David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Analysis 69 (3):531-540 (2009)
To begin with, I am deeply grateful to Michael Bratman and Michael Smith for their generosity in responding to my book, for the care with which they have read it, and for the challenge of meeting their objections. I am also grateful for their support and encouragement over the years. It is a pleasure to engage with them here.Because their comments raise many related difficulties, this reply will treat them together, beginning with brief consideration of issues in action theory before turning to Reasons and rationalism. It will also be incomplete: there is much more to say about these problems than can be said in this space.Bratman's discussion poses a structural question: how far does my argument about reason and virtue in Part Two of the book depend on the principle of Belief and the cognitive theory of intention from Part One? His answer is: quite a bit. But this is not straightforward. If we reject Belief, our account of acting for reasons becomes more minimal. This would make it more difficult to derive standards of practical reason from the nature of agency, as the rationalist purports to do. If I am right to argue that rationalism and the virtue theory are exhaustive alternatives, it therefore makes the virtue theory of practical reason easier to defend. My Anscombean assumptions are in fact a concession to some of the ideas that motivate rationalists like Korsgaard and Velleman – though not, as we will see, either Bratman or Smith. Denying them makes more trouble for the ethical views that I oppose than it does for mine. 1What does matter to my argument is that when we act intentionally, or for reasons, we need not do so ‘under the guise of the good’, since the doctrine that we must …
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
Kit Fine (1994). Essence and Modality. Philosophical Perspectives 8:1-16.
Gregory S. Kavka (1983). The Toxin Puzzle. Analysis 43 (1):33-36.
Kieran Setiya (2007). Cognitivism About Instrumental Reason. Ethics 117 (4):649-673.
Kieran Setiya (2008). Practical Knowledge. Ethics 118 (3):388-409.
Michael Smith (2004). Instrumental Desires, Instrumental Rationality. Aristotelian Society Supplementary Volume 78 (1):93–109.
Citations of this work BETA
Kieran Setiya (2014). What is a Reason to Act? Philosophical Studies 167 (2):221-235.
Similar books and articles
Laura DeHelian & Edward F. McClennen (1993). Planning and the Stability of Intention: A Comment. Minds and Machines 3 (3):319-333.
J. S. Swindell Blumenthal-Barby (2010). Harry G. Frankfurt (Author), Christine Korsgaard (Commentary), Michael Bratman (Commentary), Meir Dan-Cohen (Commentary), Debra Satz (Editor), Taking Ourselves Seriously and Getting It Right. [REVIEW] Journal of Value Inquiry 44 (1):117-121.
Kirk A. Ludwig (1995). Trying the Impossible: Reply to Adams. Journal of Philosophical Research 20:563-570.
Michael Bratman (2007). Structures of Agency: Essays. Oxford University Press.
Christopher Peacocke (1986). Reply to Michael Smith's Peacocke on Red and Red. Synthese 68 (September):577-580.
John Rosenthal (2001). Hegel Decoder: A Reply to Smith's 'Reply'. Historical Materialism 9 (1):111-151.
Michael E. Bratman (2009). Setiya on Intention, Rationality and Reasons. Analysis 69 (3):510-521.
Michael E. Bratman (2004). Three Forms of Agential Commitment: Reply to Cullity and Gerrans. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 104 (3):327–335.
John F. Gaski (2001). Normative Marketing Ethics Redux, Incorporating a Reply to Smith. Journal of Business Ethics 32 (1):19 - 34.
Ezio Di Nucci (2009). Simply, False. Analysis 69 (1):69-78.
Added to index2009-07-01
Total downloads50 ( #39,820 of 1,679,362 )
Recent downloads (6 months)7 ( #33,920 of 1,679,362 )
How can I increase my downloads?