POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY NOW 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd i 12/16/2013 2:17:14 PM Chief Editor of the Series: Howard Williams , Aberystwyth University, Wales Associate Editors: Wolfgang Kersting , University of Kiel, Germany Steven B. Smith , Yale University, USA Peter Nicholson , University of York, England Renato Cristi , Wilfrid Laurier University, Waterloo, Canada Political Philosophy Now is a series which deals with authors, topics and periods in political philosophy from the perspective of their relevance to current debates. The series presents a spread of subjects and points of view from various traditions which include European and New World debates in political philosophy. For other titles in this series, please see the University of Wales Press website: www.uwp.co.uk 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd ii 12/16/2013 2:17:14 PM Politics and Teleology in Kant Edited by Paul Formosa , Avery Goldman and Tatiana Patrone UNIVERSITY OF WALES PRESS • CARDIFF • 2014 POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY NOW 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd iii 12/16/2013 2:17:14 PM © The Contributors, 2014 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any material form (including photocopying or storing it in any medium by electronic means and whether or not transiently or incidentally to some other use of this publication) without the written permission of the copyright owner except in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. Applications for the copyright owner's written permission to reproduce any part of this publication should be addressed to The University of Wales Press, 10 Columbus Walk, Brigantine Place, Cardiff CF10 4UP. www.uwp.co.uk British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. ISBN 978-1-78316-066-2 e-ISBN 978-1-78316-067-9 The right of the Contributors to be identifi ed as authors of this work has been asserted by them in accordance with sections 77, 78 and 79 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd iv 12/16/2013 2:17:14 PM Contents List of Contributors vii List of Abbreviations xiii Introduction: The Connection between Politics and Teleology in Kant 1 Paul Formosa, Avery Goldman and Tatiana Patrone 1 Natural Right in Toward Perpetual Peace 19 Howard Williams 2 The Ends of Politics: Kant on Sovereignty, Civil Disobedience and Cosmopolitanism 37 Paul Formosa 3 The Development of Kant's Cosmopolitanism 59 Pauline Kleingeld 4 Kant's Principles of Publicity 76 Allen Wood 5 Public Reason and Kantian Civic Education, or: Are the Humanities 'Dispensable' and If Not, Why Not? 92 Susan Meld Shell 6 Kant, Justice and Civic Fellowship 110 Sarah Holtman 7 Teleology and the Grounds of Duties of Juridical Right 128 Tatiana Patrone 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd v 12/16/2013 2:17:14 PM 8 The Guarantee of Perpetual Peace: Three Concerns 145 Luigi Caranti 9 Teleology in Kant's Philosophy of History and Political Philosophy 163 Thomas Fiegle 10 The Political Foundations of Prophetic History 180 Sharon Anderson-Gold 11 What Are We Allowed to Hope? Kant's Philosophy of History as Political Philosophy 194 Fotini Vaki 12 The Principle of Purposiveness: From the Beautiful to the Biological and Finally to the Political in Kant's Critique of Judgment 211 Avery Goldman 13 Perfected Humanity: Nature's Final End and the End in Itself 228 Richard Dean 14 Kant's Pure Ethics and the Problem of 'Application' 245 Angelica Nuzzo Index 262 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd vi 12/16/2013 2:17:14 PM Contributors Sharon Anderson-Gold Sharon Anderson-Gold was professor of philosophy at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute. She is the author of Unnecessary Evil: History and Moral Progress in the Philosophy of Immanuel Kant (SUNY Press, 2001) and Cosmopolitanism and Human Rights (University of Wales Press, 2001) and the co-editor of Kant's Anatomy of Evil (Cambridge University Press, 2010). She has written numerous articles on Kant's moral, social and political philosophy and his philosophy of history. She is a past president of the North American Kant Society. For more than thirty years Sharon was a faculty member of Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, where from 2004 she was the chair of the department of science and technology studies. In 2009, Sharon proposed the idea of a collection of essays relating Kant's teleology and philosophy of history; she was one of the initial co-editors of this volume. Sadly, Sharon passed away in 2011. Luigi Caranti Luigi Caranti is associate professor of political philosophy at the Universit à di Catania. He received his Ph.D. from Boston University. Currently a visiting scholar at Columbia University, he was a Marie Curie Fellow at the Philipps-Universit ä t Marburg (November 2005–November 2007). Caranti is the author of Kant and the Scandal of Philosophy (University of Toronto Press, 2007) and the editor of Kant's Perpetual Peace. New Interpretative Essays (Luiss University Press, Rome, 2007). Caranti works on Kant, political philosophy, democratic peace theory and human rights and has published widely in journals such as Kant-Studien , Theoria and Journal of Human Rights . Richard Dean Richard Dean is an assistant professor of philosophy at California State University Los Angeles. He has also taught at the American University of Beirut and at Rutgers University. He received his Ph.D. from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Dean is the author of The Value of Humanity in Kant's Moral Theory (Oxford University Press, 2006), which was nominated for 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd vii 12/16/2013 2:17:14 PM VIII LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS the American Philosophical Association Book Prize, 2007. Dean works in both the history of moral philosophy and contemporary ethical theory, including applied ethics and empirical approaches to ethics, with a strong focus on the role of humanity in Kant's moral philosophy. He has published articles in edited book collections, with presses such as Routledge and Blackwell and in numerous journals, such as Neuroethics , Journal of the History of Philosophy , Utilitas , Pacific Philosophical Quarterly , Kantian Review and Bioethics . Thomas Fiegle Thomas Fiegle is assistant professor of political theory in the faculty of economics and social sciences at the University of Potsdam. He was a postdoctoral fellow at the Centre de Recherches Interdisciplinaires sur l'Allemagne (CRIA) at the Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales, Paris (2002–5). He is the author of Von der Solidarit é zur Solidarit ä t. Ein franz ö sischdeutscher Begriffstransfer (Lit-Verlag, M ü nster, 2003). His research interests are in the areas of Kant and post-Kantian political philosophy, the history of political science and comparative perspectives on political issues such as solidarity and social justice. Fiegle has published widely in collections and journals, such as Jahrbuch f ü r Christliche Sozialwissenschaften , Etudes Compar é es sur la France/ Vergleichende Frankreichforschung , Neue Politische Literatur and Divinatio . Paul Formosa Paul Formosa is an Australian Research Council Discovery Early Career Research Award Fellow and lecturer in the department of philosophy at Macquarie University in Sydney. He was previously a Macquarie University Research Fellow and has also taught at the University of Queensland. He has published widely on Kant, moral evil and a range of topics in moral, social and political philosophy in numerous edited collections with presses such as Oxford University Press, Routledge, De Gruyter and Ashgate and in journals such as European Journal of Philosophy , Kantian Review , Journal of Value Inquiry , Contemporary Political Theory , Social Theory and Practice , Philosophical Forum , Philosophy and Social Criticism and Journal of Social Philosophy . Avery Goldman Avery Goldman is an associate professor of philosophy at DePaul University. He was a postdoctoral teaching fellow at Fordham University (2001–3). He received his Ph.D. from The Pennsylvania State University. Goldman is the author Kant and 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd viii 12/16/2013 2:17:14 PM LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS IX the Subject of Critique: On the Regulative Role of the Psychological Idea (Indiana University Press, 2012). Goldman works on issues related to philosophical methodology, aesthetics and political philosophy, as related to Kant, German Idealism and the phenomenological tradition, and has published widely in journals and collections, including Kant-Studien , Continental Philosophy Review and Epoch é . Sarah Holtman Sarah Holtman is an associate professor of philosophy at the University of Minnesota, Twin Cities. She specialises in Kant's practical philosophy as well as in moral philosophy, political philosophy and philosophy of law. She is the author of various articles on Kant's theory of justice, published in anthologies including The Blackwell Guide to Kant's Ethics (Wiley-Blackwell, 2009) and in journals such as Ethics , Kant-Studien , American Philosophical Quarterly , Jahrbuch f ü r Recht und Ethik and Utilitas. Pauline Kleingeld Pauline Kleingeld is a professor of philosophy at the University of Groningen, the Netherlands and she has previously taught at Leiden University and Washington University in St. Louis. She is the author of Kant and Cosmopolitanism: The Philosophical Ideal of World Citizenship (Cambridge University Press, 2012) and Fortschritt und Vernunft: Zur Geschichtsphilosophie Kants (K ö nigshausen und Neumann, 1995) and the editor of Immanuel Kant, ' Toward Perpetual Peace ' and Other Writings on Politics, Peace, and History (Yale University Press, 2006). Kleingeld has also published widely on Kant, moral theory and philosophical cosmopolitanism in edited collections with presses such as Oxford University Press, Cambridge University Press, Wiley-Blackwell and in journals such as Journal of the History of Philosophy , Philosophical Quarterly , European Journal of Philosophy , KantStudien , Journal of the History of Ideas , Review of Metaphysics , Kantian Review and Philosophy and Public Affairs. She has also held numerous grants and fellowships. Angelica Nuzzo Angelica Nuzzo is professor of philosophy at the Graduate Center and Brooklyn College (City University of New York). She has been Leonard and Claire Tow Professor (2012–13), recipient of a Mellon Fellowship in the humanities (2007–8) and an Alexander von Humboldt Fellowship (2005–6) and has been a fellow at the Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Studies at Harvard 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd ix 12/16/2013 2:17:14 PM X LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS (2000–1). Among her recent publications are Memory, History, Justice in Hegel (Palgrave Macmillan, 2012), Ideal Embodiment. Kant's Theory of Sensibility (Indiana University Press, 2008) and the two edited collections: Hegel on Religion and Politics (SUNY Press, 2013) and Hegel and the Analytic Tradition (Continuum, 2009). Tatiana Patrone Tatiana Patrone is an associate professor of philosophy at Ithaca College, New York. She specialises in Kant's practical philosophy and the history of German philosophy, as well as issues in political and applied philosophy more generally. She received her Ph.D. from University at Albany (SUNY) and taught at the University of Arkansas, Fayetteville and Montclair State University, NJ. She is the author of How Kant's Conception of Reason Implies a Liberal Politics: An Interpenetration of the ' Doctrine of Right ' (The Edwin Mellen Press, 2008) and various articles on Kant's practical philosophy. She is currently working on a book on Kant's 'fact of reason'. Susan Meld Shell Susan Meld Shell is professor and chair of the department of political science at Boston College. She received her Ph.D. from Harvard University. Shell is the author of Kant and the Limits of Autonomy (Harvard University Press, 2009), The Embodiment of Reason: Kant on Spirit, Generation and Community (University of Chicago Press, 1996) and The Rights of Reason: A Study of Kant's Philosophy and Politics (University of Toronto Press, 1980). She is also the co-editor (with Richard Velkley) of Kant's ' Observations ' and ' Remarks ' : A Critical Guide (Cambridge University Press, 2012) and (with Robert Faulkner) of America at Risk: Threats to Liberal Self-Government in an Age of Uncertainty (University of Michigan Press, 2009). She has been a visiting professor at Harvard University and received fellowships from The National Endowment for the Humanities, The American Council of Learned Societies, The Bradley Foundation and the Radcliffe Institute. Shell has also written on Rousseau, German Idealism and selected areas of public policy. She has published over forty articles in a range of edited collections, with presses such as Cambridge University, University of Chicago Press, Routledge, De Gruyter and others and in numerous journals, including Kantian Review , Yearbook of German Idealism , Eighteenth-Century Studies , Political Science Reviewer , Journal of Democracy , Polity and Political Theory . 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd x 12/16/2013 2:17:14 PM LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS XI Fotini Vaki Fotini Vaki is a senior lecturer in the history of philosophy at the department of history at Ionian University, Greece. She received her MA and Ph.D. in philosophy from the University of Essex. Before joining Ionian University she taught at the University of Patras and the University of Crete. She is the author of articles both in Greek and English on the European Enlightenment, German Idealism (in particular Kant and Hegel), Marx and the Frankfurt School (especially Adorno and Habermas). Her articles have appeared in a range of edited collections, with presses such as Rodopi and Brill and in journals such as Adam Smith Review and Philosophical Inquiry . She recently published a book in Greek under the title, Progress in the Enlightenment: Faces and Facets . Howard Williams Howard Williams is professor emeritus in political theory at the department of international politics, Aberystwyth University, Wales. He is the author most recently of Kant and the End of War (Palgrave Macmillan, 2012) and of Kant's Critique of Hobbes: Sovereignty and Cosmopolitanism (University of Wales Press, 2003), International Relations and the Limits of Political Theory (Macmillan, 1996), International Relations in Political Theory (Open University Press, 1992, reprinted 1992, 1993, 1994), Hegel, Heraclitus and Marx's Dialectic (St. Martin's Press, 1989), Concepts of Ideology (Harvester Wheatsheaf, 1988) and Kant's Political Philosophy (Blackwell, 1983). He is the editor of Essays on Kant's Political Philosophy (University of Wales Press, 1992) and the co-editor of Political Thought and German Reunification (Macmillan, 1999) and A Reader in International Relations and Political Theory (Open University Press, 1993). Williams is currently editor of the Kantian Review . He has been visiting professor in the departments of philosophy at Halle University, Germany, Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada and Krakow University, Poland and twice at Stanford University, as well as visiting DAAD Fellow at Humboldt University, Berlin. He has published over fi fty articles in numerous edited collections, with presses such as Brill, Palgrave, De Gruyter, Blackwell, Cambridge University Press, Routledge, University of Wales Press and Oxford University Press and in journals such as Review of International Studies , Politics and Ethics Review , International Relations , Kantian Review , Kant-Studien , History of European Ideas , Political Studies , Journal of the History of Political Thought , Idealistic Studies and Philosophical Quarterly. 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd xi 12/16/2013 2:17:14 PM XII LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS Allen Wood Allen Wood's interests are in the history of modern philosophy, especially Kant and German idealism and in ethics and social philosophy. He was born in Seattle, Washington: BA Reed College in Portland, Oregon, Ph.D. Yale University. He has held regular professorships at Cornell University, Yale University and Stanford University, where he is Ward W. and Priscilla B. Woods Professor Emeritus. He has also held visiting appointments at the University of Michigan, University of California at San Diego and Oxford University, where he was Isaiah Berlin Visiting Professor in 2005. During year-long periods of research, he has been affi liated with the Freie Universit ä t Berlin in 1983–4 and the Rheinische-Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universit ä t Bonn in 1991–2. Wood is author of many articles and chapters in philosophical journals and anthologies. The book-length publications he has authored include: Kantian Ethics (Cambridge University Press, 2008), Kant (Blackwell, 2004), Unsettling Obligations (CSLI Publications, 2002), Kant's Ethical Thought (Cambridge University Press, 1999), Hegel's Ethical Thought (Cambridge University Press, 1990), Karl Marx (Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1981, second expanded edition Taylor and Francis, 2004), Kant's Rational Theology (Cornell University Press, 1978, reissued 2009) and Kant's Moral Religion (Cornell University Press, 1970, reissued 2009). His next book, The Free Development of Each: Studies in Reason, Right and Ethics in Classical German Philosophy , is due to appear with Oxford University Press. He is also currently working on a book on Fichte's Ethical Thought . Allen Wood is general editor (with Paul Guyer) of the Cambridge Edition of Kant's Writings in English Translation , for which he has edited, translated or otherwise contributed to six volumes. Among the other books he has edited are The Cambridge History of Philosophy in the Nineteenth Century (1790–1870) (with Songsuk Susan Hahn, Cambridge University Press, 2012), Fichte: Attempt at a Critique of All Revelation (Cambridge University Press, 2010), Kant: Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals (Yale University Press, 2002), Hegel: Elements of the Philosophy of Right (Cambridge University Press, 1991) and Self and Nature in Kant's Philosophy (Cornell University Press, 1984). 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd xii 12/16/2013 2:17:15 PM List of Abbreviations All writings of Immanuel Kant are cited by the volume and page number of the Akademie Edition (AA): Immanuel Kants gesammelte Schriften , Ausgabe der k ö niglich preussischen Akademie der Wissenschaften (Berlin: W. de Gruyter, 1902–). Except where indicated, all translations of Kant's writings are from the Cambridge Edition of the Works of Immanuel Kant (CE) (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1992–). The following abbreviations for Kant's writing are used throughout this volume. These abbreviations are based on the list of abbreviations given in the 'Style Sheet for Authors' of the journal Kant-Studien . Anth Anthropologie in pragmatischer Hinsicht (AA 07). Anthropology from a Pragmatic Point of View . Translated by R. B. Louden in CE: Kant, I. (2007) Anthropology, History, and Education , ed. G. Z ö ller and R. B. Louden (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). Br Briefe (AA 10–13). Correspondence . A selection from these volumes is translated by A. Zweig in CE: Kant, I. (1999) Correspondence , ed. A. Zweig (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). EaD Das Ende aller Dinge (AA 08). The End of All Things. Translated by A. W. Wood in CE: Kant, I. (1996) Religion and Rational Theology , ed. A. W. Wood and G. di Giovanni (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). EEKU Erste Einleitung in die Kritik der Urteilskraft (AA 20). First Introduction to the Critique of the Power of Judgment . Translated by P. Guyer and E. Matthews in CE: Kant, I. (2000) Critique of the Power of Judgment , ed. P. Guyer (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). GMS Grundlegung zur Metaphysik der Sitten (AA 04). Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals . Translated by M. J. Gregor in CE: Kant, I. (1996) Practical Philosophy , ed. M. J. Gregor (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd xiii 12/16/2013 2:17:15 PM XIV LIST OF ABBBREVIATIONS GSE Beobachtungen ü ber das Gef ü hl des Sch ö nen und Erhabenen (AA 02). Observations on the Feeling of the Beautiful and Sublime . Translated by P. Guyer in CE: Anthropology, History, and Education . IaG Idee zu einer allgemeinen Geschichte in weltb ü rgerlicher Absicht (AA 08). 'Idea for a Universal History with a Cosmopolitan Aim'. Translated by A. W. Wood in CE: Anthropology, History, and Education . KpV Kritik der praktischen Vernunft (AA 05). Critique of Practical Reason . Translated by M. J. Gregor in CE: Practical Philosophy . KrV Kritik der reinen Vernunft. Critique of Pure Reason . Translated by P. Guyer and A. W. Wood in CE: Kant, I. (1998) Critique of Pure Reason , ed. P. Guyer and A. W. Wood (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). KU Kritik der Urteilskraft (AA 05). Critique of the Power of Judgment . Translated by P. Guyer and E. Matthews in CE: Critique of the Power of Judgment . Log Logik (AA 09). The J ä sche Logic . Translated by J. M. Young in CE: Kant, I. (1992) Lectures on Logic , ed. J. M. Young (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). MAM Mutma ß licher Anfang der Menschheitsgeschichte (AA 08). Conjectural Beginning of Human History . Translated by A. W. Wood in CE: Anthropology, History, and Education . MS Die Metaphysik der Sitten (AA 06). The Metaphysics of Morals . Translated by M. J. Gregor in CE: Practical Philosophy . Nach Nachschrift zu Christian Gottlieb Mielckes Littauischdeutschem und deutsch-littauischem W ö rterbuch (AA 08). Postscript to Christian Gottlieb Mielcke's Lithauanian– German and German–Lithuanian Dictionary. Translated by G. Z ö ller in CE: Anthropology, History, and Education . P ä d P ä dagogik (AA 09). Lectures on Pedagogy . Translated by R. B. Louden in CE: Anthropology, History, and Education . Refl Refl exion (AA 14–19). Reflections . A selection from these volumes is translated by C. Bowman, P. Guyer and F. Rauscher in CE: Kant, I. (2005) Notes and Fragments , ed. P. Guyer (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd xiv 12/16/2013 2:17:15 PM LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS XV RezHufeland Recension von Gottlieb Hufeland's Versuch ü ber den Grundsatz des Naturrechts (AA 08). Review of Gottlieb Hufeland's Essay on the Principles of Natural Right . Translated by A. W. Wood in CE: Practical Philosophy . RGV Die Religion innerhalb der Grenzen der blo ß en Vernunft (AA 06). Religion within the Boundaries of Mere Reason . Translated by G. di Giovanni in CE: Religion and Rational Theology. RL Metaphysische Anfangsgr ü nde der Rechtslehre (AA 06). Metaphysical First Principles of the Doctrine of Right . SF Der Streit der Fakult ä ten (AA 07). The Conflict of the Faculties . Translated by M. J. Gregor and R. Anchor in CE: Religion and Rational Theology . TP Ü ber den Gemeinspruch: Das mag in der Theorie richtig sein, taugt aber nicht f ü r die Praxis (AA 08). On the Common Saying: That May Be Correct in Theory, but It Is of No Use in Practice . Translated by M. J. Gregor in CE: Practical Philosophy . Ü GTP Ü ber den Gebrauch teleologischer Principien in der Philosophie (AA 08). On the use of Teleological Principles in Philosophy . Translated by G. Z ö ller in CE: Anthropology, History, and Education . VAMS Vorarbeit zur Metaphysik der Sitten (AA 23). Preliminary notes for Metaphysics of Morals. VAZeF Vorarbeiten zu Zum ewigen Frieden (AA 23). Preliminary notes for Toward Perpetual Peace . V-Anth/Fried Vorlesungen Wintersemester 1775/1776 Friedl ä nder (AA 25). Anthropology Friedl ä nder (1775–1776) . Translated by G. Felicitas Munzel in CE: Kant, I. (2012) Lectures on Anthropology , ed. A. W. Wood and R. B. Louden (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). V-Anth/Mensch Vorlesungen Wintersemester 1781/1782 Menschenkunde, Petersburg (AA 25). 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd xv 12/16/2013 2:17:15 PM XVI LIST OF ABBBREVIATIONS Menschenkunde (1781–1782) . Excerpts translated by R. B. Louden in CE: Lectures on Anthropology . V-Lo/Dohna Logik Dohna-Wundlacken (AA 24). The DohnaWundlacken Logic . Translated by J. M. Young in CE: Lectures on Logic . V-Lo/Wiener Wiener Logik (AA 24). The Vienna Logic . Translated by J. M. Young in CE: Lectures on Logic . V-Met/Mron Metaphysik Mrongovius (AA 29). Metaphysics : Mrongovius's Lecture Notes . In CE: Kant, I. (1997) Lectures on Metaphysics , trans. and ed. K. Ameriks and S. Naragon (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). V-Mo/Collins Moralphilosophie Collins (AA 27). Moral Philosophy: Collins's Lecture Notes . Translated by P. Heath in CE: Kant, I. (1997) Lectures on Ethics , ed. P. Heath and J. B. Schneewind (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). WA Beantwortung der Frage: Was ist Aufkl ä rung? (AA 08). An Answer to the Question: What is Enlightenment? Translated by M. J. Gregor in CE: Practical Philosophy . ZeF Zum ewigen Frieden (AA 08). Toward Perpetual Peace . Translated by M. J. Gregor in CE: Practical Philosophy . 9781783160662pre_pi-xvi.indd xvi 12/16/2013 2:17:15 PM