Sorry ..

The PhilPapers forums are about to be replaced by a new service. As a first step toward this transition, we are no longer allowing new threads to be posted. We apologize for the inconvenience. We suggest that forum participants also do not start new discussions within existing threads, as these discussions may be interupted when we move to the new service. The transition to the new service will occur no earlier than April 2017 (possibly significantly later).