Metaphysical Myths, Mathematical Practice: The Ontology and Epistemology of the Exact Sciences

Front Cover
Cambridge University Press, Feb 25, 1994 - Mathematics - 249 pages
This original and exciting study offers a completely new perspective on the philosophy of mathematics. Most philosophers of mathematics try to show either that the sort of knowledge mathematicians have is similar to the sort of knowledge specialists in the empirical sciences have or that the kind of knowledge mathematicians have, although apparently about objects such as numbers, sets, and so on, isn't really about those sorts of things at all. Jody Azzouni argues that mathematical knowledge is a special kind of knowledge that must be gathered in its own unique way. He analyzes the linguistic pitfalls and misperceptions philosophers in this field are often prone to, and explores the misapplications of epistemic principles from the empirical sciences to the exact sciences. What emerges is a picture of mathematics sensitive both to mathematical practice and to the ontological and epistemological issues that concern philosophers. The book will be of special interest to philosophers of science, mathematics, logic, and language. It should also interest mathematicians themselves.
 

Contents

Metaphysical Inertness
3
Metaphysical Inertness and Reference
6
The Virtues of SecondOrder Theft
11
Intuitions about Reference and Axiom Systems
18
Comparing Mathematical Terms and Empirical Terms I
31
Comparing Mathematical Terms and Empirical Terms II 48
48
The Epistemic Role Puzzle
55
Benacerrafs Puzzle
58
Application and Truth
88
Systems Application and Truth
94
Quines Objections to Truth by Convention
105
Grades of Ontological Commitment
118
Multiply Interpreting Systems
132
Intuitions about Reference Revisited
139
Introduction
153
Some Observations on Metamathematics
171

Comparing Puzzles
60
Quines Approach I
64
Quines Approach II
71
POSITS AND ALGORITHMS
77
Introduction
79
An Initial Picture
80
Why There Are No Incorrigible Coempirical Truths
192
Normative Considerations the Success of Applied
204
Appendix
215
Bibliography
236
Index
246
Copyright

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

Bibliographic information