초록

Theories of Justice would be understand as a subject that dealt with liberalist view, based on methodological abstraction. But Michael Walzer tried to approach Justice in view of equality in accordance with shared cultural background of certain community. Methodological abstraction of John Rawls has internal difficulties such that the concept of value or properties which is separated from social context of community, and that the hardship of reflecting democratic ideas of the society’s actual members. Thus, Michael Walzer’s Complex Equality or Egalitarianism focuses on multiple ways of various cultures’ various value system and distributive principle that composes their own society. Based on this, Walzer insists that formulation and creation of values takes priority and controls its distribution. According to Walzer, separated values could exclusively occupied but could not shifted other types of values in the Society of Complex Equality. Spheres of Complex Equality defines the range of sharing social communication or meaning, and its fundamentals are free exchange, desert, and need. This principles would be approved as an exclusive rules of each own, or suggested as the same dominant principles side by side. Complex Equality or Egalitarianism could be a logical basis of critical socialization, for it rejects and criticizes tyranny. It also formulates motivation of moral practice for social participation or interpersonal competence, by defining the Domain of Justice and trying to apply the Principle of Distribution which characterizes Complex Equality or Egalitarianism.

키워드

Social Ideas, Social Justice, Distributional Justice, Complex Equality, Egalitarianism, Communitarianism, Moral Education, Moral Practice

참고문헌(52)open

  1. [단행본] Hong, Sungwoo / 2005 / Liberalism and Communitarianism Ethics / Seonhak Press

  2. [단행본] Kim, Miyoung / 2006 / Modern Communitarianism / Korean Studies Information

  3. [단행본] Kymlicka, Will / 2006 / Contemporary Political Philosophy / Dongmyung Press

  4. [단행본] Mulhall, Stephen / 2001 / Liberals and Communitarians / Hanwool

  5. [단행본] Sandel, Michael / 2012 / Liberalism and the Limits of Justic / Melon Press

  6. [단행본] Schumaker, Paul / 2010 / From Ideologies to Public Philosophies: An Introduction to Political Theory / Humanitas

  7. [단행본] Walzer, Michael / 1999 / Spheres of Justice / Philosophy & Practice

  8. [학술대회] Hwang, Kyungsik / 1999 / Why Liberalism and Communitarianism? Conflicts and establishment between individual rights and common good / Proceedings of Spring Seminar, Research Society of Philosophy : 1 ~ 18

  9. [학술대회] Research Society of Philosophy / 1999 / Liberalism and Communitarianism / Proceeding of SNU Research Society of Philosophy

  10. [단행본] Walzer, Michael / 2001 / Beyond Liberalism: Dasan Memorial Philosophy Lecture 3 / Philosophy & Practice

  11. [단행본] Walzer, Michael / 2004 / On Toleration: The Castle Lectures in Ethics, Politics, and Economics / Mitto Press

  12. [단행본] Walzer, Michael / 2007 / Interpretation and Social Criticism / Philosophy & Practice

  13. [단행본] Walzer, Michael / 2009 / Thinking Politically: Essays in Political Theory / Motive Book

  14. [학술지] Armstrong, Chris / 2002 / Complex Eqality: Beyond Eqality and Difference / Feminist Theory 3 : 67 ~ 82

  15. [학술지] Arneson, Richard J / 1990 / Against ‘Complex Equality’ / Public Affairs Quarterly 4 (2) : 99 ~ 110

  16. [학술지] 변순용 / 2010 / 다문화 사회 및 글로벌 시대에 요구되는 도덕교육의 핵심덕목으로서의 관용에 대한 연구 / 도덕윤리과교육 31 (31) : 133 ~ 152

  17. [학술지] Cohen, Joshua / 1986 / Review of ‘Spheres of Justice: A Defense of Pluralism and Equality’ by Michael Walzer / The Journal of Philosophy : 457 ~ 468

  18. [학술지] Doppelt, Gerald / 1978 / Walzer’s Theory of Morality in International Relations / Philosophy & Public Affairs 8 (1) : 3 ~ 26

  19. [학술지] Gill, Emily R. / 1987 / Walzer’s Complex Equality: Constraints & The Right to be Wrong / Polity 20 (1) : 32 ~ 56

  20. [학술지] Green, S. J. D. / 1988 / Is Equality of Opportunity a False Ideal for Society? / The British Journal of Sociology 39 (1) : 1 ~ 27

  21. [학술지] 정현철 / 2010 / 왈쩌의 공동체주의적 사회비판의 역동성과 전망 / 가톨릭철학 15 (15) : 185 ~ 214

  22. [학술지] Kim, Eunhee / 2007 / Comparative analysis on methodology for political philosophy between Rawls and Walzer / Philosophical Forum 35 : 271 ~ 297

  23. [학술지] Kim, Hyungryul / 2008 / A Study on the possibilities of realizing Distributional Justice in Korean Education Environment: Focusing on Rawls and Walzer / Outstanding Termpapers 6 : 39 ~ 64

  24. [학위논문] Kim, Minhyuk / 2011 / Study on M. Walzers democratic engagement of political philosophy: theory and cases of Walzers social criticism

  25. [학술지] Kim, Yangja / 2001 / Suggestions of Walzer's Complex Equality to Korea Education / Research on Social Studies Education 10 : 65 ~ 87

  26. [학위논문] Lee, Sangho / 2010 / M. Walzer's Theory of Complex Equality and Public Administration

  27. [학위논문] Lee, Sunghan / 2000 / A Study on M. Walzer’s Complex Equality

  28. [학술지] 임의영 / 2007 / 사회적 형평성의 정의론적 논거모색:R. Dworkin의 ‘자원평등론’을 중심으로 / 행정논총 45 (3) : 1 ~ 22

  29. [학술지] 임의영 / 2009 / 사회적 형평성의 정의론적 논거 모색: M. Walzer의 ‘다원주의적 정의론’을 중심으로 / 한국행정학보 43 (2) : 1 ~ 18

  30. [학술지] Mayer, Robert / 2001 / Michael Walzer, Industrial Democracy, and Complex Equality / Political Theory 29 (2) : 237 ~ 261

  31. [학술지] 문성훈 / 2011 / 타자에 대한 책임, 관용, 환대 그리고 인정 - 레비나스, 왈쩌, 데리다, 호네트를 중심으로 / 사회와 철학 (21) : 391 ~ 418

  32. [학술지] Moon, Sungwon / 2001 / The Liberalist View of Justice in the Epoche of Globalization: Liberalism and Justice / Period and Philosophy 12 (2) : 277 ~ 301

  33. [학술지] Mullenix, Linda S. / 1984 / The Limits of Complex Equality / Harvard Law Review 97 (7) : 1801 ~ 1811

  34. [학술지] 남현주 / 2011 / 시민사회와 사회정의의 맥락에서 본 연대성의 위기와 그 극복 - 뒤르깽, 하버마스, 롤즈 그리고 왈쩌의 입장을 중심으로 - / 사회보장연구 27 (4) : 137 ~ 164

  35. [학술지] Nayak, Pulin B. / 1991 / On Equality and Distributive Justice / Economic and Political Weekly 26 (11/12) : 583 ~ 590

  36. [학술지] Oh, Hyunchul / 2004 / Walzer's Complex Egalitarianism and Plural Communitarianism / Citizen and World 6 : 353 ~ 361

  37. [학술지] Park, Jungsoon / 1999 / Michael Walzer’s Communitarianism / Philosophy and Practice 41 : 175 ~ 198

  38. [학술지] 박정순 / 2003 / 공동체주의적 사회비판의 가능성 / 범한철학 30 (30) : 211 ~ 248

  39. [학술지] Park, Jungsoon / 2007 / The Philosophic Origins of Complex Equality / Researches on Philosophy 76 : 93 ~ 117

  40. [학술지] Rosenblum, Nancy L / 1984 / Moral Membership in a postliberal State: Reviews on Spheres of Justice: A Defense of Pluralism and Equality. by Michael Walzer / World Politics 36 (4) : 581 ~ 596

  41. [학술지] Shachar, Ayelet / 2007 / Citizenship as Inherited Property / Political Theory 35 (3) : 253 ~ 287

  42. [학술지] 손철성 / 2008 / 다문화주의와 관련된 몇 가지 쟁점들 / 철학연구 107 (2008) : 1 ~ 26

  43. [학술지] 손철성 / 2012 / 공동체의 성원권과 외국인 노동자의 지위 / 윤리교육연구 29 (29) : 361 ~ 380

  44. [학술지] Son, Joonjong / 1999 / Debates on Distributive Justice for Just Opportunity of Education: Focusing on M.Walzer’s Theory / Sociology of Education 9 (2) : 121 ~ 142

  45. [학술지] 설한 / 2003 / 마이클 왈쩌(M. Walzer)의 정치철학: 정의(正義)의 영역과 사회비판 / 한국정치학회보 37 (3) : 27 ~ 48

  46. [학술지] Veen, Robert J. van der / 1999 / The Adjudicating Citizen: On Equal Membership in Walzer's Theory of Justice / British Journal of Political Science 29 (2) : 225 ~ 258

  47. [학술지] Walzer, Michael / 1984 / Liberalism and the Art of Separation / Political Theory 12 (3) : 315 ~ 330

  48. [학술지] Walzer, Michael / 1990 / The Communitarian Critique of Liberalism / Political Theory 18 (1) : 6 ~ 23

  49. [학술지] Walzer, Michael / 2000 / Communitarian complementation on Liberalism and Philosophical Guide for Society of Pluralistic Equity / Philosophy & Practice 45 : 136 ~ 179

  50. [단행본] Walzer, Michael / 2003 / Contemporary Political Theory: A Reader / SAGE : 134 ~ 150

  51. [학위논문] Yi, Kangbin / 2000 / A Critical Study on the Conception of Justice in Communitarianism

  52. [학술지] Youn Jinsook / 2007 / Michael Walzer's Defense of Pluralistic Justice / Soong Sil Law Review 17 : 193 ~ 210