Abstract
Spencer’s evolutionary philosophy is usually identified with right-wing doctrines such as individualism, laissez-faire liberalism and even conservatism. Since he himself defended similar positions, it is perhaps not surprising that the study of the political interpretations of his ideas has drawn relatively little attention. In this article I propose to examine a rather atypical reading of Spencer’s organic analogy, though definitely not a marginal one: Enrico Ferri’s Marxist doctrine of Scientific Socialism. Ferri is not a figure unknown to scholars interested in the political aspects of the evolutionary debate. Nonetheless, the relation between his theory and Spencer’s bio-sociology – notably the complex dialectic of themes such as “the struggle for existence” versus “class struggle,” or “evolution” versus “revolution” – has not yet received full-length analysis. In my study I investigate the diffusion of Spencer’s ideas in Italy and their impact on the new “positivist” sciences of psychology and sociology inasmuch as these questions are essential to understanding Ferri’s position. Throughout, I stress the importance of the intellectual and political context in the process of appropriation of ideas that led to this unexpected shift in meaning.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Roberto. Ardigò’s (1870) La psicologia come scienza positiva V. Guastalla Mantova
Roberto. Ardigò’s (1879) La Morale dei positivisti Battezzati Milano
Ardigò’s Roberto. (1883). “L’inconoscibile di H. Spencer e il positivismo.” Rassegna critica. 7–8
Roberto. Ardigò’s (1899) La dottrina spenceriana dell’inconoscibile Capaccini Roma
Roberto. Ardigò’s (1908) ArticleTitle“A Comte, H. Spencer e un positivsta italiano.” Rivista italiana di Filosofia e Scienze affini 10 1–3
Roberto Ardigò’s (1882–1918) Opere filosofiche. 11 vols Draghi Padova
Atti della Reale Accademia dei Lincei, 1875–1876, Roma.
Filippo. Barbano (1985) “Sociologia e positivismo in Italia: 1850–1910. Un capitolo di sociologia storica”. Il positivismo e la cultura italiana Franco Angelli Milano
Daniel Becquemont Laurent. Mucchielli (1998) Le cas Spencer PUF Paris
Jean-Marc. Bernardini (1997) Le Darwinisme social en France (1859–1918) : Fascination et rejet d’une idéologie CNRS Paris
L. Clark Linda (1984) Social Darwinism in France University Press Alabama
Piero. Di Giovanni (2003) Filosofia e psicologia nel positivismo italiano Laterza Bari
David. Duncan (1908) Life & Letters of Herbert Spencer D. Appleton & Co. New York
Enrico. Ferri (1881) Studi sulla criminalità in Francia dal 1825 al 1878 Eredi Botta Roma.
Enrico. Ferri (1883) Socialismo e Criminalità Bocca Torino
Ferri Enrico (1886). “Discorso.” La Nuova Mantova, 20 maggio.
Enrico Ferri (1894) Socialismo e scienza positiva Casa editrice italiana Roma
Enrico Ferri (1896) Socialisme et science positive V. Giard et E. Brière Paris
Enrico Ferri (1899) Discordie positiviste sul socialismo Remo Sandron Milano-Palermo
Enrico Ferri (1900) Socialism and Positive Science New York International Library Publishing Co. Translated by Robert Rives La Monte, New York
Enrico Ferri (1903) Autobiografia Leone Magnaghi Milano
Enrico Ferri (1909) Socialism and Positive Science Independent Labour Party London
Enrico Ferri (1929) Il fascismo in Italia e l’opera di B. Mussolini Paladino Mantova
Enrico Ferri (1931) Mussolini, uomo di stato Paladino Mantova
Raffaele. Garofalo (1895) La superstizione socialista Frassati e Co. Torino-Roma
Greta. Jones (1980) Social Darwinism and English Thought: The interaction between Biological and Social Theory The Harvester Press Sussex
Antonio. Labriola (1897) ArticleTitle“Marxismo, Darwinismo, ecc” Critica Sociale 12 188–191
Larizza. Lolli Mirella (1985) “Comte e l’Italia (1849–1857).” Il positivismo e la cultura italiana Franco Angelli Milano
Terenzio. Mamiani (1871) ArticleTitle“Recensione a La psicologia come scienza positiva di R. Ardigò” La filosofia delle scuole italiane II 211–221
Terenzio. Mamiani (1875) ArticleTitle“Recensione di Herbert Spencer: Principes de Psychologie.” La Filosofia delle Scuole Italiane 11 123–133
Mamiani Terenzio. (1877). “Recensione di Herbert Spencer: Principes de Biologie”. Paris: 1877, La filosofia delle Scuole italiane 15: 421–428
Roberto. Michels (1926) Storia critica del movimento socialista italiano: dagli inizi fino al 1911 La Voce Firenze
Mark. Pittenger (1993) American Socialists and Evolutionary Thought 1870-1920 The University of Wisconsin Press Madison
Cesare. Ranzoli (1904) ArticleTitle“La fortuna di Erberto Spencer in Italia.” Rivista di Filosofia e Scienze affini. 1 217–236
Antonio. Salandra (1875) ArticleTitle“Recensione di H Spencer: The Study of Sociology (London 1874)” Giornale napoletano di Filosofia e Lettere. 1 169–172
A. Saloni (1969) Il positivismo e Roberto Ardigò Armando Armando Roma
Salvadori Rinaldo. ed. (1979). Enrico Ferri “par lui même”. Biblioteca comunale Romeo Romei, S. Benedetto Po
Judith. Schlanger (1971) Les métaphores de l’organisme Vrin Paris
Herbert. Spencer (1843) The Proper Sphere of Government W. Brittain London
Herbert. Spencer (1851) Social Statics: Or the Conditions Essential to Human Happiness Specified and the First of Them Developed Chapman London
Herbert. Spencer (1855) The Principles of Psychology Longman Brown Green and Longmans London
Spencer Herbert. (1860). “The Social Organism.”. Westminster Review: 90–121
Herbert. Spencer (1864) The Classification of the Sciences: To Which Are Added Reasons for Dissenting from the Philosophy of M Comte Williams & Norgate London
Herbert. Spencer (1872) The Priciples of Psychology. 2 vols EditionNumber2 Williams & Norgate London
Herbert. Spencer (1873) The Study of Sociology Henry S. King & Co; D. Appleton & Co London, New-York
Herbert. Spencer (1879) (1881–1893) The Principles of Ethics. Williams & Norgate; D. Appleton & Co London, New York
Herbert. Spencer (1881) Introduzione allo studio della sociologia. Translated by Sofia Fortini-Santarelli Fratteli Dumolard Milano
Herbert. Spencer (1881) Principi di sociologia. Translated by Antonio Salandra e Guglielmo Salvadori Unione Tipografico-Editirce Torino
Herbert. Spencer (1883) The Principles of Sociology Williams & Norgate; D. Appleton & Co London, New York
Herbert. Spencer (1884) The Man versus the State Williams & Norgate; D. Appleton & Co London, New York
Herbert. Spencer (1893) La Giustizia Città di Castello Lapi
Herbert. Spencer (1894) Beneficenza negativa e positiva Città di Castello Lapi
Herbert. Spencer (1899) The Principles of Psychology Williams & Norgate; D. Appleton & Co London, New York
Herbert. Spencer (1904) Autobiography. 2 Vols Willimans and Norgate; D. Appleton & Co London New, York
Herbert. Spencer (1904) Introduzione alla scienza sociale Bocca Torino
Herbert. Spencer (1922) Principi di sociologia. Translated by G. Egidi Rinfreschi Padova
Herbert. Spencer (1966) The Study of Sociology Otto Zeller Osnabrück
Herbert. Spencer (1966) The Principles of Sociology Otto Zeller Osnabrück
W. Taylor Michael (1992) Men versus the State: Herbert Spencer & late Victorian Individualism Oxford University Press Oxford-New-York
Filippo. Turati (1893) ArticleTitle“La chiesa socialista: echi del congresso di Reggio Emilia” Critica sociale. 18 273–275
Richard. Weikart (1999) Socialist Darwinism: Evolution in German Socialist Thought from Marx to Bernstein International Scholars Publications San Francisco-London-Bethesda
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
1 Spencer, 1843, 1851, 1879–1893, 1884.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Beck, N. Enrico Ferri’s Scientific Socialism: A Marxist Interpretation of Herbert Spencer’s Organic Analogy. J Hist Biol 38, 301–325 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-004-3796-2
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-004-3796-2