Abstract
Perhaps the hottest topic in the philosophy of chemistry is that of the relationship between chemistry and physics. The problem finds one of its main manifestations in the debate about the nature of molecular structure, given by the spatial arrangement of the nuclei in a molecule. The traditional strategy to address the problem is to consider chemical cases that challenge the definition of molecular structure in quantum–mechanical terms. Instead of taking that top-down strategy, in this paper we face the problem of the reduction of molecular structure to quantum mechanics from a bottom-up perspective: our aim is to show how the theoretical peculiarities of quantum mechanics stand against the possibility of molecular structure, defined in terms of the spatial relations of the nuclei conceived as individual localized objects. We will argue that, according to the theory, quantum “particles” are not individuals that can be identified as different from others and that can be reidentified through time; therefore, they do not have the ontological stability necessary to maintain the relations that can lead to a spatially definite system with an identifiable shape. On the other hand, although quantum chemists use the resources supplied by quantum mechanics with successful results, this does no mean reduction: their “approximations” add certain assumptions that are not justified in the context of quantum mechanics or are even inconsistent with the very formal structure of the theory.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Amann, A.: Must a molecule have a shape? S. Afr. J. Chem. 45, 29–38 (1992)
Ardenghi, J.S., Castagnino, M., Lombardi, O.: Quantum mechanics: modal interpretation and Galilean transformations. Found. Phys. 39, 1023–1045 (2009)
Atkins, P., de Paula, J.: Physical Chemistry. Oxford University Press, Oxford (2010)
Bader, R.: Atoms in Molecules: A Quantum Theory. Oxford University Press, Oxford (1994)
Ballentine, L.: Quantum Mechanics: A Modern Development. World Scientific, Singapore (1998)
Berlin, Y.A., Burin, A.L., Goldanskii, V.V.: The Hund paradox and stabilization of molecular chiral states. Zeitschrift für Physik D 37, 333–339 (1996)
Bernoulli, J.: Ars Conjectandi, Opus Posthumum. Accedit Tractatus de Seriebus Infinitis, et Epistola Gallice Scripta de Ludo Pilae Reticularis. Thurneysen, Basel (1713)
Bishop, R.: Patching physics and chemistry together. Philos. Sci. 72, 716–722 (2005)
Bishop, R., Atmanspacher, H.: Contextual emergence in the description of properties. Found. Phys. 36, 1753–1777 (2006)
Brading, K., Castellani, E.: Symmetries and invariances in classical physics. In: Butterfield, J., Earman, J. (eds.) Philosophy of Physics. Part B. Elsevier, Amsterdam (2007)
Bruer, J.T.: The classical limit of quantum theory. Synthese 50, 167–212 (1982)
Bub, J.: Interpreting the Quantum World. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1997)
Dirac, P.A.M.: The Principles of Quantum Mechanics. Clarendon Press, Oxford (1930)
Einstein, A., Podolsky, B., Rosen, N.: Can quantum-mechanical description of physical reality be considered complete? Phys. Rev. 47, 777–780 (1935)
French, S., Krause, D.: Identity in Physics: A Historical, Philosophical and Formal Analysis. Oxford University Press, Oxford (2006)
Heisenberg, W.: The Physical Principles of the Quantum Theory. University of Chicago Press, Chicago (1930)
Hendry, R.F.: Models and approximations in quantum chemistry. In: Shanks, N. (ed.) Idealization in contemporary physics. Amsterdam-Atlanta, Rodopi (1998)
Hendry, R.F.: The physicists, the chemists, and the pragmatics of explanation. Philos. Sci. 71, 1048–1059 (2004)
Hendry, R.F.: Is there downward causation in chemistry? In: Baird, D., McIntyre, L., Scerri, E. (eds.) Philosophy of Chemistry: Synthesis of a New Discipline. Springer, Berlin (2006)
Hendry, R.F.: Two conceptions of the chemical bond. Philos. Sci. 75, 909–920 (2008)
Hendry, R.F.: Ontological reduction and molecular structure. Stud. Hist. Philos. Modern Phys. 41, 183–191 (2010)
Hettema, H.: Reducing Chemistry to Physics. Limits, Models, Consecuences. University of Groningen, Groningen (2012)
Hund, F.: Zur Deutung der Molekelspektren. III. Zeitschrift für Physik 43, 805–826 (1927)
Kant, I.: Gesammelte Schriften. Berlin: Herausgegeben von der Preußischen Akademie der Wissenschaften (Bde. 1–22), der Deutschen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin (Bd. 23), und der Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen (Bde. 24, 25, 27–29) (1902)
Kochen, S., Specker, E.: The problem of hidden variables in quantum mechanics. J. Math. Mech. 17, 59–87 (1967)
Lévy-Leblond, J.M.: Galilei group and nonrelativistic quantum mechanics. J. Math. Phys. 4, 776–788 (1963)
Lombardi, O.: The ontological autonomy of the chemical world: facing the criticisms. In: Scerri, E., McIntyre, L. (eds.) Philosophy of Chemistry: Growth of a New Discipline (Boston Studies in the Philosophy and History of Science). Springer, Dordrecht (2014)
Lombardi, O., Castagnino, M.: Matters are not so clear on the physical side. Found. Chem. 12, 159–166 (2010)
Lombardi, O., Labarca, M.: The ontological autonomy of the chemical world. Found. Chem. 7, 125–148 (2005)
Lombardi, O., Labarca, M.: The ontological autonomy of the chemical world: a response to Needham. Found. Chem. 8, 81–92 (2006)
Nozick, R.: Invariances: The Structure of the Objective World. Harvard University Press, Harvard (2001)
Primas, H.: Chemistry, Quantum Mechanics and Reductionism. Springer, Berlin (1983)
Primas, H.: Hierarchic quantum descriptions and their associated ontologies. In: Laurikainen, K.V., Montonen, C., Sunnarborg, K. (eds.) Symposium on the Foundations of Modern Physics 1994. Editions Frontières, Gif-sur-Yvette (1994)
Primas, H.: Emergence in exact natural sciences. Acta Polytech. Scand. 91, 83–98 (1998)
Rohrlich, F.: The logic of reduction: the case of gravitation. Found. Phys. 19, 1151–1170 (1989)
Scerri, E.R.: Editorial 37. Found. Chem. 13, 1–7 (2011)
Scerri, E.R.: Philosophy of chemistry: where has it been and where is it going. In: Llored, J.-P. (ed.) The Philosophy of Chemistry: Practices, Methodologies, and Concepts. Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Newcastle (2013)
Sutcliffe, B.T., Wolley, R.G.: A comment on Editorial 37. Found. Chem. 13, 93–95 (2011)
Sutcliffe, B.T., Wolley, R.G.: Atoms and molecules in classical chemistry and quantum mechanics. In: Hendry, R.F., Woody, A. (eds.) Handbook of Philosophy of Science. Philosophy of Chemistry, vol. 6. Elsevier, Oxford (2012)
Trost, J., Hornberger, K.: Hund’s paradox and the collisional stabilization of chiral molecules. Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 023202 (2009)
Von Neumann, J.: Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik. Springer, Heidelberg (1932)
Wolff, Ch. (1728). Philosophia Rationalis Sive Logica. Reprint of the 1740 edition with introduction, notes and index by École, J. (ed.). New York: Georg Olms (1980)
Woolley, R.G.: Must a molecule have a shape? J. Am. Chem. Soc. 100, 1073–1078 (1978)
Woolley, R.G.: Natural optical activity and the molecular hypothesis. Struct. Bond. 52, 1–35 (1982)
Wolley, R.G.: Is there a quantum definition of a molecule? J. Math. Chem. 23, 3–12 (1998)
Woolley, R.G., Sutcliffe, B.T.: Molecular structure and the Born–Oppenheimer approximation. Chem. Phys. Lett. 45, 393–398 (1977)
Zurek, W.H.: Decoherence and the transition from quantum to classical. Phys. Today 44, 36–44 (1991)
Zurek, W.H.: Decoherence, einselection, and the quantum origins of the classical. Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 715–776 (2003)
Acknowledgements
Funding was provided by Templeton Foundation (Grant No. ID-57919), Agencia Nacional de Promoción Científica y Tecnológica (Grant No. PICT-2812).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
González, J.C.M., Fortin, S. & Lombardi, O. Why molecular structure cannot be strictly reduced to quantum mechanics. Found Chem 21, 31–45 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10698-018-9310-2
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10698-018-9310-2