Abstract
Who is a child’s father? Is it the man who raised her, or the one whose genes she carries—or both? We look at the view that men who have raised children they falsely believed to be ‘their own’ have been victims of a form of fraud or are ‘false fathers’. We consider the question of who has been harmed in such cases, and in what the harm consists. We use conceptual analysis, a philosophical method of investigating the use of a concept and the logical implications of its various interpretations. We devise and discuss a number of possible scenarios in which a couple (arguably) become the parents of a child. We use these scenarios to illustrate the tenuousness of the claim that we can simply rely on biology to clarify parent-child relationships. We also discuss some of the underpinnings and implications of the language in which the debate on ‘paternity fraud’ has been framed: ‘duped’ or ‘false’ fathers and ‘cuckoo children’.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Notes
- 1.
We discuss solo reproduction more thoroughly in Cutas and Smajdor (2017).
- 2.
We thank our colleague Berit Åström for coming up with this analogy.
References
Alghrani A (2018) Uterus transplantation in and beyond cisgender women: revisiting procreative liberty in light of emerging reproductive technologies. J Law Biosci 5(2):301–328
Archard D (2008) Children: rights and childhood. Routledge, London
BBC (2008) US “Pregnant Man” has baby girl, 3 July. news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/7488894.stm. Accessed Dec 2018
BBC (2016) German plan to force mums to name lovers in paternity cases, 29 August. www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-37215684. Accessed Dec 2018
BBC (2019) Brazilian identical twins both ordered to pay maintenance, 2 April. www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-47794844. Accessed May 2019
Buchanan M (2015) General election manifesto. Justice for men and boys. http://voices.avoiceformen.com/j4mb/wp-content/uploads/sites/46/2017/09/141228-V10-General-election-manifesto-RGB.pdf. Accessed Dec 2018
Bundesministerium der Justiz und für Verbraucherschutz, Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Reform des Scheinvaterregresses, zur Rückbenennung und zur Änderung des Internationalen Familien-rechtsverfahrensgesetzes (2016). www.bmjv.de/SharedDocs/Gesetzgebungsverfahren/Dokumente/RefE_Scheinvaterregress.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=1. Accessed Dec 2018
Cutas D, Smajdor A (2015) Postmenopausal motherhood reloaded: advanced age and in vitro derived gametes. Hypatia 30(2):386–402
Cutas D, Smajdor A (2017) “I am your mother and your father!” In vitro derived gametes and the ethics of solo reproduction. Health Care Anal 25(4):354–369
deMause L (2006) The evolution of childhood. In: DeMause L (ed) The history of childhood. Harper and Row, New York
Draper H (2007) Paternity fraud and compensation for misattributed paternity. J Med Ethics 33:475–480
Ejzenberg D et al (2018) Livebirth after uterus transplantation from a deceased donor in a recipient with uterine infertility. Lancet. www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(18)31766-5/fulltext. Accessed Dec 2018
Gheaus A (2018) Love, not the family. Anal J Gender Feminist Stud 10:168–176
Hendriks S et al (2015) Artificial gametes: a systematic review of biological progress towards clinical application. Hum Reprod Update 21:285–296
Highfield R (2008) Sperm cells created from female embryo. Telegraph, 31 January. www.telegraph.co.uk/news/science/science-news/3323846/Sperm-cells-created-from-female-embryo.html. Accessed Dec 2018
Hubin D (2014) Fractured fatherhood: an analytic philosophy perspective on moral and legal paternity. J Fam Theory Rev 6:76–90
Kleinhubbert G (2013) Birth fathers: trans parenthood tests Berlin authorities. Spiegel Online, 10 September. www.spiegel.de/international/zeitgeist/transsexual-parenthood-a-challenge-to-government-agencies-in-berlin-a-921350.html. Accessed Dec 2018
Mertes H, Pennings G (2008) Embryonic stem cell-derived gametes and genetic parenthood: a problematic relationship. Camb Q Healthc Ethics 17(1):7–14
Murphy T (2015) Assisted gestation and transgender women. Bioethics 29(6):389–397
Rubin G (2015) Should we be doing more to expose fertility fraud? Telegraph, 4 September. www.telegraph.co.uk/men/relationships/fatherhood/11839479/Should-we-be-doing-more-to-expose-paternity-fraud.html. Accessed Dec 2018
Sample I (2003) Womb transplant babies “within three years”: scientists in Sweden offer alternative to surrogacy. The Guardian, 2 July. www.theguardian.com/science/2003/jul/02/sciencenews.medicineandhealth3. Accessed Dec 2018
Spiegel Online (2016) Kuckuckskinder: Mütter sollen zur Auskunft über Sexualpartner verpflichtet werden, 29 August. www.spiegel.de/panorama/gesellschaft/kuckuckskinder-muetter-sollen-zur-auskunft-ueber-sexualpartner-verpflichtet-werden-a-1109927.html. Accessed Dec 2018
The Guardian (2016a) Germany mulls plans to force mothers to reveal child’s biological father, 29 August. www.theguardian.com/world/2016/aug/29/germany-plan-force-mothers-reveal-childs-biological-father. Accessed Dec 2018
The Guardian (2016b) IVF mix-up: wrong sperm may have fertilised eggs of 26 women, 28 December. www.theguardian.com/society/2016/dec/28/ivf-mix-up-wrong-sperm-may-have-fertilised-eggs-of-26-women. Accessed Dec 2018
Tritt L-F (2009) Sperms and estates: an unadulterated functionally based approach to parent-child property succession. SMUL Rev 62:367–429
Vij SV et al (2018) Biological therapy for non-obstructive azoospermia. Expert Opin Biol Ther 18(1):19–23
Wiesemann C, Equality M (2016) Bioethics, and the child. Springer, Dordrecht
Zeiler K, Malmquist A (2014) Lesbian shared biological motherhood: the ethics of IVF with reception of oocytes from partner. Med Health Care Philos 17(3):347–355
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2020 Springer-Verlag GmbH Deutschland, ein Teil von Springer Nature
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Cutas, D., Smajdor, A. (2020). ‘Duped Fathers’, ‘Cuckoo Children’, and the Problem of Basing Fatherhood on Biology: A Philosophical Analysis. In: Beier, K., Brügge, C., Thorn, P., Wiesemann, C. (eds) Assistierte Reproduktion mit Hilfe Dritter. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-662-60298-0_11
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-662-60298-0_11
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-662-60297-3
Online ISBN: 978-3-662-60298-0
eBook Packages: Medicine (German Language)