Abstract
In March of 2012, following a robust activist campaign, Arysta LifeScience withdrew the soil fumigant methyl iodide from the US market, just a little over a year after it had finally been registered for use in California. As a major part of the campaign against registration of the chemical, over 53,000 people, ostensibly acting as citizens rather than consumers, wrote public comments contesting the use of the chemical for its high toxicity. Although these comments had marginal impact on the outcome of the case, these comments are of interest for what they say about public action at a time when efforts to address food and agricultural issues have been dominated by “voting with your fork.” Based on a qualitative textual analysis of approximately 3500 representative comments made available to us, we show that many of those taking action did not abandon consumer subjectivities associated with neoliberal governmentality. By threatening “personal boycotts,” some were acting in their capacity as individual consumers; in invoking their own and their children’s health many more were also acting on behalf of consumers, despite that the chemical in question is applied before strawberries are planted and thus leaves no residues. The emphasis that letter writers gave to their own bodies reinforces the idea that some bodies count more than others and thus reveals a biopolitical sorting. Having consumer lives matter is consequential in light of evidence that consumer concern about pesticides has historically led to formulations and regulations more protective of consumers than workers and neighbors.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
This is not to say that neoliberal governmentality is not present in this latter aspect, as neoliberal governmentality is also about care of the self. But that is not the primary reason that voting with your fork has been accused of being neoliberal.
This critique has generated a counter-critique. Following in the footsteps of Gibson-Graham (2006), some argue that voting with your dollar and others acts of consumer agency must be “read for difference.” By this, they mean that the neoliberalism critique is totalizing and self-fulfilling in ways that foreclose possibilities of transforming food systems (Harris 2009).
While NVivo was highly useful to identify and compile exemplary content, we found it unsuitable for quantitative analysis given the format of the data provided. All comments, that is, were provided to us in one 3700 page PDF file, making several of NVivo’s functions virtually unusable on an ordinary laptop, especially for tabulating individual comments. Therefore, except for the word frequency count, the quantitative analysis was done ex post facto using an Excel spreadsheet to tabulate the occurrence of key themes in relation to individual comments. For these purposes, we sampled approximately one-half of the individual comments. We report this analysis with percentages rather than numbers in recognition that numbers give an impression of exactitude that is not generally possible when interpreting textual data.
Abbreviations
- CEQA:
-
California Environmental Quality Act
- CUE:
-
Critical use exemption
- DPR:
-
California Department of Pesticide Regulation
- USEPA:
-
United States Environmental Protection Agency
References
Alkon, A.H. 2014. Food justice and the challenge to neoliberalism. Gastronomica: The Journal of Food and Culture 14(2): 27–40.
Allen, P. 2004. Together at the table: Sustainability and sustenance in the American agrifood system. State College, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press.
Allen, P. 2008. Mining for justice in the food system: Perceptions, practices, and possibilities. Agriculture and Human Values 25(2): 157–161.
Allen, P., M. FitzSimmons, M. Goodman, and K. Warner. 2003. Shifting plates in the agrifood landscape: The tectonics of alternative agrifood initiatives in California. Journal of Rural Studies 19(1): 61–75.
Allen, P., and C. Sachs. 1993. Sustainable agriculture in the United States: Engagements, silences, and possibilities for transformation. In Food for the future, ed. Patricia Allen, 139–167. New York: Wiley.
Althusser, L. 1971. Lenin and philosophy and other essays. New York: Monthly Review Press.
Arnould, E.J. 2007. Should consumer citizens escape the market? The Annals the American Academy of Political and Social Science 611(1): 96–111.
Bardacke, F. 2012. Trampling out the vintage: Cesar Chavez and the two souls of the United Farm Workers. New York: Verso Books.
Bassett, T.J. 2010. Slim pickings: Fairtrade cotton in west Africa. Geoforum 41(1): 44–55.
Bauer, M., and M. Ramirez. 2010. Injustice on our plates: Immigrant women in the US Food industry. Montgomery, AL: Southern Poverty Law Center. http://www.splcenter.org/sites/default/files/downloads/publication/Injustice_on_Our_Plates.pdf. Accessed 21 Feb 2015.
Besky, S. 2013. The Darjeeling distinction: Labor and justice on fair-trade tea plantations in India. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Besky, S., and S. Brown. 2015. Looking for work: The place of labor in food studies. Labor: Working Class History of the Americas 12(1–2): 19–43.
Bolda, M., L. Tourte, K. Klonsky, and R. L. De Moura. 2010. Sample costs to produce strawberries, Central Coast region. David, CA: UC Cooperative Extension. http://coststudies.ucdavis.edu/current.php. Accessed 4 April 2014.
Brown, S. 2013. One hundred years of labor control: Violence, militancy, and the fairtrade banana commodity chain in Colombia. Environment and Planning A 45(11): 2572–2591.
Brown, S., and C. Getz. 2008a. Privatizing farm worker justice: Regulating labor through voluntary certification and labeling. Geoforum 39(3): 1184–1196.
Brown, S., and C. Getz. 2008b. Towards domestic fair trade? Farm labor, food localism, and the ‘family scale’ farm. GeoJournal 73: 11–22.
California Department of Food and Agriculture. 2012. California agricultural production statistics: Fruit and nut crops. Sacramento, CA: CDFA. http://www.cdfa.ca.gov/statistics/. Accessed 16 March 2014.
California Strawberry Commission. n.d. About strawberries. Watsonville, CA: California Strawberry Commission. http://www.californiastrawberries.com/about_strawberries%20. Accessed 24 Nov 2014.
Christensen, H. S. 2011. Political activities on the internet: Slacktivism or political participation by other means? First Monday 16(2). doi:10.5210/fm.v16i2.3336.
Clarke, N., C. Barnett, P. Cloke, and A. Malpass. 2007. The political rationalities of fair-trade consumption in the United Kingdom. Politics & Society 35(4): 583–607.
Dean, M. 1999. Governmentality: Power and rule in modern society. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Department of Pesticide Regulation. 2010a. Methyl iodide: Frequently asked questions. State of California Department of Pesticide Regulation. Sacramento, CA: DPR. http://www.cdpr.ca.gov/docs/registration/mei_pdfs/mei_faqs.pdf. Accessed 13 March 2015.
Department of Pesticide Regulation. 2010b. Report of the scientific review committee on methyl iodide to the department of pesticide regulation State of California Department of Pesticide Regulation. Sacramento, CA: DPR. http://www.cdpr.ca.gov/docs/risk/mei/peer_review_report.pdf. Accessed 13 March 2015.
Dolan, C.S. 2010. Virtual moralities: The mainstreaming of fairtrade in Kenyan tea fields. Geoforum 41(1): 33–43.
DuPuis, E.M. 2000. Not in my body: rBGH and the rise of organic milk. Agriculture and Human Values 17(3): 285–295.
DuPuis, E.M., and B.J. Gareau. 2009. From public to private global environmental governance: Lessons from the Montreal protocol’s stalled methyl bromide phase-out. Environment and Planning A 41(10): 2305–2323.
Foucault, M. 1985. History of sexuality, an introduction. New York: Vintage.
Foucault, M. 1997. “Society must be defended”: Lectures at the College de France, 1975–1976. New York: Picador.
Foucault, M. 2007. Security, territory, population: Lectures at the College de France 1977–1978. New York: Picador.
Freidberg, S. 2003. Cleaning up down south: Supermarkets, ethical trade, and African horticulture. Journal of Social and Cultural Geography 4(1): 27–42.
Fridell, G. 2007. Fair trade coffee: The prospects and pitfalls of market-driven social justice. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Friedman, M. 1996. A positive approach to organized consumer action: The “buycott” as an alternative to the boycott. Journal of Consumer Policy 19(4): 439–451.
Froines, J., S. Kegley, T. Malloy, and S. Kobylewski. 2013. Risk and decision: Evaluating pesticide approval in California: Review of the methyl iodide registration process. Los Angeles, CA: Sustainable Technology and Policy Program, UCLA. http://www.stpp.ucla.edu/node/474. Accessed 2 July 2014.
Ganz, M. 2004. Why David sometimes wins: Strategic capacity in social movements. In Rethinking social movements: Structure, meaning, and emotion, ed. Jeff Goodwin, and James M. Jasper, 177–198. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
García, M. 2012. From the jaws of victory: The triumph and tragedy of Cesar Chavez and the farm worker movement. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Gareau, B.J. 2008. Dangerous holes in global environmental governance: The roles of neoliberal discourse, science, and California agriculture in the Montreal protocol. Antipode 40(1): 102–130.
Getz, C., S. Brown, and A. Shreck. 2008. Class politics and agricultural exceptionalism in California’s organic agriculture movement. Politics & Society 36(4): 478–507.
Gibson-Graham, J.K. 2006. A postcapitalist politics. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Gilson, E. 2014. Vote with your fork? Responsibility for food justice. Social Philosophy Today 30: 113–130.
Goodman, M.K. 2004. Reading fair trade: Political ecological imaginary and the moral economy of fair trade foods. Political Geography 23(7): 891–915.
Guthman, J. 2003a. Eating risk: The politics of labeling transgenic foods. In Remaking the world: Genetic engineering and its discontents, ed. Rachel Schurman, and Dennis Takahashi-Kelso, 130–151. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Guthman, J. 2003b. Fast food/organic food: Reflexive tastes and the making of ‘yuppie chow’. Journal of Social and Cultural Geography 4(1): 43–56.
Guthman, J. 2004. Agrarian dreams: The paradox of organic farming in California. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Guthman, J. 2007. The Polanyian way? Voluntary food labels as neoliberal governance. Antipode 39(3): 456–478.
Guthman, J. 2008. Neoliberalism and the making of food politics in California. Geoforum 39(3): 1171–1183.
Guthman, J. 2011. Weighing in: Obesity, food justice, and the limits of capitalism. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Guthman, J., and S. Brown. in press. Midas’ not-so-golden touch: On the demise of methyl iodide as a soil fumigant in California. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning.
Harris, E. 2009. Neoliberal subjectivities or a politics of the possible? Reading for difference in alternative food networks. Area 41(1): 55–63.
Harrison, J.L. 2006. ‘Accidents’ and invisibilities: Scaled discourse and the naturalization of regulatory neglect in California’s pesticide drift conflict. Political Geography 25(5): 506–529.
Harrison, J.L. 2008a. Lessons learned from pesticide drift: A call to bring production agriculture, farm labor, and social justice back into agrifood research and activism. Agriculture and Human Values 25(2): 163–167.
Harrison, J.L. 2008b. Abandoned bodies and spaces of sacrifice: Pesticide drift activism and the contestation of neoliberal environmental politics in California. Geoforum 30: 1197–1214.
Harrison, J.L. 2011. Pesticide drift and the pursuit of environmental justice. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Jaffee, D. 2012. Weak coffee: Certification and co-optation in the fair trade movement. Social Problems 59(1): 94–116.
Jayaraman, S. 2012. The hands that feed us: Challenges and opportunities for worker along the food chain. Food Chain Workers’ Alliance. http://foodchainworkers.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/Hands-That-Feed-Us-Report.pdf. Accessed 17 Feb 2015.
Johnston, J. 2008. The citizen-consumer hybrid: Ideological tensions and the case of Whole Foods market. Theory and Society 37: 229–270.
Jubas, K. 2007. Conceptual con/fusion in democratic societies understandings and limitations of consumer-citizenship. Journal of Consumer Culture 7(2): 231–254.
Lavin, C. 2009. Pollanated politics, or, the neoliberal’s dilemma. Politics and Culture 2(2). http://politicsandculture.org/2009/11/03/chad-lavin-pollanated-politics-or-theneoliberal%E2%80%99s-dilemma/.
Lim, L. O., and R. R. Nu-May. 2010. Methyl iodide (iodomethane): Risk characterization document for inhalation exposure, volume1, health risk assessment. Sacramento, CA: DPR. http://www.cdpr.ca.gov/docs/risk/mei/mei_vol1_hra_final.pdf. Accessed 26 Dec 2011.
Liu, Y. and D. Apollan. 2011. The color of food. Applied Research Center. http://foodchainworkers.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/Color-of-Food_021611_F.pdf. Accessed 20 Feb 2015.
Minkoff-Zern, L.-A. 2014. Challenging the agrarian imaginary: Farmworker-led food movements and the potential for farm labor justice Human Geography 7(1). http://www.hugeog.com/index.php/component/content/article?id=303:v7n1-minkoffzern.
Mitchell, D. 2007. Work, struggle, death, and geographies of justice: The transformation of landscape in and beyond California’s Imperial Valley. Landscape Research 32(5): 559–577.
Monterey County Herald. 2010. Letters: Editorial about methyl iodide missing point. Monterey County Herald. http://www.montereyherald.com/opinion/20101217/letters-editorial-about-methyl-iodide-missing-key-point. Accessed 26 May 2015.
Neilson, L.A. 2010. Boycott or buycott? Understanding political consumerism. Journal of Consumer Behaviour 9(3): 214–227.
Pulido, L. 1996. Environmentalism and economic justice: Two Chicano struggles in the Southwest. Tuscon, AZ: University of Arizona.
Raynolds, L. 2000. Re-embedding global agriculture: The international organic and fair trade movements. Agriculture and Human Values 17(3): 297–309.
Renard, M.-C. 2003. Fair trade: Quality, market and conventions. Journal of Rural Studies 19(1): 87–96.
Rose, N. 1999. Powers of freedom: Reframing political thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Saxton, D.I. 2015. Strawberry fields as extreme environments: The ecobiopolitics of farmworker health. Medical Anthropology 34(2): 166–183.
Scammell, M. 2000. The internet and civic engagement: The age of the citizen-consumer. Political Communication 17(4): 351–355.
Shreck, A. 2005. Resistance, redistribution, and power in the fair trade banana initiative. Agriculture and Human Values 22(1): 17–29.
Shreck, A., C. Getz, and G. Feenstra. 2006. Social sustainability, farm labor, and organic agriculture: Findings from an exploratory analysis. Agriculture and Human Values 23(4): 439–449.
Soper, K. 2004. Rethinking the “good life”: The consumer as citizen. Capitalism Nature Socialism 15(3): 111–116.
Starkman, N. 2010. Strawberry show down: No methyl iodide with my shortcake, please. Civil Eats. http://civileats.com/2010/05/20/strawberry-show-down-no-methyl-iodide-with-my-shortcake-please/. Accessed 26 May 2015.
Szasz, A. 2007. Shopping our way to safety: How we changed from protecting the environment to protecting ourselves. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
US EPA. n.d. Critical use exemption information. Washington, DC: United States Environmental Protection Agency. http://www.epa.gov/ozone/mbr/cueinfo.html. Accessed 24 Nov 2014.
Wells, M. 1996. Strawberry fields: Politics, class, and work in California agriculture. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Wilson, B. 2013. Delivering the goods: Fair trade, solidarity, and the moral economy of the coffee contract in Nicaragua. Human Organization 72(3): 177–187.
Wilson, B.R., and J. Curnow. 2013. Solidarity™: Student activism, affective labor, and the fair trade campaign in the United States. Antipode 45(3): 565–583.
Wright, A. 2005. The death of Ramón González: The modern agricultural dilemma. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
Ziegler, C. 2007. Favored flowers: Culture and economy in a global system. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Acknowledgments
Funding for the research contained herein was provided by the National Science Foundation, Award #s 1228478 and 1262064. We are grateful for the research assistance of Zoe Chertov and Savannah Coker, as well as the generative comments of three anonymous reviewers.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Guthman, J., Brown, S. I will never eat another strawberry again: the biopolitics of consumer-citizenship in the fight against methyl iodide in California. Agric Hum Values 33, 575–585 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-015-9626-7
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-015-9626-7