Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-hfldf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-26T20:47:33.264Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Can Health Care Rationing Ever Be Rational?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2021

David A. Gruenewald
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Mr. M. was a 77-year-old decisionally incapacitated long-term nursing home resident with chronic schizophrenia who was admitted to the hospital with a bacterial pneumonia. His past medical history was notable for deteriorating functional status over the past 2-3 years, urinary retention requiring chronic indwelling bladder catheterization, and two recent hospitalizations for urinary tract infections leading to sepsis. He developed respiratory failure soon after admission and was intubated and placed on mechanical ventilation. Follow-up studies suggested worsening pneumonia and acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), as well as worsening kidney function.

Type
Symposium
Information
Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics , Volume 40 , Issue 1 , Spring 2012 , pp. 17 - 25
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

McCullough, D., “Grand Rounds: Slow Medicine,” Dartmouth Medicine Magazine 32, no. 3 (Spring 2008), available at <http://dartmed.dartmouth.edu/spring08/html/grand_rounds.php> (last visited November 16, 2011).Google Scholar
Owen-Smith, A. Coast, J. Donovan, J., “‘I Can See Where They're Coming From, But When You're on the End of It … You Just Want to Get the Money and the Drug’: Explaining Reactions to Explicit Healthcare Rationing,” Social Science and Medicine 68, no. 11 (2009): 1935–1942; Mechanic, D., “The Rise and Fall of Managed Care,” Journal of Health and Social Behavior 45, Supp. (2004): 76–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Greene, J., “Who Will Get Care?” Trustee 61, no. 9 (2008): 8–11.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Altman, D., “Simple Arithmetic,” Pulling It Together, no. 24, September 15, 2009, available at <http://www.kff.org/pullingittogether/091509_altman.cfm> (last visited November 16, 2011).Google Scholar
See Owen-Smith, et al Mechanic, , supra note 2; Callahan, D., “Cost Control: Time to Get Serious,” New England Journal of Medicine 361, no. 7 (August 13, 2009): E10.Google Scholar
See Mechanic, , supra note 2.Google Scholar
Barry, P., “Health Care Reform: The Assault on Truth,” AARP Bulletin 50, no. 7 (September 2009): 12–16.Google Scholar
See Mechanic, , supra note 2.Google Scholar
Callahan, D., “Symbols, Rationality, and Justice: Rationing Health Care,” American Journal of Law & Medicine 18, nos. 1 and 2 (1992): 1–13; Jecker, N. S. Pearlman, R. A., “Ethical Constraints on Rationing Medical Care by Age,” Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 37, no. 11 (1989): 1067–1075.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Greene, , supra note 3.Google Scholar
Trotochaud, K., “Ethical Issues and Access to Healthcare,” Journal of Infusion Nursing 29, no. 3 (2006): 165–170.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Callahan, , supra note 10; Jecker, N. S. Pearlman, R. A., “An Ethical Framework for Rationing Health Care,” Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 17, no. 1 (1992): 79–96.Google Scholar
See Callahan, , supra note 10.Google Scholar
Callahan, D., Setting Limits (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1987): At 23.Google Scholar
Productivity Commission, Economic Implications of an Ageing Australia, April 12, 2005, at 148, 155, available at <http://www.pc.gov.au/projects/study/ageing/docs/finalreport> (last visited November 16, 2011).+(last+visited+November+16,+2011).>Google Scholar
ter Meulen, R., “Are There Limits to Solidarity with the Elderly?” Hastings Center Report 24, no. 5 (1994): 36–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clarke, C. M., “Rationing Scarce Life-Sustaining Resources on the Basis of Age,” Journal of Advanced Nursing 35, no. 5 (2001): 799–804.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Callahan, , supra note 15, at 118.Google Scholar
Giordano, S., “Respect for Equality and the Treatment of the Elderly: Declarations of Human Rights and Age-Based Rationing,” Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 14, no. 1 (2005): 83–92; Evans, J. G., “The Rationing Debate: Rationing Health Care by Age: The Case Against,” BMJ 314, no. 7083 (March 15, 1997): 822.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Daniels, N., Editorial, “Accountability for Reasonableness: Establishing a Fair Process for Priority Setting Is Easier Than Agreeing on Principles,” BMJ 321, no. 7272 (November 25, 2000): 1300–1301.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Fisher, E. S., Editorial, “More Medicine Is Not Better Medicine,” New York Times, December 1, 2003.Google Scholar
McKinney, M., Editorial, “Where You Live = How You Die,” Modern Healthcare 40, no. 47 (2010): 6–8.Google Scholar
Fisher, E. S., Editorial, “Medical Care – Is More Always Better?” New England Journal of Medicine 349, no. 17 (2003): 1665–1667.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Altman, D., “The ‘Third School’ for Controlling Health Care Costs?” Pulling It Together, no. 27 (October 23, 2009), available at <http://www.kff.org/pullingittogether/102909_altman.cfm> (last visited November, 2011).Google Scholar
Gould, S. D. Baum, N. M. Editorial, , “Where Are We in the Rationing Debate? Improved Tools and Public Participation Can Inform Fair Systems,” BMJ 337, no. 7675 (October 18, 2008): 883–884.Google Scholar
Gawande, A., “The Cost Conundrum: What a Texas Town Can Teach Us about Health Care,” New Yorker, June 1, 2009.Google Scholar
Weinstein, M. C. Skinner, J. A., “Comparative Effectiveness and Health Care Spending – Implications for Reform,” New England Journal of Medicine 362, no. 5 (2010): 460–465.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
See Gawande, , supra note 28.Google Scholar
Kilo, C. M. Larson, E. B. Editorial, , “Exploring the Harmful Effects of Health Care,” JAMA 302, no. 1 (2009): 89–91; see Fisher, , supra note 25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Gawande, , supra note 28; id. (Kilo and Larson); Donaldson, C. Bate, A. Brambleby, P. Waldner, H., “Moving Forward on Rationing: An Economic View,” BMJ 337, no. 7675 (October 18, 2008): 905–906.Google Scholar
See Kilo, Larson, , supra note 32.Google Scholar
See Altman, , supra note 26.Google Scholar
Rittenhouse, D. R. Shortell, S. M. Fisher, E. S., “Perspective: Primary Care and Accountable Care – Two Essential Elements of Delivery-System Reform,” New England Journal of Medicine 361, no. 24 (2009): 2301–2303.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
See Gould, Baum, , supra note 27.Google Scholar
Strech, D. Persad, G. Marckmann, G. Danis, M., “Are Physicians Willing to Ration Health Care? Conflicting Findings in a Systematic Review of Survey Research,” Health Policy 90, no. 2 (2009): 113–124.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Gould, Baum, , supra note 27.Google Scholar
See Giordano, , supra note 20; see Evans, , supra note 20.Google Scholar
See McCullough, , supra note 1.Google Scholar
Feldstein, M., Editorial, “Obama's Plan Isn't the Answer,” Washington Post, July 28, 2009.Google Scholar
Somogyi-Zalud, E. Zhong, Z. Hamel, M. B. Lynn, J., “The Use of Life-Sustaining Treatments in Hospitalized Persons Aged 80 and Older,” Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 50, no. 5 (2002): 930–934.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pear, R., “Obama Returns to End-of-Life Plan that Caused Stir,” New York Times, December 25, 2010.Google Scholar
Detering, K. M. Hancock, A. D. Reade, M. C. Silvester, W., “The Impact of Advance Care Planning on End of Life Care in Elderly Patients: Randomised Controlled Trial,” BMJ 340, no. 7751 (2010): c1345; id. (Pear).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wright, A. A. Zhang, B. Ray, A. Mack, J. W. Trice, E. Balboni, T. Mitchell, S. L. Jackson, V. A. Block, S. D. Maciejewski, P. K. Prigerson, H. G., “Associations between End-of-Life Discussions, Patient Mental Health, Medical Care Near Death, and Caregiver Bereavement Adjustment,” JAMA 300, no. 14 (2008): 1665–1673; Zhang, B. Wright, A. A. Huskamp, H. A. Nilsson, M. E. Maciejewski, M. L. Earle, C. C. Block, S. D. Maciejewski, P. K. Prigerson, H. G., “Health Care Costs in the Last Week of Life: Associations with End-of-Life Conversations,” Archives of Internal Medicine 169, no. 5 (2009): 480–488.Google Scholar
Goldstein, N. E. Back, A. L. Morrison, R. S., “Titrating Guidance: A Model to Guide Physicians in Assisting Patients and Family Members Who Are Facing Complex Decisions,” Archives of Internal Medicine 168, no. 16 (2008): 1733–1739.Google Scholar
Id.; Chapman, G. B. Elstein, A. S., “Cognitive Processes and Biases in Medical Decision Making,” in Chapman, G. B. Sonnenberg, F. A., eds., Decision Making in Health Care: Theory, Psychology, and Applications (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2000): At 183–210.Google Scholar
See Goldstein, et al., supra note 48; Sudore, R. L. Fried, T. R., “Redefining the ‘Planning’ in Advance Care Planning: Preparing for End-of-Life Decision Making,” Annals of Internal Medicine 153, no. 4 (2010): 256–261.Google Scholar
Hanson, J. L. Editorial, , “Shared Decision Making: Have We Missed the Obvious?” Archives of Internal Medicine 168, no. 13 (2008): 1368–1370.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Turk-Charles, S. Meyerowitz, B. E. Gatz, M., “Age Differences in Information-Seeking among Cancer Patients,” International Journal of Aging and Human Development 45, no. 2 (1997): 85–98; Jenkins, V. Fallowfield, L. Saul, J., “Information Needs of Patients with Cancer: Results from a Large Study in UK Cancer Centres,” British Journal of Cancer 84, no. 1 (2001): 48–51; Chouliara, Z. Kearney, N. Stott, D. Molassiotis, A. Miller, M., “Perceptions of Older People with Cancer of Information, Decision Making and Treatment: A Systematic Review of Selected Literature,” Annals of Oncology 15, no. 11 (2004): 1596–1602.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See McKinney, , supra note 24.Google Scholar
See Goldstein, et al., supra note 48.Google Scholar
See McCullough, , supra note 1.Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
Callahan, D., “Controlling the Costs of Health Care for the Elderly – Fair Means and Foul,” New England Journal of Medicine 335, no. 10 (1996): 744–746.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Somogyi-Zalud, et al., supra note 44.Google Scholar