Abstract
A probabilistic explication is offered of equipoise and uncertainty in clinical trials. In order to be useful in the justification of clinical trials, equipoise has to be interpreted in terms of overlapping probability distributions of possible treatment outcomes, rather than point estimates representing expectation values. Uncertainty about treatment outcomes is shown to be a necessary but insufficient condition for the ethical defensibility of clinical trials. Additional requirements are proposed for the nature of that uncertainty. The indecisiveness of our criteria for cautious decision-making under uncertainty creates the leeway that makes clinical trials defensible.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
R.J. Amdur C.J. Biddle (2001) ArticleTitleAn Algorithm for Evaluating the Ethics of Placebo-Controlled Trial International Journal of Cancer 96 261–269 Occurrence Handle10.1002/ijc.1026
R. Ashcroft (1999) ArticleTitleEquipoise Knowledge and Ethics in Clinical Research and Practice Bioethics 13 314–326 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-8519.00160
J.A. Chard R.J. Lilford (1998) ArticleTitleThe Use of Equipoise in Clinical Trials Social Science and Medicine 47 891–898 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0277-9536(98)00153-1
B. Djulbegovic (2001) ArticleTitleAcknowledgement of Uncertainty: A Fundamental Means to Ensure Scientific and Ethical Validity in Clinical Research Current Oncology Reports 3 389–395
Ellsberg, D. “Risk, Ambiguity, and the Savage Axioms” [1961] In Decision, Probability, and Utility. Edited by Peter Gärdenfors and Nils-Eric Sahlin. 245–269. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988
E.J. Emanuel F.G. Miller (2001) ArticleTitleThe Ethics of Placebo-Controlled Trials – A Middle Ground New England Journal of Medicine 345 915–919 Occurrence Handle10.1056/NEJM200109203451211
B. Freedman (1987) ArticleTitleEquipoise and the Ethics of Clinical Research New England Journal of Medicine 317 141–145 Occurrence Handle10.1056/NEJM198707163170304
C. Fried ( 1974) Medical Experimentation: Personal Integrity and Social Policy North Holland Amsterdam
F. Gifford (1995) ArticleTitleCommunity-Equipoise and the Ethics of Randomized Clinical Trials Bioethics 9 127–148
F. Gifford (2000) ArticleTitleFreedman’s ‘Clinical Equipoise’ and ‘Sliding-Scale All-Dimensions-Considered Equipose’ Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 25 399–426 Occurrence Handle10.1076/0360-5310(200008)25:4;1-A;FT399
S.O. Hansson (1993) Entscheidungsfindung bei Uneinigkeit der Experten Horst Zilleßen Peter C. Dienel Wendelin Strubelt (Eds) Die Modernisierung der Demokratie, Internationale Ansätze Westdeutscher Verlag Opladen 87–96
S.O. Hansson (2004) ArticleTitleWeighing Risks and Benefits Topoi 23 145–152 Occurrence Handle10.1007/s11245-004-5371-z
J.T. Karlawish J. Lantos (1997) ArticleTitleCommunity Equipoise and the Architecture of Clinical Research Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 6 385–396 Occurrence Handle10.1017/S0963180100008136
I. Levi (1980) The Enterprise of Knowledge: An Essay on Knowledge, ␣Credal Probability, and Chance The MIT Press Cambridge MA
I. Levi (, 1984) Decisions and Revisions: Philosophical Essays on Knowledge and Value Cambridge University Press Cambridge
A. Lewis et al. (2002) ArticleTitlePlacebo-Controlled Trials and the Declaration of Helsinki Lancet 359 1337–1340 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0140-6736(02)08277-6
R.J. Lilford (2003) ArticleTitleEthics of Clinical Trials from a Bayesian and Decision Analytic Perspective: Whose Equipoise Is it Anyway? BMJ 326 980–981 Occurrence Handle10.1136/bmj.326.7396.980
A.J. London (2001) ArticleTitleEquipoise and International Human-Subjects Research Bioethics 15 312–332 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-8519.00241
A.J. London J.B. Kadane (2003) ArticleTitleSham Surgery and Genuine Standards of Care: Can the Two Be Reconciled? American Journal of Bioethics 3 61–64 Occurrence Handle10.1162/152651603322614652
M. Longwood (1983) ArticleTitleSins of Omissions: The Non-Treatment of Controls in Clinical Trials, I Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volume 57 207–222
F.G. Miller D.L. Rosenstein. (2003) ArticleTitleThe Therapeutic Orientation to Clinical Trials New England Journal of Medicine 348 1383–1386 Occurrence Handle10.1056/NEJMsb030228
P.B. Miller C. Weijer. (2003) ArticleTitleRehabilitating Equipoise Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 13 93–118 Occurrence Handle10.1353/ken.2004.0008
P.B. Miller C. Weijer. (2003) ArticleTitleWill the Real Charles Fried Please Stand Up? Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 13 353–357 Occurrence Handle10.1353/ken.2004.0008
C.R. Palmer (2002) ArticleTitleEthics, Data-Dependent Designs, and the Strategy of Clinical Trials: Time to Start-Learning-As-We-Go? Statistical Methods in Medical Research 11 381–402 Occurrence Handle10.1191/0962280202sm298ra
R. Peto (1978) ArticleTitleClinical Trial Methodology Biomedicine 28 S24–S36
D.L. Sackett (2000) ArticleTitleWhy Randomized Controlled Trials Fail But Needn’t: 1. Failure to Gain ‘Coal-Face’ Commitment and to Use the Uncertainty Principle CMAJ 162 1311–1314
D.L. Sackett (2000) ArticleTitleEquipoise a Term Whose Time (If It Ever Came) Has Surely Gone CMAJ 163 835–836
S.H. Shapiro et al. (2000) ArticleTitleWhy Sackett’s Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials Fails, But Needn’t CMAJ 163 834–835
R. Temple S.S. Ellenberg (2000) ArticleTitlePlacebo-Controlled Trials and Active-Control Trials in the Evaluation of New Treatments Annals of Internal Medicine 133 455–463
R.J. Temple R. Meyer. (2003) ArticleTitleContinued Need for Placebo in Many Cases Even When There is Effective Therapy Archives of Internal Medicine 163 371–373 Occurrence Handle10.1001/archinte.163.3.371-b
R.M. Veach (2002) ArticleTitleIndifference of Subjects: An Alternative to Equipoise in Randomized Clinical Trials Social Philosophy and Policy 19 295–323 Occurrence Handle10.1017/S0265052502192120
C. Weijer et al. (2000) ArticleTitleClinical Equipoise and Not the Uncertainty Principle is the Moral Underpinning of the Randomised Controlled Trial BMJ 321 756–757 Occurrence Handle10.1136/bmj.321.7263.756
C.W. Weijer K.C. Glass (2002) ArticleTitleThe Ethics of Placebo-Controlled Trials New England Journal of Medicine 346 382–383 Occurrence Handle10.1056/NEJM200201313460522
C. Weijer P.B. Miller (2004) ArticleTitleWhen Are Research Risks Reasonable in Relation to Anticipated Benefits? Nature Medicine 10 570–573 Occurrence Handle10.1038/nm0604-570
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hansson, S.O. Uncertainty and the Ethics of Clinical Trials. Theor Med Bioeth 27, 149–167 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11017-006-0001-y
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11017-006-0001-y