David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Medicine Studies 1 (3):229-247 (2009)
In this paper, which brings together aging research and media research, we will contribute to the mapping of the complicated cartography of anti-aging by analyzing the press coverage of anti-aging medicine. The mass media decisively shape societal impacts of the expert scientific discourse on anti-aging. While sensitivity towards the heterogeneity of the field of anti-aging is increasing to some degree in the social-gerontological discussion, the role of the media in transmitting the various anti-aging messages to the general public has so far not been systematically scrutinized. Current opinions on the press coverage of anti-aging medicine range from proponents’ complaints of a media witch-hunt against them to opponents’ reproaches about uncritical reporting of this complex topic. This paper discusses whether the media act accordingly to the ideal of the fourth estate, controlling the increased power of science in the 20th century. Our areas of investigation are two Western countries: the USA and Germany. Both countries have experienced an apparent increase in the average age of their populations, which has led to increasingly vigorous public debate since the late 20th century. The subjects of our study are three organizations that represent different approaches to anti-aging medicine: the American Academy of Anti-Aging Medicine, the German Society of Anti-Aging Medicine, and the Methuselah Foundation. The article discusses the programs, goals, and media strategies of these organizations and compares them with the anti-aging messages that actually make their way to the reader in the media “interdiscourse.” The article asks whether transatlantic learning processes within the anti-aging medicine movement as well as in the media can be identified. The paper’s methods and sources are those of contemporary history and ethnography. The three approaches to anti-aging medicine are drawn from publications of spokespersons from the three presented anti-aging medicine organizations and from participant observation of anti-aging medicine conferences in Germany and Europe during the period from 2005 to 2008. The media analysis is based on the study of about 300 articles that appeared between 1990 and 2009 in US and German dailies and weeklies such as Newsweek, The New York Times, Der Spiegel, and Die Welt. Our analysis shows that, against the backdrop of pessimistic demographic apprehensions, the leitmotiv of both nations’ medical journalism between 1990 and 2009 was overwhelmingly pro anti-aging medicine. It is criticized that medical journalism on anti-aging medicine refrains from own investigations on potential risks. Scrutinizing activities of the media in terms of a fourth estate require stimulation from science itself. Hence, we argue for sensitization of medical journalism regarding ageism.
|Keywords||Anti-aging medicine Mass media Press coverage American Academy of Anti-Aging Medicine Methuselah Foundation German Society of Anti-Aging Medicine Transatlantic learning processes|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
Stephen Katz & Barbara L. Marshall (2004). Is the Functional 'Normal'? Aging, Sexuality and the Bio-Marking of Successful Living. History of the Human Sciences 17 (1):53-75.
Citations of this work BETA
Amina Mire (2014). Skin Trade’: Genealogy of Anti-Ageing ‘Whiteness Therapy’ in Colonial Medicine. Medicine Studies 4 (1-4):119-129.
Similar books and articles
Courtney Mykytyn (2009). Anti-Aging is Not Necessarily Anti-Death: Bioethics and the Front Lines of Practice. [REVIEW] Medicine Studies 1 (3):209-228.
Antje Kampf & Lynn Botelho (2009). Anti-Aging and Biomedicine: Critical Studies on the Pursuit of Maintaining, Revitalizing and Enhancing Aging Bodies. [REVIEW] Medicine Studies 1 (3):187-195.
Timothy F. Murphy (1986). A Cure for Aging? Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 11 (3):237-255.
Noelle Graham (2010). Eating Disorders: The Ethics of Media Reporting. Bioethics Research Notes 22 (2):25.
Paul Jones (2000). Democratic Norms and Means of Communication: Public Sphere, Fourth Estate, Freedom of Communication. Critical Horizons 1 (2):307-339.
Alan Petersen & Kate Seear (2009). In Search of Immortality: The Political Economy of Anti-Aging Medicine. [REVIEW] Medicine Studies 1 (3):267-279.
Douglas Walton (1996). The Witch Hunt as a Structure of Argumentation. Argumentation 10 (3):389-407.
Margaret van Heekeren (2012). The Organic Filament. Collingwood and British Idealism Studies 17 (1):37-61.
Craig M. Klugman (2007). Buying the Fourth Estate. American Journal of Bioethics 7 (8):16 – 18.
Norman Daniels (1998). Does Economics Provide a Unified Account of Aging Behavior and Aging Policy?:Aging and Old Age. Richard Posner. Ethics 108 (3):569-.
Joseph A. Mirando (1998). Lessons on Ethics in News Reporting Textbooks, 1867-1997. Journal of Mass Media Ethics 13 (1):26 – 39.
Doug Childers (1988). Media Practices in Aids Coverage and a Model for Ethical Reporting on Aids Victims. Journal of Mass Media Ethics 3 (2):60 – 65.
Marsha A. Dickson & Molly Eckman (2008). Media Portrayal of Voluntary Public Reporting About Corporate Social Responsibility Performance: Does Coverage Encourage or Discourage Ethical Management? [REVIEW] Journal of Business Ethics 83 (4):725 - 743.
Dennis D. Cali (2002). Journalism After September 11: Unity as Moral Imperative. Journal of Mass Media Ethics 17 (4):290 – 303.
Added to index2011-11-26
Total downloads6 ( #322,860 of 1,725,806 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #348,716 of 1,725,806 )
How can I increase my downloads?