David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
The Review of Metaphysics 62 (1):45-59 (2008)
Gordon P. Barnes has recently argued that presence by power is inadequate as an explanation of the way elements are present in complex bodies, and that it would be better to explain the elements’ presence by claiming that simpler substances—carbon atoms, for example—are actually and substantially present in living things. In order to address his arguments, this paper begins by briefly presenting St. Thomas’s understanding of presence by power, and then argues that Barnes’s proposal—that there is a multiplicity of substantial forms in one matter—is unsatisfactory. First, the paper explains why the scientific facts do not require a plurality of substantial forms. Second, it shows how Barnes’s theory does not adequately explain living things. Third, it argues against Barnes’s claim that St. Thomas’s explanation is insufficient because it denies "the universal causality of nature."
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
|Through your library||Configure|
Similar books and articles
Michael Hector Storck (2011). Cogs, Dogs, and Robot Frogs. Proceedings of the American Catholic Philosophical Association 85:253-264.
Nicholaos Jones (2009). Fazang's Total Power Mereology: An Interpretive Analytic Reconstruction. Asian Philosophy 19 (3):199-211.
S. Olsaretti (2013). Coercion and Libertarianism: A Reply to Gordon Barnes. Analysis 73 (2):295-299.
Ludwig Fahrbach (2005). Understanding Brute Facts. Synthese 145 (3):449 - 466.
Jennifer Wilson Mulnix (2011). Explanatory Unification and Scientific Understanding. Acta Philosophica 20 (2):383 - 404.
Massimo Mazzotti (ed.) (2008). Knowledge as Social Order: Rethinking the Sociology of Barry Barnes. Ashgate Pub Co.
Saba Fatima (2012). Presence of Mind. Social Philosophy Today 28:131-146.
Fatima Saba (2012). Presence of Mind. Social Philosophy Today 28:131-146.
Martin Schwab (1986). The Rejection of Origin: Derrida's Interpretation of Husserl. Topoi 5 (2):163-175.
Gordon Barnes (2008). Justification Without Awareness - by Michael Bergmann. Philosophical Books 49 (2):163-164.
Gordon P. Barnes (2003). 1 Introduction. Logos 6 (1).
Gordon Barnes (2003). On Michael DePaul's (Ed.) Resurrecting Old-Fashioned Foundationalism. [REVIEW] Philosophical Books 44 (1):53-62.
Annette Barnes & Jonathan Barnes (1989). Time Out of Joint: Some Reflections on Anachronism. Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 47 (3):253-261.
Gordon Barnes (2000). Modal Inquiry: An Epistemological Study. Dissertation, University of Wisconsin, Madison
Gordon P. Barnes (2002). Resolving the Responsibilism Dilemma. The Monist 85 (3):415-420.
Added to index2011-01-09
Total downloads2 ( #254,287 of 1,004,691 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #64,743 of 1,004,691 )
How can I increase my downloads?