Abstract
Political philosophy has difficulties to cope with the complexity and variety of state-religions relations. ‘Strict separationism’ is still the preferred option amongst liberals, deliberative and republican democrats, socialist and feminists. In this article, I develop a complex typology based on comparative history and sociology of religions. I summarize my reasons why institutional pluralist models like plural establishment or non-constitutional pluralism are attractive not only for religious minorities but for religiously deeply diverse societies in general. Most attention is paid defending associative democracy, the most flexible and open variety of institutional pluralism, against realist objections that group representation is incompatible with liberal democracy, that it leads to stigmatization and bureaucratization, that it strengthens undemocratic leaders, that it leads to an ossification of the status quo, and, most importantly, that it is inherently divisive undermining social cohesion and political unity. In my refutation of these objections I try to show that it helps to integrate minority religions into liberal democratic policies compatible with reasonable pluralism and to prevent religious and political fundamentalism.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ahonen, P., A Minority State-Church in a Liberal Democracy. ECPR Copenhagen, 14–19 April, 2000.
Bader, V.M., Kollektives Handeln. Opladen: Leske + Budrich, 1991.
Bader, V.M., Incorporation. Unpublished Manuscript (http://home.hum.uva.nl/oz/baderv), 1996.
Bader, V.M., Egalitarian Multiculturalism: Institutional separation and Cultural Pluralism, in R. Bauböck and J. Rundell (eds.), Blurred Boundaries. Aldershot, Ashgate, 1998, pp. 185–220.
Bader, V.M., Dilemmas of Ethnic Affirmative Action. Benign State-neutrality or Relational Ethnic Neutrality, Citizenship Studies 2(3) (1998a), pp. 435–473.
Bader, V.M., Religious Pluralism. Secularism or Priority for Democracy?, Political Theory 27(5), October 1999, pp. 597–633.
Bader, V.M., How to Institutionalize Religious Pluralism? Conference Paper, Bremen, May 2000.
Bader, V.M., Culture and Identity. Contesting Constructivism, in Ethnicities 1(2) (April 2001), pp. 251–285.
Bader, V.M., Problems and Prospects of Associative Democracy, in P. Hirst and V. Bader (eds.), Associative Democracy — The Real Third Way? CRISPP 4(1), January 2001a, pp. 31–70.
Bader, V.M., Associative Democracy and the Incorporation of Ethnic and National Minorities, in P. Hirst and V. Bader (eds.), Associative Democracy. The Real Third Way. London: Frank Cass, 2001b, pp. 187–202.
Bader, V.M., Cohesion, Unity and Stability in Modern Societies, in A. v. Harskamp and A.A. Musschenga (eds.), The Many Faces of Individualism. Leuven: Peeters, 2001c, pp. 107–132.
Bader, V.M., Ethnic and Religious State-Neutrality: Utopia or Myth? (2001d), in Hakan Sicakkan and Yngve Lithman (eds.), Modes of Belonging and Politics of Recognition. Berg, 2003 (forthcoming).
Bader, V.M., Pluralisme ernstig nemen. Politieke Filosofie en het Neo-Institionalisme. Pleidooi voor een institutionele wending in de politieke filosofie, Ethiek & Maatschappij 4(3) (Oktober 2001 (2001e)), pp. 11–36.
Bader, V.M., Democratic Institutional Pluralism and Cultural Diversity. (2001f), in Danielle Juteau and Christiane Harzig (eds.), Life in Diversity. Berghan, 2003 (forthcoming).
Bader, V.M., “Diversity within Unity”: A Dialogue Opener (A. Etzioni). Critical Remarks and Suggestions (2001g).
Bader, V.M., Religious Diversity and Democratic Institutional Pluralism (2002), Political Theory 2003.
Bader, V.M., Democratic Institutional Pluralism. Conference ECIP, Amsterdam, July (2002a).
Bader, V.M., Associative Democracy and Minorities within Minorities. Conference Lincoln, Nebraska, October 2002 (2002b).
Bader, V.M., Taking Religious Pluralism Seriously. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 6(1) (2003), pp. 3–22.
Barker, E., Beckford, J., and Dobbelaere, K. (eds.), Secularization, Rationalism and Sectarianism. Oxford: Clarendon, 1993.
Barrett, D (ed.), The World Christian Encyclopedia. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1982.
Bruce, S. (ed.), Religion and Modernization. Oxford: Clarendon, 1992.
Carens, J., Culture, Citizenship, and Community. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000.
Casanova, J., Public Religions in the Modern World. Chicago/London: University of Chicago Press, 1994.
Chaves, M., and Cann, D., Regulation, Pluralism, and Religious Market Structure, Rationality and Society 4 (1992), pp. 272–290.
Cole Durham, Jr., W., The Right to Autonomy in Religious Affairs: A Comparative View, in G. Robbers (ed.), Church Autonomy. Frankfurt a. M.: Peter Lang, 2001, pp. 683–714.
Demerath, N.J., and Williams, R.H., A. Mythical Past and an Uncertain Future, in T. Robbins and R. Robertson (eds.), Church-State Relations. New Brunswick: Transaction Inc., 1987, pp. 77–90.
Doomernik, J., The Institutionalization of Turkish Islam in Germany and the Netherlands, Ethnic and Racial Studies 18(1) (1995).
Eisenach, E.J., The Next Religious Establishment. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield, 2000.
Eisenberg, A., Reconstructing Political Pluralism. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1995.
Esbeck, C., A Typology of Church-State Relations in Current American Thought, in Lugo (ed.), Religion, Public Life, and the American Polity. Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press, 2001, pp. 3–36.
Galanter, M., Religious Freedoms in the United States. A Turning Point, Wisconsin Law Review (1996), pp. 217–296.
Galston, W., Liberal Pluralism. Cambridge University Press, 2002.
Gowricharn, R., and Saharso, S. (eds.), Islam in Nederland. Themanummer Migrantenstudies 13(3) (1997).
Grillo, R.D., Pluralism and the Politics of Difference. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1998.
Greenawalt, K., Private Consciences and Public Reasons. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995.
Greenawalt, K., Five Questions about Religion Judges are Afraid to Ask, in N. Rosenblum (ed.), Obligations of Citizenship and Demands of Faith. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000, pp. 196–244.
Handy, R.T., A History of the Churches in the United States and Canada. Oxford: Clarendon, 1976.
Heikkilae, M., Knuutila, J., and Scheinin, M., State and Church in Finaldn, in G. Robbers (ed.), State and Church in the European Union. Baden-Baden: Nomos, 1996, pp. 279–294.
Hirsch, H.N., Let Them Eat Incidentals, in N. Rosenblum (ed.), Obligations of Citizenship and Demands of Faith. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000, pp. 280–293.
Hirst, P., Associative Democracy. Cambridge: Polity Press, 1994.
Hirst, P., and J.N. Figgis, Churches and the State, in D. Marquand and R. Nettler (eds.), Obligations of Citizenship and Demands of Faith. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000, pp. 104–120.
Hirst, P., Comment. Amsterdam workshop, June 29, 2001.
Hoekema, A. et al., Integraal Bestuur. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press, 1998.
Hoekema, A. et al., Negotiating governance and indigenous self-rule, in P. Hirst and V. Bader (eds.), Associative Democracy. The Real Third Way. London: Frank Cass, 2001, pp. 157–186.
Hollinger, D., Religious Disestablishment in Western Europe, The Responsive Community (2002) (forthcoming).
Horowitz, D., Making Moderation Pay, in J. Montville (ed.), Conflict and Peace-Making in Multiethnic Societies. New York: Lexington, 1991, pp. 115–130.
Jacobsohn, R.J., By the Light of Reason, in N. Rosenblum (ed.), Obligations of Citizenship and Demands of Faith. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000, pp. 294–320.
Israel, J.I., The Dutch Republic. Oxford: Clarendon, 1995.
Kaspersen, L., and Ottesen, L., Associationalism for 150 Years, in P. Hirst and V.M. Bader (eds.), Associative Democracy. The Real Third Way. London: Frank Cass, 2001, pp. 105–130.
Kalyvas, S., The Rise of Christian Democracy in Europe. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1996.
Keane, J., Secularism? in D. Marquand and R. Nettler (eds.), Obligations of Citizenship and Demands of Faith. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000, pp. 5–19.
Khilnani, S., The Idea of India. New York: Farrar, Straus, Giroux, 1999.
Koopmans, R., Zachte heelmeesters..., Migrantenstudies 2 (2002), pp. 87–92.
Kymlicka, W., Multicultural Citizenship. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995.
Kymlicka, W., States, Nations and Cultures. Assen: van Gorcum, 1997.
Kymlicka, W., Contemporary Political Philosophy, 2nd. Ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001.
Kymlicka, W., and Norman, W. (eds.), Citizenship in Diverse Societies. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000.
Lash, K., Five Models of Church Autonomy, in G. Robbers (eds.), State and Church in the European Union. Baden-Baden: Nomos, 2001, pp. 303–319.
Lehmbruch, G., Der Beitrag der Korporatismusforschung zur Entwicklung der Steuerungstheorie, Politische Vierteljahres Schrift 17(4) (1996), pp. 735–751.
Lijphart, A., Democracies. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1984.
Lijphart, A., Self-Determination vs. Pre-Determination in Powersharing Systems, in W. Kymlicka (ed.), The Rights of Minority Cultures. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995, pp. 275–287.
Luckmann, T., Invisible Religion. New York, MacMillan, 1967.
Luhmann, N., Funktion der Religion. Frankfurt, M. Suhrkamp, 1977.
Luhmann, N., Die Religion der Gesellschaft. Frankfurt/M.: Suhrkamp, 2001.
Madeley, J., Towards an Inclusive Typology of Church-State Relations in Europe. ECPR Copenhagen, 14–19 April, 2000.
Marquand, D., and Nettler, R. (eds.), Religion and Democracy. Oxford: Blackwell, 2000.
Martin, D., A General Theory of Secularization. New York: Harper & Row, 1978.
McLeod, H., Religion and the People of Western Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1981.
McConnell, M., Accommodation of Religion, George Washington Law Review 60(3) (1992), pp. 685–742.
McConnell, M., Believers as Equal Citizens, in N. Rosenblum (ed.), Obligations of Citizenship and Demands of Faith. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000, pp. 90–110.
Minnerath, R., Church Autonomy in Europe, in G. Robbers (ed.), Church Autonomy. Frankfurt a. M.: Peter Lang, 2001, pp. 381–394.
Miller, W.L., The First Liberty. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, Inc., 1985.
Minkenberg, M., Religion and Policy Effects. ECPR Copenhagen, 14–19 April, 2000.
Monsma, S., and Soper, C., The Challenge of Pluralism. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield, 1997.
Modood, T. (ed.), Church, State and Religious Minorities. London, Policy Studies Institute, 1996 (contributions by Tariq Modood, Bikhu Parekh, Anne Phillips, Bishop Michael Nazir-Ali, Vaerie Pitt, Adrian Hastings, Jim Herrick, Rabbi Sylvia Rothschild, Ramindar Singh, Dharmchari Kulananda, Deepak Naik, Daoud Rosser-Owen) Quoted as PSI.
Modood, T., Comment workshop, Amsterdam, June 29, 2001.
Moore, R.L., Selling God. New York, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1994.
Parekh, B., Rethinking Multiculturalism. Houndsmill: MacMillan, 2000.
Parekh, B., Comment workshop, Amsterdam, June 29, 2001.
Penninx, R., and Schrover, M., Splijtzwam of Bindmiddel. De organisatie van migranten in een lange-termijn perspectief. NWO/NMPS paper 2001.
Plesner, I., State Church and Church Autonomy in Norway, in G. Robbers (ed.), Church Autonomy. Frankfurt a. M.: Peter Lang, 2001, pp. 467–484.
Pfeffer, L., Religious Exemptions, in T. Robbins and R. Robertson (eds.), Church-State Relations. New Brunwick: Transaction Inc., 1987, pp. 103–114.
PSI: see Modood, T. (ed.), 1996.
Rath, J., Penninx, R., Groenendijk, K., and Meijer, A., Nederland en zijn Islam. Amsterdam, Spinhuis, 1996.
Rath, J., Penninx, R., Groenendijk, K., and Meijer, A., De Nederlandse samenleving en haar islam. And: Repliek, Migrantenstudies 13(2) (1997), pp. 69–80, 113–115.
Robbers, G. (ed.), State and Church in the European Union. Baden-Baden: Nomos, 1996.
Robbers, G. (ed.), Church Autonomy. Frankfurt a. M.: Peter Lang, 2001.
Robbins, T., and Anthony, D. (eds.), In Gods We Trust. New Brunswick: Transaction Books, 1981.
Robbins, T., and Anthony, D., Church-State Tensions and Marginal Movements, in T. Robbins and R. Robertson (eds.), Church-State Relations. New Brunwick: Transaction Inc., 1987, pp. 135–152.
Robbins, T., and Anthony, D., Church-State Tensions in the United States, in T. Robbins and R. Robertson (eds.), Church-State Relations. New Brunwick: Transaction Inc., 1987a, pp. 67–76.
Robbins, T., and Robertson, R. (eds.), Church-State Relations. New Brunswick: Transaction Inc., 1987.
Robertson, R., General Considerations in the Study of Contemporary Chuch-State Relationships, in T. Robbins and R. Robertson (eds.), Church-State Relations. New Brunswick: Transaction Inc., 1987, pp. 5–12.
Robertson, R., Church-State Relations in Comparative Perspective, in T. Robbins and R. Robertson (eds.), Church-State Relations. New Brunswick: Transaction Inc., 1987a, pp. 153–160.
Rooden, P.v., Religieuze Regimes. Amsterdam: Bakker, 1996.
Rosenblum, N., Membership and Morals. Princeton etc.: Princeton University Press, 1998.
Rosenblum, N. (ed.), Introduction: Pluralism, Integralism, and Political Theories of Religious Accommodation, in Obligations of Citizenship and Demands of Faith. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000, pp. 3–31.
Rosenblum, N. (ed.), Religious Autonomy and the Moral Uses of Pluralism, in Obligations of Citizenship and Demands of Faith. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000a, 165–195.
Rosenblum, N., Religious Parties, Religious Political Identity, etc., Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 6(1), (2003), pp. 23–53.
Rosenblum, N. (ed.), Obligations of Citizenship and Demands of Faith. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000.
Rudolph, S.H., and Rudolph, L., Living with Difference in India, in D. Marquand and R. Nettler (eds.), Obligations of Citizenship and Demands of Faith. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000, pp. 19–37.
Shachar, A., Multicultural Jurisdictions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001.
Sisk, T., Power Sharing and international mediation in ethnic conflicts. Carnegie Coop. Of New York, 1996.
Spinner-Halev, J., Surviving Diversity. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press, 2000.
Swaine, L., How ought liberal democracies to treat theocratic communities?, Ethics 111 (2001), pp. 302–343.
Tomasi, J., Liberalism Beyond Justice. Princeton, Oxford: Princeton University Press, 2001.
Valadez, J., Deliberative Democracy, Political Legitimacy, and Selfdetermination in Multicultural Societies. Boulder: Westview, 2001.
Walzer, M., On Toleration. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1997.
Williams, M., Toward a Deliberative Understanding of Justice Toward Groups. Manuscript (2001).
Williams, M., Tolerable Liberalism. Paper, Lincoln Nebraska, 2002.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bader, V. Religions and States. A New Typology and a Plea for Non-Constitutional Pluralism. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 6, 55–91 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1023294302099
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1023294302099