David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Journal of Value Inquiry 47 (4):1-21 (2013)
I evaluate four historically precedented tests for what makes a life worth living: (1) The Suicide Test (Camus), (2) The Recurrence Test (Schopenhauer and Nietzsche), (3) The Extra Life Test (Cicero and Hume), and (4) The Preferring Not to Have Been Test (Job and Williams). I argue that all four fail and tentatively defend the heuristic value of a fifth, The Pre-Existence Test for what makes a life worth living: (5) A life worth living is one that a benevolent caretaker with foreknowledge would allow. A life worth avoiding is one that a benevolent caretaker would disallow. This test usefully tracks the general extension of the concept of what makes a life worth living. I consider three objections and note that there appears to be an indeterminate middle category of lives worth neither. Ultimately, I argue that any plausible test will risk circularity or will require a theory of worth to be viable.
|Keywords||a life worth living welfare value of lives worthwhile meaning of life suicide recurrence|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
|Through your library||Configure|
Similar books and articles
Brooke Alan Trisel (2007). Judging Life and Its Value. Sorites (18):60-75.
Thaddeus Metz (2014). Life Worth Living. In Alex Michalos (ed.), Encyclopedia of Quality of Life and Well-being Research. Springer. 3602-05.
Aaron Smuts (2013). To Be or Never to Have Been: Anti-Natalism and a Life Worth Living. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice:1-19.
Ludwig F. Schlecht (2008). “Is Life Worth Living?”. Philosophy and Theology 20 (1/2):227-242.
Kathleen O'Dwyer (forthcoming). Camus' Challenge: The Question of Suicide (Is Life Worth Living). Journal of Humanistic Psychology.
Louis G. Lombardi (1983). Inherent Worth, Respect, and Rights. Environmental Ethics 5 (3):257-270.
Hyunseop Kim (2013). The Uncomfortable Truth About Wrongful Life Cases. Philosophical Studies 164 (3):623-641.
William James (1895). Is Life Worth Living? International Journal of Ethics 6 (1):1-24.
James Yeates (2012). Quality Time: Temporal and Other Aspects of Ethical Principles Based on a “Life Worth Living”. [REVIEW] Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 25 (4):607-624.
Ernest W. Hankamer (2006). Reply to “Is the Unexamined Life Not Worth Living?”. Teaching Philosophy 29 (1):37-39.
Philip Kitcher (2000). Parfit's Puzzle. Noûs 34 (4):550–577.
Peter E. Pruim (2002). What Makes the Examined Life Worth Living? Teaching Philosophy 25 (4):323-343.
Added to index2012-04-02
Total downloads44 ( #31,325 of 1,011,230 )
Recent downloads (6 months)9 ( #11,350 of 1,011,230 )
How can I increase my downloads?