Abstract
Ethical and legal discourse pertaining to the ability to consent to treatment and research in England operates within a dualist framework of “competence” and “capacity”. This is confusing, as while there exists in England two possible senses of legal capacity – “first person” legal capacity and “delegable” legal capacity, currently neither is formulated to bear a necessary relationship with decision-making competence. Notwithstanding this, judges and academic commentators frequently invoke competence to consent in discussions involving the validity of offering or withholding consent as a synonym for legal capacity to consent. I argue that this gives rise to a conflation, jeopardising clarity and consistency in law. This is somewhat less problematic in instances of “first-person” legal capacity that are heavily informed by criteria for decision-making competence than in the second sense of legal capacity, which is qualitatively different from decision-making competence, or with first-person legal capacity when defined in different terms from competence. The paper concludes by proposing that the soundest resolution to this problem is by making decision-making competence a necessary and sufficient condition of first-person legal capacity, affording a more scrupulous distinction between the two different forms of legal capacity that exist.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
P. Alderson (1990) Children’s Consent to Surgery Open University Press Buckingham
P. Appelbaum L. Roth C. Lidz (1982) ArticleTitle“The Therapeutic Misconception: Informed Consent in Psychiatric Research’ International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 5 IssueID3–4 319–329 Occurrence Handle6135666 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:BiyB28vmt1c%3D
E. Baumgarten (1980) ArticleTitle“The Concept of Competence in Medical Ethics’ Journal of Medical Ethics 6 180–184 Occurrence Handle7463426 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:Bi6C3MbntlQ%3D
T.L. Beauchamp (1991) “Competence” M.A. Cutter E.E. Shelp (Eds) Competency: A Study of Informal Competency Determinations in Primary Care Kluwer Dordrecht 49–77
J.W. Berg P.S. Appelbaum T. Grisso (1996) ArticleTitle“Constructing Competence: Formulating Standards of Legal Competence To Make Medical Decisions” Rutgers Law Review 48 IssueID2 345–396 Occurrence Handle16086484 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DC%2BD2MvitFKksA%3D%3D
J.W. Berg P.S. Appelbaum (1999) “Subjects’ Capacity to Consent to Neurobiological Research’ H.A. Pincus J. Lieberman S. Ferris (Eds) Ethics In Psychiatric Research: A Resource Manual for Human Subjects Protection American Psychiatric Publishing Washington D.C 81–106
D. Beyleveld (1991) The Dialectical Necessity of Morality: An Analysis and Defense of Alan Gewirth’s Argument to the Principle of Generic Consistency The University of Chicago Press Chicago
D. Beyleveld R. Brownsword (1994) Law As A Moral Judgment Sheffield Academic Press Sheffield
D. Beyleveld R. Brownsword (2001) Human Dignity in Bioethics and Biolaw Oxford University Press Oxford
D. Beyleveld S. Pattinson (2000) “Precautionary Reasoning as a Link to Moral Action” M. Boylan (Eds) Medical Ethics Prentice-Hall Upper Saddle River, NJ 39–53
M. Brazier (1991) “Competence, Consent and Proxy Consents” M. Brazier M. Lobjoit (Eds) Protecting the Vulnerable: Autonomy and Consent in Health Care Routledge London 34–51
InstitutionalAuthorNameBritish Medical Association and The Law Society (2004) Assessment of Mental Capacity: Guidance for Doctors and Lawyers BMJ Publishing London
A.E. Buchanan D.W. Brock (1989) Deciding for others: The Ethics of Surrogate Decision-Making Cambridge University Press New York
C.M. Culver B. Gert (1982) Philosophy in Medicine: Conceptual and Ethical Issues in Medicine and Psychiatry Oxford University Press Oxford
W.J.M. Dekkers (2001) ArticleTitle“Autonomy and Dependence: Chronic Physical Illness and Decision-Making Capacity” Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 4 IssueID2 185–192 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1011497901122 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DC%2BD3MvpslGrsA%3D%3D
J.F. Drane (1985) ArticleTitle“The Many Faces of Competency” Hastings Center Report 15 17–21 Occurrence Handle4008235 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:BiqB3szosVY%3D
A. Gewirth (1978) Reason and Morality The University of Chicago Press Chicago
T. Grisso P.S. Appelbaum (1995) ArticleTitle“The MacArthur Treatment Competence Study, III: Abilities of Patients to Consent to Psychiatric and Medical Treatments” Law and Human Behavior 19 IssueID2 149–174 Occurrence Handle11660292
T. Grisso P.S. Appelbaum (1998) Assessing Competence to Consent to Treatment: A Guide for Physicians and Other Health Professionals Oxford University Press New York
M.J. Gunn (1994) ArticleTitle“The Meaning of Incapacity” Medical Law Review 2 8–24 Occurrence Handle11656866
M.J. Gunn J.G. Wong I.C.H. Clare A.J. Holland (1999) ArticleTitle“Decision-Making Capacity” Medical Law Review 7 269–306 Occurrence Handle10.1093/medlaw/7.3.269 Occurrence Handle11885611 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DC%2BD387lsVegug%3D%3D
Hohfeld W.N. (1923) reissued 2001, Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied In Judicial Reasoning, D. Campbell, P. Thomas, N.E. Simmonds (eds.) London: Dartmouth.
P. Jones (1994) Rights Palgrave Basingstoke
I. Kennedy A. Grubb (2000) Medical Law EditionNumber3 Butterworths London
Law Commission of England and Wales (1991) Mental Incapacitated Adults and Decision-Making: An Overview, Consultation Paper 119. London: HMSO.
Law Commission of England and Wales (1993) Mentally Incapacitated Adults and Decision-Making: Medical Treatment and Research, Consultation Paper 129. London: HMSO.
Law Commission of England and Wales (1995) Mental Incapacity, Report 231. London: HMSO.
R.J. Levine (1988) Ethics and Regulation of Clinical Research EditionNumber2 Yale University Press New Haven
N. MacCormick (1994) Legal Reasoning and Legal Theory, revised edition Clarendon Press Oxford
J.K. Mason R.A. McCall-Smith G.T. Laurie (2002) Law and Medical Ethics EditionNumber6 Butterworths London
G.B. Melton G.P. Koocher M.J. Saks (1983) Children’s Competence to Consent Plenum New York
Mill, J.S. (1859) reissued 1991, On Liberty and Other Essays (edited with an introduction and notes by J. Gray). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
E.H. Morreim (1983) ArticleTitle“Three Concepts of Patient Competence” Theoretical Medicine 4 231–251 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00489207 Occurrence Handle11649530
E.H. Morreim (1991) “Competence: at the Intersection of Law, Medicine and Philosophy” M.A. Cutter E.E. Shelp (Eds) Competency: A Study of Informal Competency Determinations in Primary Care Kluwer Dordrecht 93–125
N. Ondrusek R. Abramovitch P. Pencharz G. Koren (1998) ArticleTitle“Empirical Examination of the Ability of Children to Consent to Medical Research” Journal of Medical Ethics 24 158–165 Occurrence Handle9650109 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK1czhtlOqtw%3D%3D Occurrence Handle10.1136/jme.24.3.158
J.D. Rendorff (2002) ArticleTitle“Basic Ethical Principles in European Bioethics and Biolaw: Autonomy, Dignity, Integrity and Vulnerability – Towards a Foundation of Bioethics and Biolaw” Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 5 IssueID2 235–244
L.H. Roth A. Meisel C.W. Lidz (1977) ArticleTitle“Tests of Competency to Consent to Treatment” American Journal of Psychiatry 134 IssueID3 279–284 Occurrence Handle842704 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:CSiC3s3htlY%3D
J.O.A. Tan D.P.H. Jones (2001) ArticleTitle“Children’s Consent” Current Opinion in Psychiatry 14 303–307 Occurrence Handle10.1097/00001504-200107000-00012
InstitutionalAuthorNameUnited Kingdom Department for Constitutional Affairs (2003) Draft Mental Incapacity Bill, Cm 5859 HMSO London
InstitutionalAuthorNameUnited Kingdom Department of Health (2001) Good Practice in Consent Implementation Guide: Consent to Examination or Treatment Department of Health London
InstitutionalAuthorNameUnited Kingdom Lord Chancellor’s Department (1999) Making Decisions: Government Proposals for Making Decisions on behalf of Mentally Incapacitated Adults, Cm 4465 HMSO London
InstitutionalAuthorNameUnited Kingdom Parliament, House of Commons (2004) Mental Capacity Bill (Bill 1, 53/4) The Stationery Office London
United Kingdom Parliament, House of Commons (2004) Explanatory Notes on the Mental Capacity Bill (EN-1) London: The Stationery Office.
H.Y. Vanderpool (1991) “The Competency of Definitions of Competency” M.A. Cutter E.E. Shelp (Eds) Competency: A Study of Informal Competency Determinations in Primary Care Kluwer Dordrecht 197–209
L.A. Weithorn S.B. Campbell (1982) ArticleTitle“The Competency of Children and Adolescents to make Informed Consent Treatment Decisions” Child Development 53 1589–1598 Occurrence Handle7172783 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:BiyD2sfkt1E%3D
J.V.M. Welie S.P.K. Welie (2001) ArticleTitle“Patient Decision Making Competence: Outlines of A Conceptual Analysis” Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 4 IssueID2 127–138 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DC%2BD3MvpslGktQ%3D%3D
B.C. White (1994) Competence to Consent Georgetown University Press Washington, D.C.
M. Wicclair (1991) ArticleTitle“Patient Decision-Making Capacity and Risk” Bioethics 5 IssueID2 87–104
I. Wilks (1997) ArticleTitle“The Debate Over Risk-Related Standards of Competence” Bioethics 11 IssueID5 413–426 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-8519.00081 Occurrence Handle11655120
I. Wilks (1999) ArticleTitle“Asymmetrical Competence” Bioethics 13 IssueID2 154–159 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-8519.00139 Occurrence Handle11657098
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bielby, P. The Conflation of Competence and Capacity in English Medical Law: A Philosophical Critique. Med Health Care Philos 8, 357–369 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-005-0537-z
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-005-0537-z