Abstract
Much research about organic foods standards and certification in the United States employs a critical political economic perspective to interrogate links between certification politics and the “conventionalization” of organic agriculture. While helpful, this literature tends towards a dualistic framework, which emphasizes conflicts between movement-oriented and agribusiness wings of the organic community but obscures deliberative processes that sustain the organic market as an alternative economic space. This article develops a different approach by taking up E. Melanie DuPuis and Sean Gillon’s invitation to “begin a conversation about the everyday forms of civic engagement” involved in the governance of the organic foods market and other alternative economies (DuPuis and Gillon in Agric Hum Values 26:43, 2009). I merge DuPuis and Gillon’s analysis of civic “modes of governance” in the organic sector with a theory of deliberative discourse developed by the cultural sociologist Jeffrey Alexander. I then apply this approach to examine a 2017 dispute about whether hydroponic growing operations were eligible for certification under the National Organic Program rules. The data indicate that (1) several features of this dispute did not follow the lines of movement/agribusiness conflict emphasized by political economic research and (2) both supporters and opponents of hydroponic certification drew from a common discursive repertoire to advocate for their preferred outcomes. I argue that while this common repertoire does not prevent conflict over the organic standards, it does sustain the importance of civic—as opposed to purely economic or technical—considerations in the sector’s governance.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- NOP:
-
National Organic Program
- NOSB:
-
National Organic Standards Board
- USDA:
-
United States Department of Agriculture
References
Alexander, J.C. 2003. The meanings of social life: a cultural sociology. New York: Oxford University Press.
Alexander, J.C. 2006. The civil sphere. New York: Oxford University Press.
Alexander, J.C. 2007. On the interpretation of the civil sphere: understanding and contention in contemporary social science. The Sociological Quarterly 48 (4): 641–659.
Alexander, J.C., and P. Smith. 1993. The discourse of American civil society: a new proposal for cultural studies. Theory and Society 22 (2): 151–207.
Alkon, A.H. 2009. From value to values: sustainable consumption at farmers markets. Agriculture and Human Values 25 (4): 487–498.
Allen, P., and M. Kovach. 2000. The capitalist composition of organic: the potential of markets in fulfilling the promise of alternative agriculture. Agriculture and Human Values 17 (3): 221–232.
Anderson, C.R., W. McDonald, J. Gardiner, and S.M. McLachlan. 2014. Navigating the fault lines in civic food networks. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development 4 (3): 79–99.
Baiocchi, G. 2006. The civilizing force of social movements: corporate and liberal codes in Brazil’s public sphere. Sociological Theory 24 (4): 285–311.
Battani, M., D.R. Hall, and R. Powers. 1997. Cultures’ structures: meaning making in the public sphere. Theory and Society 26 (6): 781–812.
Blumberg, R., H. Leitner, and K.V. Cadieux. 2020. For food space: theorizing alternative food networks beyond alterity. Journal of Political Ecology 27 (1): 1–22.
Bornemann, B., and S. Weiland. 2019. New perspectives on food democracy. Politics and Governance 7 (7): 1–7.
Bruce, A. 2017. Frankenfish or fish to feed the world: scientism and biotechnology regulatory policy. Rural Sociology 82 (4): 628–663.
Buck, D., C. Getz, and J. Guthman. 1997. From farm to table: the organic vegetable commodity chain of northern California. Sociologia Ruralis 37 (1): 3–20.
Candel, J.J.L. 2022. Power to the people? Food democracy initiatives’ contributions to democratic goods.". Agriculture and Human Values 39 (4): 1477–1489.
Cohen, L. 2003. A consumers’ republic: the politics of mass consumption in postwar America. New York: Vintage.
Connor, B.T. 2012. 9/11—a new Pearl Harbor? Analogies, narratives, and meanings of 9/11 in civil society. Cultural Sociology 6 (1): 3–25.
Constance, D.H., J.Y. Choi, and D. Lara. 2012. Social dimensions of organic production and systems research. Crop Management Online. https://doi.org/10.1094/CM-2012-0429-01-RV.
DeLind, L.B. 2000. Transforming organic agriculture into industrial organic products: reconsidering national organic standards. Human Organization 59 (2): 198–208.
Dentzman, K.E., and J.R. Goldberger. 2020. Organic standards, farmers’ perceptions, and the contested case of biodegradable plastic mulch in the United States. Journal of Rural Studies 73: 203–213.
DuPuis, E.M. 2006. Civic markets: alternative value chain governance as civic engagement. Crop Management Online. https://doi.org/10.1094/CM-2006-09XX-09-RV.
DuPuis, E.M. 2015. Dangerous digestion: the politics of American dietary advice. Berkeley: University of California Press.
DuPuis, E.M., and S. Gillon. 2009. Alternative modes of governance: organic as civic engagement. Agriculture and Human Values 26 (1–2): 43–56.
Eliasoph, N., and P. Lichterman. 2003. Culture in interaction. American Journal of Sociology 108 (4): 735–794.
Emirbayer, M. 2004. The Alexander school of cultural sociology. Thesis Eleven 79 (1): 5–15.
Gershuny, G. 2016. Organic revolutionary: a memoir of the movement for real food, planetary healing, and human liberation. Lexington, KY: Joe’s Brook Press.
Gieryn, T.F. 1983. Boundary-work and the demarcation of science from non-science: strains and interests in professional ideologies of scientists. American Sociological Review 48 (6): 781–795.
Goodman, D., E.M. DuPuis, and M.K. Goodman. 2011. Alternative food networks: knowledge, practice, and politics. New York: Routledge.
Guthman, Julie. 1998. Regulating meaning, appropriating nature: the codification of California organic agriculture. Antipode 30 (2): 135–154.
Guthman, Julie. 2004a. Agrarian dreams: the paradox of organic farming in California. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Guthman, Julie. 2004b. The trouble with “organic lite” in California: a rejoinder to the “conventionalization” debate. Sociologia Ruralis 44 (3): 301–316.
Haedicke, M. 2021. Contested regulations in the organic foods sector: public administration’s challenging encounter with alternative food activism. In Administering and managing the U.S. food system: Revisiting food policy and politics, ed. A.B. Hoflund, J.C. Jones, and M.C. Pautz, 147–162. Lanham: Lexington Books.
Halweil, B. 2005. "The rise of food democracy. UN Chronicle 42 (1): 71–73.
Hassanein, N. 2003. Practising food democracy: a pragmatic politics of transformation. Journal of Rural Studies 19 (1): 77–86.
Hassanein, N. 2008. Locating food democracy: theoretical and practical ingredients. Journal of Hunger and Environmental Nutrition 3 (2–3): 286–308.
Howard, P.H. 2009. Consolidation in the North American organic food processing sector, 1997 to 2007. International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food 16 (1): 13–30.
Jacobs, R.N. 1996. Civil society and crisis: culture, discourse, and the Rodney King beating. American Journal of Sociology 101 (5): 1238–1272.
Jacobs, R.N. and S. Sobieraj. 2007. Narrative and legitimacy: U.S. Congressional debates about the nonprofit sector. Sociological Theory 25(1): 1–25.
Jaffee, D., and P. Howard. 2010. Corporate cooptation of organic and fair trade standards. Agriculture and Human Values 27 (4): 387–399.
Johnston, J., A. Biro, and N. MacKendrick. 2009. Lost in the supermarket: the corporate-organic foodscape and the struggle for food democracy. Antipode 41 (3): 509–532.
Kinchy, A.J. 2010. Anti-genetic engineering activism and scientized politics in the case of “contaminated” Mexican maize. Agriculture and Human Values 27 (4): 505–517.
Lang, T. 1999. Food policy for the 21st century: can it be both radical and reasonable? In For hunger-proof cities: sustainable urban food systems, ed. M. Koc, R. MacRae, L.J.A. Mougeot, and J. Weslh, 216–224. Ottawa: International Development Research Centre.
Lang, T., D. Barling, and M. Caraher. 2009. Food policy: integrating health, environment, and society. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lichterman, P., and N. Eliasoph. 2014. Civic action. American Journal of Sociology 120 (3): 798–863.
Lozano-Cabedo, C., and C. Gómez-Benito. 2017. A theoretical model of food citizenship for the analysis of social praxis. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 30 (1): 1–22.
Lyson, T.A. 2004. Civic agriculture: reconnecting farm, food and community. Medford: Tufts University Press.
Mansfield, B. 2004. Organic views of nature: the debate over organic certification for aquatic animals. Sociologia Ruralis 44 (2): 216–232.
Misleh, D. 2022. Moving beyond the impasse in geographies of ‘alternative’ food networks. Progress in Human Geography 46 (4): 1028–1046.
Morath, S.J. 2018. Hydroponics: the end of organic. Natural Resources and Environment 33 (1): 36–39.
National Organic Standards Board Crops Committee. 2010. Production standards for terrestrial plants in containers and enclosures. 23 January 2010. https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/NOP%20Final%20Rec%20Production%20Standards%20for%20Terrestrial%20Plants.pdf. Accessed 15 Dec 2022.
National Organic Standards Board Crops Subcommittee. 2017. Hydroponics and container-growing recommendations. 29 August 2017. https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/CSHydroponicsContainersNOPFall2017.pdf. Accessed 16 Dec 2022.
National Organic Standards Board Hearing. 2017a. Transcript: 13 April 2017. https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/TranscriptsNOSBApril2017.pdf. Accessed 15 Dec 2022.
National Organic Standards Board Hearing. 2017b. Transcript: 24 October 2017. https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/TranscriptsNOSBFall2017.pdf. Accessed 15 Dec 2022.
National Organic Standards Board Hydroponic and Aquaponic Task Force. 2016. Hydroponic and aquaponic task force report. 21 July 2016. https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/2016%20Hydroponic%20Task%20Force%20Report.PDF. Accessed 15 Dec 2022.
National Organic Standards Board Meeting. 2017a. Meeting transcript: 19 April 2017a. https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/TranscriptsNOSBApril2017a.pdf. Accessed 15 Dec 2022.
National Organic Standards Board Meeting. 2017b. Meeting transcript: 20 April 2017b. https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/TranscriptsNOSBApril2017b.pdf. Accessed 15 Dec 2022.
National Organic Standards Board Meeting. 2017c. Meeting transcript: 31 October 2017c. https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/TranscriptsNOSBFall2017c.pdf. Accessed 15 Dec 2022.
National Organic Standards Board Meeting. 2017d. Meeting transcript: 1 November 2017d. https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/TranscriptsNOSBFall2017d.pdf. Accessed 15 Dec 2022.
National Organic Standards Board Public Comment Webinar. 2017. Transcript: 26 October 2017. https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/TranscriptsNOSBFall2017.pdf. Accessed 15 Dec 2022
Nemes, G., V. Lajos, R. Reckinger, and S. Zollet. 2022. Values-based territorial food networks—benefits, challenges, and controversies. Sociologia Ruralis 63 (1): 3–19.
Obach, B.K. 2015. Organic struggle: the movement for sustainable agriculture in the United States. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Renting, H., M. Schermer, and A. Rossi. 2012. Building food democracy: exploring civic food networks and newly emerging forms of food citizenship. International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food 19 (9): 289–307.
Rosol, M. 2020. On the signfiicance of alternative economic practices: reconceptualizing alterity in alternative food networks. Economic Geography 96 (1): 52–76.
Sass, J., and J.S. Dryzek. 2014. Deliberative cultures. Political Theory 42 (1): 3–25.
Schurman, R., and W.A. Munro. 2010. Fighting for the future of food: activists versus agribusiness in the struggle over biotechnology. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Swidler, A. 1995. Cultural power and social movements. In Social movements and culture, ed. A. Swidler, 25–40. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Tocqueville, A. [1835]1969. Democracy in America. New York: Anchor Books.
Vos, T. 2000. Visions of the middle landscape: organic farming and the politics of nature. Agriculture and Human Values 17 (3): 245–256.
Wilkins, J.L. 2005. Eating right here: moving from consumer to food citizen. Agriculture and Human Values 22 (3): 269–273.
Zollet, S. 2022. Hybrid food networks and sustainability transitions: shared and contested values and practices in food relocalisation and resocialisation. Sociologia Ruralis 63 (1): 117–139.
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank participants in the University of Maine Department of Communication and Journalism Colloquium Series and two anonymous reviewers for helpful comments on earlier drafts of this paper.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Haedicke, M.A. Organic as civic engagement revisited: civic codes and deliberative strategies in the debate about hydroponic certification. Agric Hum Values 41, 9–24 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-023-10463-1
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-023-10463-1