Abstract
This paper is an attempt to clarify why Ludwig Boltzmann from about 1895 to 1905 seemed to adopt a series of extreme epistemological positions, ranging from phenomenalism to pragmatism, while emphatically rejecting what he called ‘metaphysics’ (by which he meant all traditional philosophy). He concluded that all philosophical differences were merely linguistic and most were ultimately meaningless. But at about the time that young Ludwig Wittgenstein began absorbing these desperate ideas (1905), Boltzmann himself under the influence of Franz Brentano seemed to assume a type of representationalism about the external physical world, while in his own mind adopting it for pragmatic reasons. Why? Because “it worked”. He seems to have defended his non-representationalist Bildtheorie on similar grounds, but his suicide followed shortly (1906).
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Battimelli, C., M. G. Iannielo, and O. Kresten (eds.): 1993, Proceedings of the In-ternational Symposium on Ludwig Boltzmann (Rome, February 9-11, 1989),Verlag der österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Wien. [This recent publication includes articles by Cercigriani, Flamm, Wilson, and others. Most of the articles are on Boltzmann's contributions to physics or on controversies resulting from them.]
Blackmore, J.: 1970a, Ernst Mach-His Life, Work, and Influence, Vol.I, Xerox Microfilm, Ann Arbor.
Blackmore, J.: 1970b, Ernst Mach-His Life, Work, and Influence, Vol.II, Xerox Microfilm, Ann Arbor.
Blackmore, J.: 1972, Ernst Mach-His Life, Work, and Influence, University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles.
Blackmore, J.: 1978, 'Is Planck's "Principle", True?', British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 29, 347-9. [This article points out that Kuhn's quotation from Planek about how science advances is misleading, especially about Planck himself.]
Blackmore, J.: 1982, 'Boltzmann's Concessions to Mach's Philosophy of Science' in R. Sexl and J. Blackmore (eds.), Ludwig Boltzmann Ausgewählte Abandlungen (Ludwig Boltzmann Gesamtausgabe, Band 8), Vieweg, Braunschweig/Wiesbaden, pp. 155-90.
Blackmore, J. and K. Hentschel (eds.): 1985, Ernst Mach als Aussenseiter-Machs Briefwechsel üher Philosophie und Relativitätstheorie mit Persönlichkeiten seiner Zeit, Wilhelm Braumüller, Wien.
Blackmore, J. (ed.): 1992, Ernst Mach-A Deeper Look, Kluwer, Dordrecht.
Blackmore, J. (ed.): 1995a, Ludwig Boltzmann His Later Life and Philosophy 1900-1906, A Documentary History, Vol. I, Kluwer, Dordrecht. [This work includes a translation of most of Boltzmann's letters from 1900 to 1906.]
Blackmore, J.: 1995b, Ludwig Boltzmann His Later Life and Philosophy 1900-1906, A Documentary History, Vol. II, Kluwer, Dordrecht. [This book is an attempt to describe the changes in Boltzmann's philosophy of nature from 1903 to 1906.]
Boltzmann, L.: 1896, 'Zur Energetik', Annalen der Physik und Chemie,n.f.58, 137-140.
Boltzmann, Ludwig: 1897 and 1906, Vorlesungen über die Principe der Mechanik,2Vols., Barth, Leipzig.
Boltzmann, L. and J. Nabl: 1907, 'Kinetische Theorie der Materie', Enzyklopädie der mathematischen Wissenschaften, Vol. 5, Physik Band 1, Teil 8, Teubner, Leipzig, p. 549 following.
Boltzmann, Ludwig.: 1925 (1905), Populäre Schriften,Barth, Leipzig.
Boltzmann, L.: 1968 (1909), in F. Hasenöhrl (ed.), Wissenschaftliche Abhandlungen,3 Vols., Chelsea Publishing Company, New York.
Boltzmann, L.: 1974, in B. McGuinness (ed.), theoretical Physics and Philosophical Problems, Reidel, Dordrecht.
Boltzmann, L.: 1979 (1905), Populäre Scriften (incomplete), chapters selected by E. Broda and edited by R. Sexl, Vieweg, Braunschweig/Wiesbaden.
Boltzmann, Ludwig.: 1995 (1964), Lectures on Gas Theory, edited and translated by Stephen Brush, Dover, New York.
Broda, E.: 1983, Ludwig Boltzmann-Man-Physicist-Philosopher, Ox Bow Press, Woodbridge, Connecticut. [This is the first biography on Boltzmann to appear in English. It is an updated translation of a 1955 book in German.]
Brush, Stephen.: 1987, Die Temperatur der Geschichte, Vieweg, Branschweig.
Büchner, L.: 1876 (1855), Kraft und Stoff, 14 Auflage, Verlag von Theodor Thomas, Leipzig.
Burbank, L. S. and J. I. Hanson (eds.): 1881, Introductory Course of Natural Philosophy for the Use of High Schools and Academies, edited from Ganot's Popular Physics by William G. Peck.: 1860, A.S. Barnes and Company, New York and Chicago.
Burtt, E. A:1954 (1924), The Metaphysical Foundations of Modern Science, Doubleday, Garden City. [This is a very fundamental book for people who want to understand the epistemological assumptions of the leaders of the Scientific Revolution.]
Carnap, R.: 1956, Meaning and Necessity-A Study in Semantics and Model Logic, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Cercignani, Carlo: 1998, Ludwig Boltzman-The Man Who Trusted Atoms, foreword by Sir Roger Penrose, Oxford University Press, Oxford. [The first well-documented biography of Boltzmann in English.]
Dugas, R.: 1959, La Théorie physique au sens de Boltzmann et ses prolongements modernes, Éditions du Griffon, Neuchatel-Suisse, Distribution Dunod, Paris.
Einstein, A.: 1902, 'Kinetisehe Theorie des Warmegleichgewichtes und des zweiten Hauptsatzes der Thermodynamik', Annalen der Physik 9, 417-433.
Einstein, A.: 1903, 'Eine Theorie der Grundlagen der Thermodynamik', Annalen der Physik11, 170-87.
Einstein, A.: 1905, 'Zur Elektrodynamik bewegter Körper', Annalen der Physik 17, 891-921.
Einstein, A.: 1970 (1950), Out of MyLaterYears,Greenwood Press, Westport, Connecticut.
Einstein, A.: 1987, in J. Stachel (ed.), Collected Papers of Albert Einstein, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey.
Fasol-Boltzmann, I. M. (ed.): 1990, Ludwig Boltzmann Principien der Naturfilosofi, Springer Verlag, Berlin. [This is an extremely valuable work for anyone interested in Boltzmann's late philosophy. Frau Fasol-Boltzmann deciphered Boltzmann's short hand notes and included the results plus other documents. This book also includes articles by Gerhard Fasol and Stephen Brush.]
Flamm, D.: 1982, 'Die Persönchkeit Ludwig Boltzmanns', in R. Sexl and J. Blackmore (eds.), Ludwig Boltzmann Gesamtausgabe, Band 8, Vieweg, Braunschweig.
Flamm, D. (ed.): 1995, Hochgeehrter Herr Professor! Innig geliebter Louis! Ludwig Boltzmann Henriette von Aigentler B riefwechsel, Böhlau Verlag, Wien-Köln-Weimar. [This book includes the correspondence between Boltzmann and his fiancé from 1872 to 1876 when Boltzmann got married and returned from teaching mathematics in Vienna to teaching experimental physics in Graz.]
Frank, P.: 1962, 'Transcript of a Tape-Recorded Interview by Thomas S. Kuhn', July 16, 1962, copy located in the Niels Bohr Library, College Park, Maryland.
Ganot, A.: 1851, Traité élémentaire de physique expérimentale et appliquée et de metéorologie...[published by the author himself], Paris.
Ganot, A.: 1859, Cours de physique purement expérimentale, 'a l'usage des personnes étrangères aux connaisances mathématiques,...[published by the author himself], Pans.
Gillet, J. A. and W. J. Rolfe: 1881, Natural Philosophy for the Use of Schools and Academies, American Book Company, New York-Cincinnati-Chicago.
Hall, E. H.. and J. Y. Bergen Jr.: 1892, A Textbook of Physics-Largely Experimental, Henry Holt, New York.
Hertz, H: 1894, Die Principien der Mechanik,Barth.
Höflechner, W.: 1994, Ludwig Boltzmann Leben und Briefe, Akademische Druck und Verlagsanstalt, Graz. [This book includes almost all of the extant correspondence of Ludwig Boltzmann. It also contains a detailed biography.]
Höfler, A (ed.): 1881 (1854), Schabus' Anfangsgründe der Naturlehre. Zum Gebrauche an den unteren Classen der Mittelschulen, Vierzehnte Auflage, Carl Gerold's Sohn, Wien.
Höfler, A.: 1903, Naturlehre für die Oberstufe der Gymnasien, Realschulen, und verwandter Lehranstalten, unter mitwirkung von Dr. Eduard Maisss und Dr. Friedrich Poske, Vieweg und Sohn, Braunschweig und Carl Gerold's Sohn, Wien.
Höfler, A..: 1921, 'DeDie Philosophic des Alois Höfler', in R. Schmidt (ed.), Die Deutsche Philosophie der Gegenwart in Selbstdarstellungen, zweiter Band, Verlag von Felix Meiner, Leipzig.
Hörst, H. and Andreas Laaß (eds.): 1989, Ludwig Boltzmanns Wege nach Berlin, Akademie Verlag, Berlin. [This work includes documents and correspondence about Boltzmann's abortive attempt to become a professor in Berlin in the late 1880's.]
Holton, G.: 1974, Introduction to Concepts and Theories in Physical Science, revised and with new material by Stephen G. Brush, 2nd edn, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, Reading Massachusetts.
Holton, G.: 1974, 'Einstein, Michelson, and the 'Crucial' Experiment', in Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought-Kepler to Einstein,Harvard University Press, Cambridge, pp. 261-352.
Holton, G.: 1993, Science and Anti-Science, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
Körber, H. G. (ed.): 1961, Aus dem wissenschaftlichen Briefwechsel Wilhelm Ostwalti, Band I, Akademie Verlag, Berlin.
Kuhn, T.: 1970 (1962), The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 2nd edn. Enlarged (International Encyclopedia of Unified Science, editor-in-chief Otto Neurath, Vol. 2, No. 2), University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London.
Lanczos, C.: 1974, The Einstein Decade (1905-1915), Academic Press, New York and London.
Lewes, G. H.: 1902 (1845-46), A Biographical History of Philosophy,4vols., George Routledge & Sons, London.
Lind, G.: 1992, Physik im Lehrbuch 1700-1850-Zur Geschichte der Physik und ihrer Didaktik in Deutschland, Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
Mach, E.: 1863, Compendium der Physik für Mediciner, W. Braumüller, Wien.
Mach, E.: 1872, Die Geschichte und Wurzel des Satzes von der Erhaltung der Arbeit, Calve, Prag.
Mach, E.: 1883, Die Mechanik in ihrer Etwicklung historisch-kritisch dargestellt, Brockhaus, Leipzig.
Mach, E.: 1886, Beiträge zur Analyse der Empfindungen, G. Fischer, Jena.
Mach, E. and J. Odstrcil: 1910 (1887), Grundriss der Naturlehre für die unteren Classen der Mittelschulen, Ausgabe für Gymnasien,Vol.7,Auflage,Tempsky, Prag.
Mach, E. and J. Odstrcil: 1891, Grundriss der Naturlehre für die oberen Classen der Mittelschulen, Ausgabe für Gymnasien, Tempsky, Prag.
Mach, E. and G. Jaumann: 1891, Leitfaden der Physik für Studierende, Tempsky, Prag und Wien; Freytag, Leipzig. [A second edition appeared in 1891 without the contribution from Jaumann.]
Mach, E.: 1910, 'Die Leigedanken meiner naturwissenschaftlichen Erkenntnislehre und ihre Aufnahme durch die Zeitgenossen', Physikalische Zeitschrift 11, 599-606.
Mach, E.: 1959 (1897), Analysis of Sensations, Dover, New York.
Meitner, L.: 1964, 'Looking Back', Bulletin of Atomic Scientists 20, 2-7.
Menger, K.: 1994, in L. Golland, B. McGuinness, and A. Sklar (eds.), Reminiscences of the Vienna Circle and the Mathematical Colloquium, Kluwer, Dordrecht
Moleschott, J.: 1857 (1852), Der Kreislauf des Lebens,V.vonZabern,Mainz.
Motz, H.: 1982, 'Did the Germ of General Relativity Come from Boltzmann?', in R. Sexl and J. Blackmore (eds.), Ludwig Boltzmann Ausgewählte Abhandlungen(Ludwig Boltzmann Gesamtausgabe, Band 8), Vieweg, Braunschweig/Wiesbaden, pp. 355-61.
Moyer, Albert E.: 1986, American Physics in Transition(The History of Modern Physics 1800-1950, Volume 3), Tomash Publishers, Los Angeles and San Francisco.
Planck, M.: 1909, 'Die Einheit des physikalischen Weltbildes', Physikalische Zeitschrift 10, 62-75.
Planck, M.: 1910, 'Zur Machschen Theorie der physikalischen Erkenntnis-Eine Erwiderung', Physikalische Zeitschrift 11, 1186-1190.
Reinold, A. W. (ed.): 1909, Elementary Treatise on Physics-Experimental and Applied for the Use of Colleges and Schools, translated from Ganot's Éléments de Physique by E. Atkinson, seventeenth edition (1906), William Wood and Company, New York.
Seelig, C.: 1954, Albert Einstein-Eine dokumentarische Biographie, Europa Verlag, Zürich-Stuttgart-Wien.
Sexl, R. and J. Blackmore (eds.): 1982, Ausgewählte Abhandlungen der internationalen Tagung Wien 1981(Ludwig Boltzmann Gesamtausgabe, Band 8), Akademische Druck und Verlagsanstalt, Graz und Freidrich Vieweg & Sohn, Braunschweig/Wiesbaden.
Stiller, W.: 1989, Ludwig Boltzmann Altmeister der klassischen Physik und Wegbereiter der Quantenmechanik und Evolutionstheorie, Verlag Harri Deutsch, Thun & Frankfurt am Main. [This book has added much useful information about Boltzmann's colleagues, friends, and opponents.]
Vogt, C.: 1855 (1954), Köhlenglaube und Wissenschaft,J.Ricker,Giessen.
Wagner, S.: 1982, 'Ludwig Boltzmann and the Special Theory of Relativity', in R. Sexl and J. Blackmore (eds.), Ludwig Boltzmann Ausgewählte Abhandlungen(Ludwig Boltzmann Gesamtausgabe, Band 8), Vieweg, Braunschweig/Wiesbaden, pp. 341-54.
Weinberg, S.: 1998, 'The Non-Revolution of T. S. Kuhn', The New York Review of Books, XLV, 48-52.
Wilson, A.: 1993, 'Boltzmann's Philosophical Education and its Bearing on His Mature Scientific Epistemology', in Proceedings of the International Symposium on Ludwig Boltzmann (Rome, February 9-11, 1989), Verlag der österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Wien, pp. 57-69. [This article documents information about what Boltzmann's teachers in philosophy probably taught him during the 1860's.]
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Blackmore, J. Boltzmann and Epistemology. Synthese 119, 157–189 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005299405864
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005299405864