Redrawing Maps, Manipulating Demographics: On Exchange of Populated Territories and Self-Determination
David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Law and Ethics of Human Rights 2 (1):1-25 (2008)
In “The Blessing of Departure—Exchange of Populated Territories The Lieberman Plan as anExercise in Demographic Transformation,” Prof. Timothy Waters offers a strong endorsement of the right of ethnic majorities within a state to redefine their state's boundaries in ways consistent with the majority's right to self-determination and to opt out of a political union with minority groups, regardless of the latter's' political preferences. Applied to the Israeli context, Waters concludes that parts of the Lieberman Plan—a plan advocating the redrawing of Israel borders, inter alia, in ways which exclude some areas populated by Israeli citizens belonging to the Arab-Palestinian minority —does not run afoul of international law . This short response challenges two points that are central to Waters’s analysis. First, that the right to self-determination of peoples—in particular, the right to external self-determination —is subject to temporal or contextual limitations. The right is fully applicable only in exceptional and formative moments in the life of a nation—e.g., during the formation of a new polity or the collapse of an existing political arrangement , and when states systematically fail to respect the basic interest of some of the groups that comprise its populace—i.e., in response to extraordinary situations of groups exclusion or oppression. Second, even if Waters is correct and an ongoing right to self-determination—including, a right to secede from existing states—is available to ethnic groups comprising diverse national societies, the invocation of such a right must necessarily be limited by other positive rules of international law designed to protect group and individual interests. Specifically, Waters’s concept of self-determination as a right of a preliminary nature, that overrides other human rights , is debatable
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Timothy William Waters (2008). A Different Departure: A Reply to Shany's “Redrawing Maps, Manipulating Demographics: On Exchange of Populated Territories and Self-Determination”. Law and Ethics of Human Rights 2 (1):1-13.
Timothy William Waters (2008). The Blessing of Departure: Acceptable and Unacceptable State Support for Demographic Transformation: The Lieberman Plan to Exchange Populated Territories in Cisjordan. Law and Ethics of Human Rights 2 (1):1-65.
Peter Fibiger Bang (2005). Gift-Exchange S. Von Reden: Exchange in Ancient Greece . Pp. Xii + 244, Maps, Pls. London: Duckworth, 2003 (1995 1 ). Paper, £16.99. ISBN: 0-7156-3179-. [REVIEW] The Classical Review 55 (02):579-.
Todd S. Mei (2009). The Preeminence of Use: Reevaluating the Relation Between Use and Exchange in Aristotle's Economic Thought. Journal of the History of Philosophy 47 (4):pp. 523-548.
Stephen Chen & Chong Ju Choi (2005). A Social Exchange Perspective on Business Ethics: An Application to Knowledge Exchange. [REVIEW] Journal of Business Ethics 62 (1):1 - 11.
Michel Seymour (2007). Secession as a Remedial Right. Inquiry 50 (4):395 – 423.
Alan Strudler (1988). Self-Determination, Incompetence, and Medical Jurisprudence. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 13 (4):349-365.
Stephen Maitzen (2006). Divine Hiddenness and the Demographics of Theism. Religious Studies 42 (2):177-191.
Linda D. Molm (2003). Theoretical Comparisons of Forms of Exchange. Sociological Theory 21 (1):1-17.
Timothy Bahti (1990). Redrawing the Lines. New Vico Studies 8:122-126.
Christopher Norris (2000). McDowell on Kant: Redrawing the Bounds of Sense. Metaphilosophy 31 (4):382-411.
Gabriele Contessa (2008). A Note on the Nomic Possibility of a Dynamic Shift. Erkenntnis 68 (2):187 - 190.
Added to index2010-09-13
Total downloads11 ( #159,696 of 1,692,471 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #184,284 of 1,692,471 )
How can I increase my downloads?