Abstract
Culture creates the context within which individuals experience life and comprehend moral meaning of illness, suffering and death. The ways the patient, family and the physician communicate and make decisions in the end-of-life care are profoundly influenced by culture. What is considered as right or wrong in the healthcare setting may depend on the socio-cultural context. The present article is intended to delve into the cross-cultural perspectives in ethical decision making in the end-of-life scenario. We attempt to address the dynamics of the roles of patient, family and physician therein across two countries from East and West, namely, India and Germany. In India, where illness is more a shared family affair than an individual incident, a physician is likely to respect the family’s wishes and may withhold the ‹naked truth’ about the diagnosis of a fatal disease to the patient. In Germany, a physician is legally required to inform the patient about the disease. In India, advance directive being virtually non-existent, the family acts as the locus of the decision-making process, taking into account the economic cost of available medical care. In Germany, advance directive is regarded as mandatory and healthcare is covered by insurance. Family and the physician appear to play larger roles in ethical decision making for patients in India than for those in Germany, who place greater emphasis on autonomy of the individual patient. Our study explicates how culture matters in ethical decision-making and why the bioethical discourse is necessary in the concrete realities of the socio-cultural context. To explore the possibility of finding a common ground of morality across different cultures while acknowledging and respecting cultural diversity, thus remains a formidable challenge for the bioethicists.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alora A.T., J.M. Lumitao (eds.): 2001, Beyond a Western Bioethics: Voices from the Developing World. Washington: Georgetown University Press
Arekapudi S., M.K. Wynia: 2003, The Unbearable Whiteness of the Mainstream: Should we Eliminate, or Celebrate, Bias in Bioethics? American Journal of Bioethics 3, 18–19
Balakrishnan S., R.K. Mani: 2005, The Constitutional and Legal Provisions in Indian Law for Limiting Life Support. Indian Journal of Critical Care Medicine 9, 108–114
Barker J.C.: 1992, Cultural Diversity—Changing the Context of Medical Practice. Western Journal of Medicine 157, 248–254
Basham A. L.: 1954, The Wonder that was India. London: Sidwick and Jackson
Bates M.S., W.T. Edwards: 1992, Ethnic Variations in the Chronic Pain Experience. Ethnic Diseases 2, 63–83
Bates M.S., W.T. Edwards, K.O. Anderson: 1993, Ethnocultural Influences on Variation in Chronic Pain Perception. Pain 52, 101–112
Bell R.: 1994, Prominence of Women in Navajo Healing Beliefs and Values. Nursing Health Care 15, 232–240
Berger J.T.: 1998, Culture and Ethnicity in Clinical Care. Archives of Internal Medicine 158, 2085–2090
Bhagwati S.N.: 1967, Ethics, Morality and Practice of Medicine in Ancient India. Child’s Nervous System 13, 428–434
Blank R.H., J.C. Merrick: 2005, End-of-Life Decision Making—A Cross-National Study. Cambridge: The MIT Press
Burton O.R.: 2007, Why Bioethics Cannot Figure Out What to do with Race. American Journal of Bioethics 7, 6–12
Calvillo E.R., J.H. Flaskerud: 1993, Evaluation of the Pain Response by Mexican-American and Anglo-American Women and their Nurses. Journal of Advance Nursing 18, 451–459
Caralis P.V., B. Davis, K. Wright, E. Marcial: 1993, The Influence of Ethnicity and Race on Attitudes Toward Advance Directives, Life Prolonging Treatments and Euthanasia. Journal of Clinical Ethics 4, 155–165
Coward H., P. Ratanakul, (eds.): 1999, Cross-Cultural Dialogue on Health Care Ethics. Ontario: Wilfrid Laurier University Press
Crawford S.C.: 2003, Hindu Bioethics for the Twenty-First Century. New York: SUNY Press
Desai P.N.:2000, ‹Medical Ethics in India’, in: Robert M. Veatch, Cross-Cultural Perspectives in Medical Ethics. Sudbury Massachusetts: Jones and Bartlett Publishers
Deshpande O., M.R. Reid, A.S. Rao: 2005, Attitudes of Asian-Indian Hindus Toward End-of-Life Care. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 53, 131–135
Enquete-Kommission des Deutschen Bundestages zu, Ethik und Recht der modernen Medizin” 2004. Zwischenbericht: Patientenverfügungen v. 13.9.2004. BT-Drucks. 15/3700
German Federal Court of Justice: 1995, Neue Juristische Wochenschrift 48, 204–207
German Federal Court of Justice: 2003, Neue Juristische Wochenschrift 56, 1588–1594
German Federal Ministry of Justice: 2005, Ethische, rechtliche und medizinische Aspekte zur Bewertung von Patientenverfügungen. Bericht der Arbeitsgruppe, Patientenautonomie am Lebensende”. http://www.bmj.bund.de/media/archive/695.pdf
German Medical Association: 1993, Richtlinien der Bundesärztekammer für die ärztliche Sterbebegleitung. Deutsches ärzteblatt 90, B-1791–B-1792
German Medical Association: 1998, Grundsätze der Bundesärztekammer zur ärztlichen Sterbebegleitung. Deutsches ärzteblatt 95, A2366–A2367
German Medical Association: 2004, Grundsätze der Bundesärztekammer zur ärztlichen Sterbebegleitung. Deutsches ärzteblatt 101, A1298–A1299
German National Ethics Council: 2005, The Advance Directive: An Instrument of Self-Determination. Berlin. http://www.ethikrat.org/stellungnahmen/pdf/Stellungnahme_Patientenverfuegung.pdf
Helman C.G.: 2005, ‹Cultural Aspects of Time and Ageing. EMBO reports 6, S54–S58
Hern H.E. Jr., B.A. Koenig, L.J. Moore, P.A. Marshall: 1998, The Difference that Culture can make in End-of-Life Decisionmaking. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 7, 27–40
Iltis A.S.: 2004, Bioethics: The Intersection of Private and Public Decisions. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 29, 381–388
Kagawa-Singer M., L.J. Blackhall: 2001, Negotiating Cross-Cultural Issues At the End of Life “You Got to Go Where He Lives”. The Journal of the American Medical Association 286, 2993–3001
Klessig, J.: 1992, The Effect of Values and Culture on Life-Support Decisions. The Western Journal of Medicine 157, 316–322
Koenig B.A., Gates-Williams, J.: 1995, Understanding cultural difference in caring for dying patients. The Western Journal of Medicine 163, 244–249
Mani R.K.: 2006, End-of-Life Care in India. Intensive Care Medicine 32, 1066–1068
Millet, P.E., B.F. Sullivan, A.I. Schwebel and L.J. Myers: 1996, `Black Americans and White Americans' Views of the Etiology and Treatment of Mental Health Problems', Community Mental Health Journal 32, 235–242
Morgan, M.: 1995, The Significance of Ethnicity for Health Promotion: Patients’ use of Anti-Hypertensive Drugs in Inner London. International Journal of Epidemiology 24, S79–S84
Murphy S.T., J.M. Palmer, S. Azen, G. Frank, V. Michel, L.J. Blackhall: 1996, Ethnicity and Advance Directives. Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 24, 108–117
Myser, C.: 2003, Differences from Somewhere: The Normativity of Whiteness in Bioethics in the United States. American Journal of Bioethics 3, 1–11
Pandya S.K.: 2005, End of Life Decision Making in India. In: Robert H. Blank, Janna C. Merrick (eds.), End-of-Life Decision Making—A Cross-National Study. Cambridge: The MIT Press
Rao, M.S.: 1968, The History of Medicine in India and Burma. Medical History 12, 52–61
Ren X.S., B.C. Amick: 1996, Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Self-Assessed Health Status: Evidence from the National Survey of Families and Households. Ethnicity & Health 1, 293–303
Searight H.R., J. Gafford: 2005, Cultural Diversity at the End of Life: Issues and Guidelines for Family Physicians. American Family Physician 71, 515–522
Stonington S., P. Ratanakul: 2006, Is There a Global Bioethics? End-of-life in Thailand and the case for local difference. PLoS Med 3, e439
Subbarayappa B.V.: 2001, The Roots of Ancient Medicine: An Historical Outline. Journal of Biosciences 26, 135–144
Thomas N.D.: 2001, The Importance of Culture Throughout all of Life and Beyond. Holistic Nursing Practice 15, 40–46
Turner, L.: 2001, Medical Ethics in a Multicultural Society. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 94, 592–594
Turner, L.: 2004, Bioethics in Pluralistic Societies. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 7, 201–208
Uba, L.: 1992, Cultural Barriers to Health Care for South-East Asian Refugees. Public Health Report 107, 544–548
UNESCO: 2002, Universal Declaration on Cultural Diversity. Paris: UNESCO
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Chattopadhyay, S., Simon, A. East meets West: Cross-cultural perspective in end-of-life decision making from Indian and German viewpoints. Med Health Care Philos 11, 165–174 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-007-9106-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-007-9106-y