Correspondence and Disquotation: An Essay on the Nature of TruthMarian David defends the correspondence theory of truth against the disquotational theory of truth, its current major rival. The correspondence theory asserts that truth is a philosophically rich and profound notion in need of serious explanation. Disquotationalists offer a radically deflationary account inspired by Tarski and propagated by Quine and others. They reject the correspondence theory, insist truth is anemic, and advance an "anti-theory" of truth that is essentially a collection of platitudes: "Snow is white" is true if and only if snow is white; "Grass is green" is true if and only if grass is green. According to disquotationalists the only profound insight about truth is that it lacks profundity. David contrasts the correspondence theory with disquotationalism and then develops the latter position in rich detail--more than has been available in previous literature--to show its faults. He demonstrates that disquotationalism is not a tenable theory of truth, as it has too many absurd consequences. |
Common terms and phrases
account of truth belief-truth biconditional claim committed conjunction contain correspondence definition correspondence theory D₁ declarative defined definiens definition of sentence-truth definition of truth deflationary deflationism deflationist disjunction disquotation definition disquotational theory disquotationalism disquotationalist dummy symbol explained expression fact formulas grammatical idea identical ideology infinite intuition language of thought liar paradox logical M-sentence Mentalese sentences notation notion of truth object ontological open sentence physicalist proposal propositions public idiolect quantifier question Quine quotation name reference representation relation representation theory representational content represents restriction s₁ s₂ schema semantic sense sentence is true sentence Snow sentence tokens sentence types singular terms Snow is white speaker specified structure substantive substituends substitution class substitutional quantification synonymy syntactic T)-schema Tarski tences theorist theory of sentence-truth theory of truth thesis tion translation true iff true or false truth and falsehood truth conditions truth definitions truth for sentences truth predicate understand