anthony L. Brueckner (2000). Externalism and the a Prioricity of Self-Knowledge. Analysis 60 (1):132-136.
Gregory McCulloch (1990). Externalism and Experience. Analysis 50 (October):244-50.
Carlos J. Moya (2003). Externalism, Inclusion, and Knowledge of Content. In Maria J. Frapolli & E. Romero (eds.), Meaning, Basic Self-Knowledge, and Mind. Csli. 773-800.
Ted A. Warfield (1992). Privileged Self-Knowledge and Externalism Are Compatible. Analysis 52 (4):232-37.
Gregory McCulloch (1994). Not Much Trouble for Ultra-Externalism. Analysis 54 (4):265-9.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads27 ( #53,420 of 1,010,568 )
Recent downloads (6 months)2 ( #39,218 of 1,010,568 )
How can I increase my downloads?