David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Ezio Di Nucci
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Biology and Philosophy 20 (4):767–789 (2005)
The problem of moral compliance is the problem of explaining how moral norms are sustained over extented stretches of time despite the existence of selfish evolutionary incentives that favor their violation. There are, broadly speaking, two kinds of solutions that have been offered to the problem of moral compliance, the reciprocity-based account and the punishment-based account. In this paper, I argue that though the reciprocity-based account has been widely endorsed by evolutionary theorists, the account is in fact deeply implausible. I provide three arguments that suggest that moral norms are sustained by punishment, not reciprocity. But in addition to solving the problem of moral compliance, the punishment-based account provides an additional important theoretical dividend. It points the way for how theorists might build an evolutionary account of a feature of human groups that has long fascinated and troubled social scientists and moral philosophers – the existence of moral diversity.
|Keywords||Moral norms Evolution of morality Reciprocity Punishment Cooperation Evolutionary game theory Moral diversity|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
David Hume (1739/2000). A Treatise of Human Nature. Oxford University Press.
Brian Skyrms (1990). The Dynamics of Rational Deliberation. Harvard University Press.
Allan Gibbard (1990). Norms, Discussion, and Ritual: Evolutionary Puzzles. Ethics 100 (4):787-802.
David Sloane Wilson, Carolyn Wilczynski, Alexandra Wells & Laura Weiser (2000). Gossip and Other Aspects of Language as Group-Level Adaptations. In Celia Heyes & Ludwig Huber (eds.), The Evolution of Cognition. MIT Press
Edward Westermarck (1932/1970). Ethical Relativity. Westport, Conn.,Greenwood Press.
Citations of this work BETA
John Turri & Peter Blouw (2015). Excuse Validation: A Study in Rule-Breaking. Philosophical Studies 172 (3):615-634.
Nicolas Baumard (2010). Has Punishment Played a Role in the Evolution of Cooperation? A Critical Review. Mind and Society 9 (2):171-192.
Brendan Cline (2015). Nativism and the Evolutionary Debunking of Morality. Review of Philosophy and Psychology 6 (2):231-253.
Hisashi Nakao & Edouard Machery (2012). The Evolution of Punishment. Biology and Philosophy 27 (6):833-850.
Amrisha Vaish, Esther Herrmann, Christiane Markmann & Michael Tomasello (2016). Preschoolers Value Those Who Sanction Non-Cooperators. Cognition 153:43-51.
Similar books and articles
Thom Brooks (2003). Kant's Theory of Punishment. Utilitas 15 (2):206.
Bill Wringe (2010). War Crimes and Expressive Theories of Punishment: Communication or Denunciation? Res Publica 16 (2):119-133.
Christopher Bennett (2001). Punishment, Moral Community and Moral Argument: A Review of R.A. Duff,Punishment, Communication and Communityand Matt Matravers,Justice and Punishment: The Rationale of Coercion. [REVIEW] Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 4 (3):101-119.
Alan Wertheimer (1977). Punishing the Innocent — Unintentionally. Inquiry 20 (1-4):45 – 65.
Kyle Swan (2004). Moral Judgment and Emotions. Journal of Value Inquiry 38 (3):375-381.
A. T. Nuyen (2008). Moral Luck, Role-Based Ethics and the Punishment of Attempts. International Journal of Applied Philosophy 22 (1):59-69.
Ben Fraser (2012). The Nature of Moral Judgements and the Extent of the Moral Domain. Philosophical Explorations 15 (1):1-16.
Peter Hobson (1986). The Compatibility of Punishment and Moral Education. Journal of Moral Education 15 (3):221-228.
Ido Weijers (2000). Punishment and Upbringing: Considerations for an Educative Justification of Punishment. Journal of Moral Education 29 (1):61-73.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads87 ( #47,425 of 1,796,251 )
Recent downloads (6 months)6 ( #137,388 of 1,796,251 )
How can I increase my downloads?